Question:
And so the debate continues. This article just came out (I pulled if off either MSNBC web page or Washington Post.Com Web page) What do you all think? Relief for Asthmatics Arrives With Release of "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" an Emergency Self-Help Technique 12:17 p.m. Oct 17, 1997 Eastern NEW YORK–(BW HealthWire)–Oct. 17, 1997– Business Editors and Medical/Health Writers "The CPR of Asthma" On Oct. 7, 1997 at Medtrade in New Orleans, a medical industry trade show for medical innovations, "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic," an instructional video guide created for sufferers of asthma, was introduced to the public. Created by Andrea Weissleder, a physical therapist trained at Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, School of Physical Therapy, with 30 years of experience working with asthmatic individuals. "Breath Magic" teaches a specific breathing technique to asthmatics and their caregivers which is to be used during an attack. "Breath Magic" is essentially the CPR of asthma. The premise of the technique lies within the utilization of maximum respiratory exchange while totally controlling the inevitable PANIC response. Suffers who implement the technique have been able to arrest the progression and often abort an attack. It is an emergency care technique, not a replacement for medication. It offers the asthmatic help in crisis. Sometimes, in spite of medication, in the absence of effective medication, away from medication or medical help, while engaged in activity, asthma can persist leading to more serious respiratory compromise. The technique can be utilized anywhere easily. "It is a simple, albeit precise, method breathing which addresses the very difficult moment crisis," says Weissleder. The "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" video also teaches asthmatics and their caregivers a strategy for controlling their asthma which includes awareness training for recognizing triggers, a simple breath vigilance method and the "Breath Magic" technique. The "Breath Magic" technique has been taught to asthmatic children, adults, community and professional groups in a variety of settings. KLW Associates, Inc. is distributing the video at a price within reach of most people, less than most prescription medications. "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" is packaged with an instruction booklet and a self-help emergency card to be carried with the individual. The retail price is $24.95 plus $4.75 for shipping. For additional information and/or bio, please call Ken Weissleder at 941/346-2664. (See also: http://www.businesswire.com) Copyright 1997, Business Wire
Response:
And so the debate continues. This article just came out (I pulled if off either MSNBC web page or Washington Post.Com Web page) What do you all think?
…snipped It may be that these exercises are similar to some used by Buteyko to stop attacks, however the main thrust of Buteyko is to change the automatic breathing response so that we breath less continually. Then the attacks will never come. It doesn’t sound like the technique mentioned covers this at all. So I’d say its more than likely not based on Buteyko. Dave.
Response:
Yea, I saw this on the RC-World group and said the same thing! John Rhoades, RRT Asthma Guide for the Mining Company http://asthma.miningco.com – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And so the debate continues. This article just came out (I pulled if off either MSNBC web page or Washington Post.Com Web page) What do you all think? Relief for Asthmatics Arrives With Release of "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" an Emergency Self-Help Technique 12:17 p.m. Oct 17, 1997 Eastern NEW YORK–(BW HealthWire)–Oct. 17, 1997– Business Editors and Medical/Health Writers "The CPR of Asthma" On Oct. 7, 1997 at Medtrade in New Orleans, a medical industry trade show for medical innovations, "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic," an instructional video guide created for sufferers of asthma, was introduced to the public. Created by Andrea Weissleder, a physical therapist trained at Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, School of Physical Therapy, with 30 years of experience working with asthmatic individuals. "Breath Magic" teaches a specific breathing technique to asthmatics and their caregivers which is to be used during an attack. "Breath Magic" is essentially the CPR of asthma. The premise of the technique lies within the utilization of maximum respiratory exchange while totally controlling the inevitable PANIC response. Suffers who implement the technique have been able to arrest the progression and often abort an attack. It is an emergency care technique, not a replacement for medication. It offers the asthmatic help in crisis. Sometimes, in spite of medication, in the absence of effective medication, away from medication or medical help, while engaged in activity, asthma can persist leading to more serious respiratory compromise. The technique can be utilized anywhere easily. "It is a simple, albeit precise, method breathing which addresses the very difficult moment crisis," says Weissleder. The "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" video also teaches asthmatics and their caregivers a strategy for controlling their asthma which includes awareness training for recognizing triggers, a simple breath vigilance method and the "Breath Magic" technique. The "Breath Magic" technique has been taught to asthmatic children, adults, community and professional groups in a variety of settings. KLW Associates, Inc. is distributing the video at a price within reach of most people, less than most prescription medications. "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" is packaged with an instruction booklet and a self-help emergency card to be carried with the individual. The retail price is $24.95 plus $4.75 for shipping. For additional information and/or bio, please call Ken Weissleder at 941/346-2664. (See also: http://www.businesswire.com) Copyright 1997, Business Wire
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Yea, I saw this on the RC-World group and said the same thing! John Rhoades, RRT Asthma Guide for the Mining Company http://asthma.miningco.com And so the debate continues. This article just came out (I pulled if off either MSNBC web page or Washington Post.Com Web page) What do you all think? Relief for Asthmatics Arrives With Release of "Asthma Attack: Breath Magic" an Emergency Self-Help Technique 12:17 p.m. Oct 17, 1997 Eastern
Hi, I’ve really no idea what one should say about any "alternative" treatments in the US to be correct and give people the right sort of warning to keep clear of frauds, but one object of Buteyko as I understand it is to normalize breathing. Given that asthmatics often breath abnormally, I really can see anything wrong in recommending exercises to correct breathing.
Response:
PJ, I am researching the Buteyko breathing method, in an attempt to better my asthma and allergies. I wondered if you have any experience with asthma/ Buteyko. I am a 29 year old, active man, who can complete a 12 mile hike, up 4000 vertical feet. However, my asthma slows me down, and often prevents me from skiing and other sports. Do you have asthma? Have you attempted this breathing tecnique? Results?
Response:
PJ, I am researching the Buteyko breathing method, in an attempt to better my asthma and allergies. I wondered if you have any experience with asthma/ Buteyko. I am a 29 year old, active man, who can complete a 12 mile hike, up 4000 vertical feet. However, my asthma slows me down, and often prevents me from skiing and other sports.
I have exercise-induced asthma, and tried a "reverse Butekyo" technique of breathing *more* when my EIA got worse. It seemed to help…but pre-medicating with a reliever inhaler helped me even more. I bring this up because you might want to try both methods, under carefully controlled conditions, before you decide. (It’s worked for me several times, so it wasn’t simply a situational effect.) Talk to your doctor; s/he might have other suggestions. Note: the above is not medical research or advice, but rather the call to get more medical research and advice. Scott Takacs, Ph.D. (marketing, not medicine)
Response:
says… PJ, I am researching the Buteyko breathing method, in an attempt to better my asthma and allergies. I wondered if you have any experience with asthma/ Buteyko. I am a 29 year old, active man, who can complete a 12 mile hike, up 4000 vertical feet. However, my asthma slows me down, and often prevents me from skiing and other sports. Do you have asthma? Have you attempted this breathing tecnique? Results?
Check my earlier posts to this news group (using dejavu) … my teen-age daughter, active in soccer, basketball, dance, track etc used a DIY kit on Buteyko to go from an average 1-3 attacks a month + regular "wheezing" some exercize-induced problems to zero attacks and zero symptoms maintained for more than 6 months now, and under a doctor’s supervision she’s off all medications (was daily Serevent, daily Pulmicorte, as-needed Bricanyl), is more active than ever and maintaining personal best peak flows. Daughter and I read C. Owens comment "Scientifically, Buteyko CAN’T work" and chuckled. It’s made a huge impact in my daughter’s life. Steve Jackson
Response: