Heating and Air Cond. Type and Sinusitis
Question:
I was just wondering what people have for a heating and AC source? I purposely purchased a house with forced hot water due to my allergist’s recommendation. Although in my area now forced hot air, ducts with AC built in is what builders are putting in. Has anyone lived with both types of heating sources (forced hot air vs. forced hot water) and noticed a difference in their sinusitis? Also what about the AC method?
Response:
On Fri, 09 Dec 2005 15:58:47 -0500, "sedum41" <sedum41@EMAIL protected
wrote: I was just wondering what people have for a heating and AC source? I purposely purchased a house with forced hot water due to my allergist’s recommendation. Although in my area now forced hot air, ducts with AC built in is what builders are putting in. Has anyone lived with both types of heating sources (forced hot air vs. forced hot water) and noticed a difference in their sinusitis? Also what about the AC method?
There are pros and cons of both types. With forced air, *theoretically* you can filter it but if you still have dust and mold in your room, it will blow it around and this will raise the level in the air in actual fact. In your case, I would stay where you are with what yoy have and try and optimize it. You should be fine if you have some nearly dust-free rooms, What I find myself is that in very cold werther, I am fine because the indoor heat dries (either forced air or radiator) out the mold and dust mites. I am also ok in very hot weather, because the AC dries out the mold and mites. It is in the fall and spring that I have problems. This is because indoor humidity rises and so do mold and mite populations. In those seasons, a lot of air exchange with the outdoors in needed to keep levels down. An open windows in an adjacent room is starting point. If you have active sources of pollution indoors, then you may need more outdoor air exchange even in mid-winter. This is hard to do but possible. Of course it will drastically increase heating costs…… You need to experiment to test the effects of various factors……
Response:
If you have allergy problems you can try a local bee keeper/honey producer. I have had a very bad asthmatic bronchitis and a genetic (father family) tendency to asthma and treatment with honey caps (When the water content is less than18%, workers seal each cell with a cap) helped me get over it completely. Even though my father and his mother both had asthma and got treatment, I never got to asthmatic bronchitis again. It was later found that the caps and the mixture bees produce to seal the honeycomb has antiallergenic properties. Alexandra C
Response:
In news:1134317830.999405.55190@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com, birdieb <creaproje…@yahoo.com
typed: If you have allergy problems you can try a local bee keeper/honey producer. I have had a very bad asthmatic bronchitis and a genetic (father family) tendency to asthma and treatment with honey caps (When the water content is less than18%, workers seal each cell with a cap) helped me get over it completely. Even though my father and his mother both had asthma and got treatment, I never got to asthmatic bronchitis again. It was later found that the caps and the mixture bees produce to seal the honeycomb has antiallergenic properties. Alexandra C
So are you suppost to get the cone and consume it, or just the honey? I’m confused when above you say "…treatment with honey cops…"
Response:
Don, I do have allergies to the outdoor types of mold. For me I have most allergy problems June-Sept when the weather is hot and humid. Last year we had a bad summer for outdoor mold. By monitoring a mold/pollen web site for a town next to mine the outdoor airborne mold levels were highest from May-October which corresponded closely with my symptoms. My allergist wasn’t too keen on the forced hot air as he stated most of his patients with the worst allergies had this type of heat/AC. Of course, I am basing this on conversations we had in the early 90’s when I first went for allergy testing and shots. I’m sure the technology is much better now as 15 years have passed. I’ve seen him since then but haven’t discussed heating/AC with him. For me I now think I would be better with a forced hot air that I could attach very good HEPA filters, AC, humidifiers etc. The big question is can you keep the ducts, AC, humidifier free from mold spores or can they be cleaned effectively? I was just curious if people had lived in houses with both types of heat as I’ve only lived in apartments or houses with either steam heat or forced hot water.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -On Mon, 12 Dec 2005 21:15:51 -0500, "sedum41" <sedum41@EMAIL protected
wrote: Don, I do have allergies to the outdoor types of mold. For me I have most allergy problems June-Sept when the weather is hot and humid. Last year we had a bad summer for outdoor mold. By monitoring a mold/pollen web site for a town next to mine the outdoor airborne mold levels were highest from May-October which corresponded closely with my symptoms. My allergist wasn’t too keen on the forced hot air as he stated most of his patients with the worst allergies had this type of heat/AC. Of course, I am basing this on conversations we had in the early 90’s when I first went for allergy testing and shots. I’m sure the technology is much better now as 15 years have passed. I’ve seen him since then but haven’t discussed heating/AC with him. For me I now think I would be better with a forced hot air that I could attach very good HEPA filters, AC, humidifiers etc. The big question is can you keep the ducts, AC, humidifier free from mold spores or can they be cleaned effectively? I was just curious if people had lived in houses with both types of heat as I’ve only lived in apartments or houses with either steam heat or forced hot water.
Oh I have lived in all of the above but I do not think you will get a conclusive answer. Actually I have both right now (baseboard heaters and central forced air) and switch back and forth. I really cannot stand the forced air except in very cold weather. In mild weather it seems to blow around irritating mold or gasses for whatever reason. My place is really not at all dust and mold free though – things might work better if it were. I like low-temperature baseboard heaters a lot. They are small closed-off radiators. Some authorities recommend them over other solutions.. High temperature heaters cause gasses to be given off from roasting dust. There is no doubt that well-filtered forced air can work well but I do not think it is the only solution. What if the major source of dust is locally-stirred up dust and mold within the individual rooms? Air filtering is not going to get rid of that. In a super-clean house, central filters might work well. But presumably you would have to leave the fan on all the time. Otherwise it would be off all the time if the temperature indoors and ourdoors matched. The windows would have to be closed. I prefer to be able to open the windows selectively. It is just horrendously complicated…..
Response:
Only the cap the bee puts on the cone (and the substance it produces to seal it). The caps are usually thrown away by the producer or used to make house beverages, because they want the honey to be clean of wax when they extract it from the honeycomb.
Response:
My mother used a book written by a Montana doctor called Jarvis. Unfortunately, I gave it to someone who has never returned it. It was about the uses of honey and he gave detailed description of the treatment with honey caps. As I remember (I redo the treatment from time to time) he indicated not to use a metal teaspoon, to chew the waxy caps for about 15 mins and not to drink anything after that for at least 30 mins – this keeps the antiallergic substance in place. I did it approximately 4 times a day, for a month. After the first 10 days the allergy started to subside.
Response:
On 12/13/05 6:57 AM, in article 4085r8F1968n…@individual.net, "Susan" – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -<neverm…@nomail.com
wrote: x-no-archive: yes Don Brady wrote: Oh I have lived in all of the above but I do not think you will get a conclusive answer. Actually I have both right now (baseboard heaters and central forced air) and switch back and forth. I really cannot stand the forced air except in very cold weather. In mild weather it seems to blow around irritating mold or gasses for whatever reason. My place is really not at all dust and mold free though – things might work better if it were. I like low-temperature baseboard heaters a lot. They are small closed-off radiators. Some authorities recommend them over other solutions.. High temperature heaters cause gasses to be given off from roasting dust. There is no doubt that well-filtered forced air can work well but I do not think it is the only solution. What if the major source of dust is locally-stirred up dust and mold within the individual rooms? Air filtering is not going to get rid of that. In a super-clean house, central filters might work well. But presumably you would have to leave the fan on all the time. Otherwise it would be off all the time if the temperature indoors and ourdoors matched. The windows would have to be closed. I prefer to be able to open the windows selectively. It is just horrendously complicated….. I should say that my assumption is that someone who’s going to such lengths to choose a system would already be doing what we do in my house, which is keep dust and other air pollutants to a minimum. Before relying on filters, ventilation systems, etc, hygiene has to be in place. I have wood floors with area rugs that have no furniture on top, so they can be hepa vacuumed top and bottom. Dusting is job one, and nothing visible is blowing around my house. Bedding is in allergy barriers, and there’s a big HEPA air cleaner in my bedroom.h As mentioned, it’s been really important to aggressively dust iron radiators with bottle brushes, long felt rods, etc. Susan
I agree, no matter what you do, wall to wall carpets, etc will create dust. We have eliminated these and frankly the only dust is from "self contained" units i.e. The closed display cabinets have dust all the time from deteriorating wood, I suppose. I haven’t heard anything about wallpaper allergy, except that people chewed this for the glue in Leningrad in World War Two. Anyone know about the allergic situation re wallpaper. I think Susan’s suggestion is correct – eliminate the sources of dust – carpets, etc. If you gotta have a rug, use throw rugs that can be washed. More important, its not that critical that the entire house be totally dust proof. Its the bedroom that is most important. An electric heater and a hepa filter may do the job.
Response:
If you have wood floors or wood pannels, cabinets in the bathroom/kitchen that are made of wood, etc… you might want to try a mold specialist. Sometimes the mold is not visible but its spores reach the air and one eventually inhales them. The specialist would check your house for humidity and molds. It isn’t expensive and they usually do a very good job detecting molds. There are also vaccines that can be prepared from the liquids present at the site of the infection/inflammation. I had a friend who had a recurrent infection and she went to do something like this; she called it "desensitivation". I am not in the medical field, so you have to ask a doctor what it is or find a vaccine research company (like "Pasteur" in France). The advantage is that the research lab/unit is usually in a hospital and offers several options for increasing immunity which combined give better results.
Response:
Don, Susan, Dr. Grossan – Thanks for the good discussion, pros and cons to think about. I don’t have any experience with forced hot air so it is good to hear people’s experiences. I agree that keeping the bedroom environment right is the most important thing for people with mold and dust allergies. I’ve done all the things discussed on this group including installing hardwood floors with small area rugs, keeping it clutter and dust free, using all the allergy bedding and covers for pillows, mattresses, running AC in summer and good room humidifier (with UV sterilization of the water) in winter, running a good HEPA filter year round. I know it makes a huge difference because when we travel, I am sometimes bothered with increased symptoms. In any case, I think it is a moot point as my husband and I like very much where we live. I don’t think I could readily convince him to move at this point!
Response:
sedum41 wrote:
I was just wondering what people have for a heating and AC source? I purposely purchased a house with forced hot water due to my allergist’s recommendation. Although in my area now forced hot air, ducts with AC built in is what builders are putting in. Has anyone lived with both types of heating sources (forced hot air vs. forced hot water) and noticed a difference in their sinusitis? Also what about the AC method?
If you live in an apartment, get one on the top floor with the windows facing south. Then if you live in a warm climate like CA you will rarely need the heat. If you are buying a house, make sure its at least 2 story and the bedroom is not on the ground floor, and again preferably bedroom windows facing south. AC should be OK as long as the ducts are clean. If they are new, this should not be a problem. Forced air heat can be a problem regardless, I have found. Radiator is probably better. When it is especially damp like during rainstorms, you can first heat the house up to, say, 80F then set the AC to 70F which should help drive out the humidity – or buy a dehumidifier. Never ever consider an evap cooler. Woody
Response:
On 15 Dec 2005 20:30:59 -0800, "Woody Long" <woodylon…@hotmail.com
wrote:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
sedum41 wrote: I was just wondering what people have for a heating and AC source? I purposely purchased a house with forced hot water due to my allergist’s recommendation. Although in my area now forced hot air, ducts with AC built in is what builders are putting in. Has anyone lived with both types of heating sources (forced hot air vs. forced hot water) and noticed a difference in their sinusitis? Also what about the AC method? If you live in an apartment, get one on the top floor with the windows facing south. Then if you live in a warm climate like CA you will rarely need the heat. If you are buying a house, make sure its at least 2 story and the bedroom is not on the ground floor, and again preferably bedroom windows facing south. AC should be OK as long as the ducts are clean. If they are new, this should not be a problem. Forced air heat can be a problem regardless, I have found. Radiator is probably better.
Yes low temperature portable heaters may be best. http://www.cadetco.com/show_product.php?prodid=1011 I have 4 of these. However, I find even these irritating if too close – I put them in adjacent rooms. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
When it is especially damp like during rainstorms, you can first heat the house up to, say, 80F then set the AC to 70F which should help drive out the humidity – or buy a dehumidifier. Never ever consider an evap cooler. Woody
Categories:
