Posts belonging to Category 'Bad Asthma'

Question to long-time sufferers

Question:

In my experience with psychiatrists, they want only to change one drug at a time, and if you don’t play ball with them, they may coerce you or offer a "compromise" that totally may be against what you want to do.  At least that’s how things are with my new pdoc.  I went to the old one with my mother usually, and he worked pretty well with me. Hopefully, this "new" one will as well.  I’d really like to look further into taking Abilify. BB On 20 Sep 2005 05:43:27 -0700, "Luke Flyswatter" <chewie_r…@hotmail.com

wrote: Abilify has hardly any side effects.  It’s worth a try.  Although I’ve read on this group that getting off Geodon is a bitch.  You might try a small dose of an old anti-psych with geodon.  That might keep the delusions down.  I get delusions when I take benadryl and stay up. Maybe it’s the sleepy factor.

— Remove the word Spam from my e-mail to contact me… http://www.PrivacySig.com/SIGbutherboySpam-gmail-black.png ~

Response:

Schizophrenia is an illness…like any other they say  Some fundamentalists may suggest that it is the work of Satan, and while it may be, it’s still an illness…like any other they say. Buther Boy On Tue, 20 Sep 2005 17:38:55 +0000 (UTC), "Jamie Moroney" <jamie_moro…@btinternet.com

wrote: What are these delusions you speak of, i’m still on a 90/10 belief that what i see is real, there is a 10% doubt though that they may be delusions cos the whole world can’t be satanic, or can it? The book of Revelations says it can, so if it is then there will be a lot of weird demonic activity messing with the minds of the innocent. Thats my personal belief anyway.

— Remove the word Spam from my e-mail to contact me… http://www.PrivacySig.com/SIGbutherboySpam-gmail-black.png ~

Response:

I take haldol and geodon.  Just had my ekg today though.  My doc said it was okay.

Response:

"Michael A. Pereira" <mpere…@webtv.net

wrote in message

news:9045-432FECDD-1162@storefull-3135.bay.webtv.net… <snip bit

| Theoretically, and from my experience, you can use your symptoms and | cash in on them; but to a Christian that’s like selling your soul to the | "devil". Devil? I thought I was Satan, and remembered it. | | | http://community.webtv.net/mpereira/TheSecretsofthe | I like that ending you always have something interesting added in your posts I tend to think you get sympathy from your label rather coz I rarely have symptoms unless the needle freaks they hell out of me. I like your separate reality and dreaming tonight also I was just typing some notes up out a book about that just before or morning should I say. I got post arriving in a few hours nightmare. might as well stay awake now looks like I got another 500meg of blasting tunes to download from bangingtunes.com so I’ll do that now. just really feel that I should say as I never spoke to you before that I used an old post of yours from 16-Jul-2004 put it at the top of this page. I’m sure you wont mind as Usenet is public domain anyway. I hope you don’t mind coz I would like to keep it there. http://matthewlan.com/FileMenu/HTML/quotes_an_stuff.html Thanks everyone passed the 1000 in a month mark already on the double words with your help and the media. Total  # 2539 This Month # 1053 Got some new photos scanned on tonight http://matthewlan.com/Photos_Scanned_Photo’s.htm If like a lift check me out 3 days into my first stay on a ward 1 could be dodge they didn’t like the camera after those I had to have it taken out by one of my outside visitors they got strict rules for mobile cams now but they weren’t expecting me with that then. as was in 1997 the last photo looks as if I’m more aware but also my hair is more scruffy so it was just one of those days that’s how I judged what order they were in. they were actually taken 1 day at a time. there wasn’t someone behind the lens it was timered. see ya

Response:

      The Merck Manual says that Benedryl is the antidote for Thorazine and antipsychotic drug poisoning. Apparently it removes the blocking antipsychotic drugs from the dopamine receptor sites. I don’t think I have a dopamine problem. I probably have Korsakov’s Syndrome from a life of alcoholism. But THEY’d rather call anybody Skizz. It’s worse than even being called a drunk. http://community.webtv.net/mpereira/TheSecretsofthe

Response:

Abilify has hardly any side effects.  It’s worth a try.  Although I’ve read on this group that getting off Geodon is a bitch.  You might try a small dose of an old anti-psych with geodon.  That might keep the delusions down.  I get delusions when I take benadryl and stay up. Maybe it’s the sleepy factor.

Response:

After reading reports in this group for years, I believe that each person is quite different, and that the meds have to be tried one by one (or two) until they find what works for them personally. I get by with .5 mg of Risperdal.  Maybe I’m lucky. "Buther Boy" <m…@privacy.net

wrote in message

news:qbfvi1d8dr5ihjchddcdutmj20ovdhob82@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

I have for so very long, probably about a year, been suffering with persistent delusions and paranoia.  Mostly delusions.  It happens when I watch movies, surf the Internet, in conversation with people I know and don’t know, and doesn’t seem to come to a halt long enough to put me in the functioning-better-with- medication category; or am I supposed to feel all of this and function this way?  I take the maximum does of Geodon among "other prescribed things."  No drugs, no alcohol.  Anyway, should I try for something different?  Is what I’m feeling normal for my condition?  The only other thing I can think of trying medication-wise is Abilify…I’ve tried everything else. Thanks. Buther Boy — Remove the word Spam from my e-mail to contact me… http://www.PrivacySig.com/SIGbutherboySpam-gmail-black.png ~

Response:

What are these delusions you speak of, i’m still on a 90/10 belief that what i see is real, there is a 10% doubt though that they may be delusions cos the whole world can’t be satanic, or can it? The book of Revelations says it can, so if it is then there will be a lot of weird demonic activity messing with the minds of the innocent. Thats my personal belief anyway.

Response:

hello Buther Boy I am on geodon also and I have delusions and voices also.  I’ve had delusions on all the medications.  It is my belief that medications only do so much, they are not miracle cures.  I have a similiar problem with movies and tv. By the way, acoording to Surviving Schizophrenia by E. Fuller Torrey, you can’t mix an older medication with geodon (ziprasidone) due to potential heart arrythmias. My psychologist keeps saying that you need less medication as you get older, so that gives me hope. penguin

Response:

I know something about that book as I’ve read bits and pieces of it. Yeah, that guy is controversial, but I know he does much for the mentally ill.  He has a web site called psychlaws.com that sends out an email newsletter once a week on information regarding the work that’s being done around the U.S. to help persons with mental illness. Anyway, the point I want to make, is that all of this suffering is needless, it’s pointless, and it’s really too damn bad.  I would have thought the newer atypicals would have gotten it right, but did you know that most of "them" and most of "every" antipsychotic were created 15 years before the "official" release of the drug.  So, drugs that come out five years from now, say 2010, will have been created in 1995…totally f–ked up, and totally too bad for us! Buther Boy On Tue, 20 Sep 2005 12:32:15 -0700, kol…@webtv.net (Penguin A) wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

hello Buther Boy I am on geodon also and I have delusions and voices also.  I’ve had delusions on all the medications.  It is my belief that medications only do so much, they are not miracle cures.  I have a similiar problem with movies and tv. By the way, acoording to Surviving Schizophrenia by E. Fuller Torrey, you can’t mix an older medication with geodon (ziprasidone) due to potential heart arrythmias. My psychologist keeps saying that you need less medication as you get older, so that gives me hope. penguin

— Remove the word Spam from my e-mail to contact me… http://www.PrivacySig.com/SIGbutherboySpam-gmail-black.png ~

Response:

I have for so very long, probably about a year, been suffering with persistent delusions and paranoia.  Mostly delusions.  It happens when I watch movies, surf the Internet, in conversation with people I know and don’t know, and doesn’t seem to come to a halt long enough to put me in the functioning-better-with- medication category; or am I supposed to feel all of this and function this way?  I take the maximum does of Geodon among "other prescribed things."  No drugs, no alcohol.  Anyway, should I try for something different?  Is what I’m feeling normal for my condition?  The only other thing I can think of trying medication-wise is Abilify…I’ve tried everything else. Thanks. Buther Boy — Remove the word Spam from my e-mail to contact me… http://www.PrivacySig.com/SIGbutherboySpam-gmail-black.png ~

Response:

      God gave everybody freedom of choice. I have only been a Christian for six years. Before then I thought I had worked hard for the "occult" abilities I gained, which are considered symptoms of schizophrenia. I read about a Japanesse technique called "Raicone" where you write a letter to a deceased person asking them for anything you want, and if it is within their abiity they will see to it that you get it. Among other things, I wrote a letter to my decease grandmother, who was deeply into the occult herself, to give me the ability to hear my enemies planning against me. Good strategy. From that day on I was able to hear my enemies talking about me. It’s so real I have to look up some of their words in the dictionary. How could my subconcious mind concoct sentences in proper context with words I don’t know? It’s upseting at times but I have to know what THEY plan next. When I was a little kid I had bad asthma, so, my parents sent me to the yoga teacher across the street. She first taught me the asanas and pranayama for my asthma. I really enjoyed it, for obvious reasons. I continued practicing yoga for a half a century, plus learning many other occult techniques of withchcraft, alchemy and sorcery, I developed "powers". I can project my mind into the most secret meetings, any where in the word, and not only hear, but also see the partcipants, and their graphs and charts. But, it could be on any timeline. I have multiple screens of vision which I can impose on my natural vision. But, in this way I can be looking right at something "real" and not see it. It seems that if I don’t "believe" in it I can’t see it. If I didn’t get Shamans’ Disease from being stabbed through the heart in my sleep by a woman on "antipsychotic" drugs, which caused her to be unable to distinguish dreams from reality, I probably caused it myself, and had a little "assistance" in causing it at our Sabbats. That’s all taboo now as a Christian. I made as much as $500 an hour as a professional psychic, boosted my gross worth to a half million dollars, got wiped out financially by divorce, and now I can’t use the occult to get "milk money". But, I perceive what I perceive, and all my senses are mixed in a condition called "synesthesia", which is not considered a disease or mental illness. The Synesthesia Society claims that people like Leonardo Da Vinci and Isaac Newton had synesthesia. Dopamine blockers not only don’t diminish my perceptions, but, by depriving me of deep sleep or full wakefullness I also soon fail to distinguish dream from reality. Fortunately I’m not violent. I have one "bumblebee on wheels’ for a doctor, Dr. Beverly Greenwald (let the "perra" try to sue me) now, who I’m trying to get out of my life with a radionic machine, which changes timelines for you, who is trying to force me on dopamine blockers. It’s not withchcraft, alchemy or sorcery, it’s solid quantum mechanics. Dopamine only puts some rewarding feelings in life. Dopamine blockers are used primarily to disable "undesirables" with a nonaddictive drug. Antipsychotic drugs just make you feel miserable. Theoretically, and from my experience, you can use your symptoms and cash in on them; but to a Christian that’s like selling your soul to the "devil". Devil? I thought I was Satan, and remembered it. http://community.webtv.net/mpereira/TheSecretsofthe

Response:

Bi-Polar Symptoms….

Question:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thank You. I will see if I can get my insurance to cover them, or if I can come up with the money to pay for him. The closest one: Barry Blackwell MD Sinai Samaritan Medical Center Milwaukee 414 937 5300 Is about 2 hours from me. I take it that you are confident that he has the experiance to handle a disorder of my kind.

yes I am confident many can , but you need to find them-this is a starting point and certainly worth two hours and price of consult. I mentioned in my e-mail to you you need supervison not because you are so complicated, but because so far I am convinced you haven’t received adequete care yet. There are people with asthma who require oral steroids at low to moderate dose for life with no real problems except some osteo degeneration, possible eye problems and a moon face. It can sometimes be reduced or removed by use of other drugs including some inhaled steroid meds-asthma is a bitch to treat and manage and can be kicked off by your emotions-but again seeing a good asthma specialists who talks to your psychiatrist and therapist, you would be in good hands. The main mode of action of stimulants like ritalin and concerta seem to be in the noradrenergic receptors of the brain-benzos work on benzo receptors and the gaba system which are not related to dopamine benzos depress the cns, stimulants excite it-you can find a balance of action between the the two when treating learning problems and anxiety problems together-a good doc will know how to dose them if the only ad med that helps you in the whole wide world is luvox and the only benzo to help is xanax and the only add med is concrta you can still take these together but a knowledgeable supervising professional needs to be calling the shots and most importantly doing some liver enzyme panels every few months and an ultrasound twice a year you will be fine once you get the right pros in your corner LM – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Thank You. — -Jamie Jamie, I don’t think you are bipolar. Thannk you. Why the Prednison? It is a steroid short term to controal my asthma. Please find another pdoc *on the double*. You are on a dubious medication cocktail and you are scaring yourself with anxious *what if’s* all the time. A fresh start with a new and good pdoc would change so much for the better. Didn’t Margrove refer you to one? I told him the city and state I am in Neenah, WI, but I never saw a response from him with a refferal. Thanks, Jamie Philip — The charter is available at: http://readystump.algebra.com/~asapm Barry Blackwell MD Sinai Samaritan Medical Center Milwaukee 414 937 5300 an rebt therapist: Dr.  Henry Steinberger Madison WI 608 238 5176 — The charter is available at: http://readystump.algebra.com/~asapm

– The charter is available at:

Question for UC/Crohn's Folks Not Taking Meds

Question:

I have UC since 1993.  One flare up every 2 years on average.  Each flare lasts about 6 months.  Between flares I take nothing in the way of drugs or supplements.  Once, in 2000, I used SCD for 6 months to help with a particularly bad flare. No surgeries.  No prednisone, ever.  Imflammation is limited to the lower 6 inches of rectum but symtoms can be severe with extreme rectal pain and urgency 12+ times a day.

Response:

Are there any dietary preferences and/or avoidances that help to put you and keep you in remission?

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have read about most of those, but I figure what I am doing is working, and keeping this disease at bay is like walking a tightrope. i am always afraid of doing anything that will tip the balance and dump me off it.  It took so much trial and error to get to this point I don’t want to mess up anything. Although with respect to the bromelain, I do eat pineapple (a bromeliad) at least once a week, which I believe is generally considered an aid to digestion.   I also have lemon balm and peppermint growing on my deck and make lemon balm or peppermint tea from time to time, which are also supposed to aid digestion. B-12 levels are OK–I don’t seem to have too much trouble absorbing nutrients. I was more interested in find out whether people had tried stuff like cat’s claw, pycnogenol, bromelain, quercetin, boswellin, etc., and whether any such supplements had helped anyone. Bill: Have  you had your B-12 level checked? I am now on monthly shots and I think it has helped with my symptoms. Rebecca :-) What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful?

Response:

I have read about most of those, but I figure what I am doing is working, and keeping this disease at bay is like walking a tightrope. i am always afraid of doing anything that will tip the balance and dump me off it.  It took so much trial and error to get to this point I don’t want to mess up anything. Although with respect to the bromelain, I do eat pineapple (a bromeliad) at least once a week, which I believe is generally considered an aid to digestion.   I also have lemon balm and peppermint growing on my deck and make lemon balm or peppermint tea from time to time, which are also supposed to aid digestion. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – B-12 levels are OK–I don’t seem to have too much trouble absorbing nutrients. I was more interested in find out whether people had tried stuff like cat’s claw, pycnogenol, bromelain, quercetin, boswellin, etc., and whether any such supplements had helped anyone. Bill: Have  you had your B-12 level checked? I am now on monthly shots and I think it has helped with my symptoms. Rebecca :-) What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful?

Response:

dexedrine…isn’t that the drug used for ADHD- works to calm that problem down but for the average person it is like speed?  If it is the same thing, didn’t know it controlled pain also

Response:

Mike, What is Perilla oil.  Never heard of it. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease Mild UC–proctitis, really 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds Yes.  A tablespoon of Perilla oil a day.  Whole flaxseeds ground up (in my mouth) when things get bad.  Evening Primrose oil.  I am going to try coconut oil (it contains short chain fatty acids that the gut needs for fuel). 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease I avoid high amine foods like tomatoes, cheese, milk, fermented products.  I also make slipery elm suppositories with cocoa butter. Antihistamines seem to help me. 4. Operations Thanks, Mike

Response:

I appreciate everyone’s input.   It’s kinda funny, when I was living in NYC, I led a very stressful life (and fullfilling) and had very few UC problems.  Now I’m in FL and life is stress free (boring) and the intestines are more sensitive.

Response:

I appreciate everyone’s input.   It’s kinda funny, when I was living in NYC, I led a very stressful life (and fullfilling) and had very few UC problems.  Now I’m in FL and life is stress free (boring) and the intestines are more sensitive.

nadine i think that just helps prove that ibd is NOT caused by stress…i also lived a very stressfilled life and dont now..and i have become worse over the years..i do think stress can make some of the symptoms worse…or seem worse..but overall..its just not related…but one issue..re florida..could it be the heat making you worse? i know that summer is very bad for me…hot muggy weather is about the worst… take care.. annie

Response:

I think the vit e in particular helps…I take a lactose free multi, I take calcium (which dosage I am increasing based on my dr’s advice of last week).   I don’t know whether the vit e thing is in my head or not…BUT I had read that hospitals were applying liquid vit e to post-surgical incisions which healed faster, and with less puckering and itching, keeping the skin more supple.  I use the liquid when I get a cut or scratch and it heals quickly.  I asked my GI, if it heals externally, might it heal internally?  (After all, IBD is a form of ulceration.)  He said "can’t hurt, might help."  Told me no more than 1000 I.U.s a day.   I don’t know if it is helping my gut for sure, I think it is; I do know that it has helped my skin look wonderful.  I just turned 56 and people are always complementing me on my skin.  It looks  better in the last 6 years than it ever has, and the dryness it used to have (almost to the point of feeling windburned) went away within weeks of taking the vit e.  I have tried several brands of probiotics, but all upset my stomach.  I tried fish oil as well, but didn’t notice any difference.  I tried many brands of calcium, before I found one I could tolerate.   Ditto the multi.  Oh, and I take slow release iron and one enteric coated aspirin every night at bedtime. Notice I am not naming brands here on the board, but would do so in a private email.   I haven’t found anything that works for pain.  When I hurt my back last year my gp gave me some celebrex samples, but they did nothing but upset my stomach.  I also took vicodin once on a Friday evening for the back pain, slept for 16 hours, felt like a zombie for another 16 and threw them down the toilet.   I couldn’t tolerate glucosamine and Gluc. condroitin.  Guess I just have a high tolerance for pain.  About 8 physical therapy visits got my back feeling human again.  Exercise (a combo of aerobics and weights) helps the most, and massage is helpful as well.   I don’t do lactose, I don’t drink (or like) coffee; I do drink a lot of tea, both black and green, not herbal, not decaf.   I do whole grains, limit sugar, fried food, refined products (the whole Sugarbusters thing is really similar to the basic diabetic diet). I eat some red meat, but mostly fish and chicken, veggies well-cooked, fruit peeled.   I eat cheese, not too much, but very good cheese in small quantities. (Not basic cheddar and such.) I just got the Angry Gut from the library last week; will start it this week.       On the negative side my job is very stressful and demanding, and I never get enough sleep.   I am working on the sleep thing, but not much I can do about the job, other than to change, and short of winning a lottery that isn’t going to happen, because despite the stress and administrative b…s…t I do like my job and still find it challenging.   Hope this answers some of your questions. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful? I take meds (asacol) and supplements now, but when I was first diagnosed mid 80s my disease (CD) was active and severe (and pan-colonic).  After 6 months on pred and sufasalzine and then 6 more on the sulfasalzine alone I went into a med free remission from 1987 to mid-1995.  I don;t know why.  I did nothing special, did not take any meds or supplements, and except for avoiding dairy (which I had also done pre-diagnosis) I had no special dietary restrictions.  I was working full-time, attending college and raising a teenage son, total stressville, yet I lived a normal life. When the symptoms began coming back in 1995 I saw a dr immediately, had a scope, had active disease (but not nearly as bad as the first time) got put on asacol and the flare subsided pretty quickly. Strangely enough, by 1995 I had finished college, sold my monster (i.e. money pit) of a house and bought a nice little condo, my son had moved out on his own, and I was headed for my first trip to Europe. Life was about the least stressful it had been for a decade.  Go figure. Now I do asacol 6/day (tried reducing to 4, but after a few weeks felt the symptoms returning); some basic vitamins – calcium, vit e, iron and a multi.  I get massage for the joint pain; I also exercise at Curves for the joint pain and to increase my flexibility.  I walk as much as I can within the time limits of my job (still very stressful). I have avoided pain meds in an effort to keep my head clear…I live alone,  I need to work and can’t be drugged up during the day.  I have no active disease, some microscopic inflammation (per my last scope). No operations yet (knock on wood). I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

Bill: Have  you had your B-12 level checked? I am now on monthly shots and I think it has helped with my symptoms. Rebecca :-)

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful?

Response:

B-12 levels are OK–I don’t seem to have too much trouble absorbing nutrients. I was more interested in find out whether people had tried stuff like cat’s claw, pycnogenol, bromelain, quercetin, boswellin, etc., and whether any such supplements had helped anyone.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Bill: Have  you had your B-12 level checked? I am now on monthly shots and I think it has helped with my symptoms. Rebecca :-) What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful?

Response:

I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations

Dear Nadine.   Over the 30 some odd years that I have had cd and uc, I have always had a list of approximately 16 different pills to be taken throuout the day leaving me taking some  25or so pills a day.  Like you, every time I tried to go off of any of them, the first few days were okay but then my body seemed to drop right into hell.  It finally stopped playing around with my meds and just took them, which was MUCH BETTER than going to the hospital for a couple of weeks each time. And getting a central line put in each   time really hurt!  So just hang in there  and take your meds, please! Love,   Margie CD Class of 67 UC Class of 96

Response:

Navid– In the interests of good Karma, would you care to share some of your "quick-remission" tips right now for someone like me, who has Crohn’s? Thanks!

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – One of the reasons l do not take any drugs for IBD is because l have a strong aversion to all drugs generally. I do not take any supplements on a regular basis. The only Complementary medical treatment for IBD that l have recommended is Traditional Chinese Acupncture from a consultant level(10 years+ experience post qualification in a Chinese hospital) Acupuncturist. Inevitably, if a person does not take any medication for their IBD and wants to live as normal a life as possible i.e. be able to work and have a social life, they will need to unpuzzle a way to control their medical condition in some other way. This is what l managed to achieve via a lot of hard experimenting, luck and help from family members. The ability to achieve and maintain a systematic remision within a limited timescale is of fundamental importance to all those diagnosed with IBD, and those researching IBD. Towards the end of this year  l plan to provide a service, likely for people with UC initially, that will enable a person to achieve a remission within one and a half days time and then learn how to maintain this remission long term, and all done without the aid of any drugs, surgery, supplements or complementary/alternative medicine. Navid.

Response:

What supplements, if any, have you taken or do you still take? Have you found any to be especially helpful?

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I take meds (asacol) and supplements now, but when I was first diagnosed mid 80s my disease (CD) was active and severe (and pan-colonic).  After 6 months on pred and sufasalzine and then 6 more on the sulfasalzine alone I went into a med free remission from 1987 to mid-1995.  I don;t know why.  I did nothing special, did not take any meds or supplements, and except for avoiding dairy (which I had also done pre-diagnosis) I had no special dietary restrictions.  I was working full-time, attending college and raising a teenage son, total stressville, yet I lived a normal life. When the symptoms began coming back in 1995 I saw a dr immediately, had a scope, had active disease (but not nearly as bad as the first time) got put on asacol and the flare subsided pretty quickly. Strangely enough, by 1995 I had finished college, sold my monster (i.e. money pit) of a house and bought a nice little condo, my son had moved out on his own, and I was headed for my first trip to Europe. Life was about the least stressful it had been for a decade.  Go figure. Now I do asacol 6/day (tried reducing to 4, but after a few weeks felt the symptoms returning); some basic vitamins – calcium, vit e, iron and a multi.  I get massage for the joint pain; I also exercise at Curves for the joint pain and to increase my flexibility.  I walk as much as I can within the time limits of my job (still very stressful). I have avoided pain meds in an effort to keep my head clear…I live alone,  I need to work and can’t be drugged up during the day.  I have no active disease, some microscopic inflammation (per my last scope). No operations yet (knock on wood). I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

Oh, I forgot to add exercise.  I can only do so much, but my cousin, who has sarcoidosis, runs marathons to keep her disease at bay.  When she stops running, her disease flares up again.  Intense exercise ramps up natural cortisol levels and puts the immune system in check. Thanks, Mike – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – "I just made a huge change to my lifestyle…starting with the obvious stuff like exercising regularly, avoiding exposure to toxins, avoiding high sugar and processed foods.My meat and veges are organic whenever possible. I make sure the water I drink is  clean.etc. etc. Other than having my butt sliced a  dozen times or 2 to drain perianal abcesses no major surgery." Ken.W. All that your post shows is that your "lifestyle" was likely to have been disasterous, hence your need to make "a huge change" to your lifestyle. Whether or not making a "huge" change to your lifestyle will prevent you from having your "butt sliced" to drain perianal abscesses is best left to qualified health professionals and not to U###A vitamin/supplement salesman like Ken.W or Ed Torres  who plague health related newsgroups. Navid.

Oh yes heaven forbid people will take vitamins and minerals.You know Navid ….I never even mentioned USANA Health Sciences ….. but you still gotta act out your silly part.  With CBS marketwatch and Business weekly  and with all the news coverage USANA got this year on it’s million dollar guarantee and you have all these well known Doctors in Nutrition saying ya It’s good matey!   it’s quite obvious not everyone shares your opinion on USANA. I do agree withyou though about my lifestyle likely being disastrous before. I use to eat at so called fast food places….burger fries and a coke.Potato chips,Use to drink a ton of milk.Never worried about having balanced meals, didn’t take any nutritional supplements, was never regular on getting any type of exercise.My meats and veges fruits I never even cared how they were grown….. I use to think….aaah just what difference could it possibly make to me.

Response:

One of the reasons l do not take any drugs for IBD is because l have a strong aversion to all drugs generally. I do not take any supplements on a regular basis. The only Complementary medical treatment for IBD that l have recommended is Traditional Chinese Acupncture from a consultant level(10 years+ experience post qualification in a Chinese hospital) Acupuncturist. Inevitably, if a person does not take any medication for their IBD and wants to live as normal a life as possible i.e. be able to work and have a social life, they will need to unpuzzle a way to control their medical condition in some other way. This is what l managed to achieve via a lot of hard experimenting, luck and help from family members. The ability to achieve and maintain a systematic remision within a limited timescale is of fundamental importance to all those diagnosed with IBD, and those researching IBD. Towards the end of this year  l plan to provide a service, likely for people with UC initially, that will enable a person to achieve a remission within one and a half days time and then learn how to maintain this remission long term, and all done without the aid of any drugs, surgery, supplements or complementary/alternative medicine. Navid.

Response:

I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease

Mild UC–proctitis, really 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds

Yes.  A tablespoon of Perilla oil a day.  Whole flaxseeds ground up (in my mouth) when things get bad.  Evening Primrose oil.  I am going to try coconut oil (it contains short chain fatty acids that the gut needs for fuel). 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease

I avoid high amine foods like tomatoes, cheese, milk, fermented products.  I also make slipery elm suppositories with cocoa butter. Antihistamines seem to help me. 4. Operations

Thanks, Mike

Response:

piggyback I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like:

I have a tentative diagnosis of IBD (Crohn’s in the small intestine) and I’m sure I have a mild case of it. Due to several pre-existing life-threatening conditions, I can’t take NSAIDs, can’t take steroids for long and have bad asthma attacks on high-dose salicylates. My treatment so far has been to manage the pain and to try to manage the other symptoms with Lomotil (not with much success). If the abnormality is still in my small intestine next month, there is the possibility of a resection. I’m rather hoping to avoid surgery, though if it made the pain and other symptoms go away… I’d still have to come down on the "rather would not have surgery" side! — "Did Father shoot him? I will eat Grandfather for dinner." – Helen Keller, on learning of the death of her grandfather

Response:

"I went into a med free remission from 1987 to mid-1995.  I don’t know why.  I did nothing special, did not take any meds or *supplements*, "Carole Allen. Well done. Navid

Response:

Hi Nadine, I am taking Pentasa and have crohn’s.  I am in remission now since surgery recovery in Sept.  I had a previous surgery also in ‘01.  I take a supplement prescribed by my gi for mostly the stuff I don’t absorb due to the resection.  UM MOM Susan

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

"I just made a huge change to my lifestyle…starting with the obvious stuff like exercising regularly, avoiding exposure to toxins, avoiding high sugar and processed foods.My meat and veges are organic whenever possible. I make sure the water I drink is  clean.etc. etc. Other than having my butt sliced a  dozen times or 2 to drain perianal abcesses no major surgery." Ken.W. All that your post shows is that your "lifestyle" was likely to have been disasterous, hence your need to make "a huge change" to your lifestyle. Whether or not making a "huge" change to your lifestyle will prevent you from having your "butt sliced" to drain perianal abscesses is best left to qualified health professionals and not to U###A vitamin/supplement salesman like Ken.W or Ed Torres  who plague health related newsgroups. Navid.

Response:

Yes it is true that there are some of us who do not take any meds.It’s been 9 years for me. Okay..in real short form so as to not offend anyone here. The severity of my crohn’s would have been right up there. Do I take nutritional supplements?  Yes….  were they in lieu of meds?…. No As for alternative therapies…….I just made a huge change to my lifestyle Healthwise…..starting with the obvious stuff like exercising regularly, avoiding exposure to toxins, avoiding high sugar and processed foods.My meat and veges are organic whenever possible. I make sure the water I drink is clean.etc. etc. Other than havin my butt sliced a  dozen times or 2 to drain perianal abcesses no major surgery.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

Carole I don’t have an option with regard to pain meds and they were making a little groggy during the day.  I ended up in the hospital with a pulmonary problem and the pain control team  looked over my pain control program.  The psychiatrist that was part of the team added some dexedrine to the mix, a tablet a breakfast and one more at lunch.  I have had many people comment on the difference,  A little old lady caame up to me at the super maarket and she said that she hadn’t seen me for some time but I sure looked better.  If you get into a situation where you need pain meds regularly you might talk to your doc about the dexedrene. Sounds like you do pretty weell.  that is thing about IBD you always know someone who has it worse off and someone who has it better off  so wee have something to be thankful for and something to justify our self pity. May you have continued good luck. – Paul – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I take meds (asacol) and supplements now, but when I was first diagnosed mid 80s my disease (CD) was active and severe (and pan-colonic).  After 6 months on pred and sufasalzine and then 6 more on the sulfasalzine alone I went into a med free remission from 1987 to mid-1995.  I don;t know why.  I did nothing special, did not take any meds or supplements, and except for avoiding dairy (which I had also done pre-diagnosis) I had no special dietary restrictions.  I was working full-time, attending college and raising a teenage son, total stressville, yet I lived a normal life.   When the symptoms began coming back in 1995 I saw a dr immediately, had a scope, had active disease (but not nearly as bad as the first time) got put on asacol and the flare subsided pretty quickly. Strangely enough, by 1995 I had finished college, sold my monster (i.e. money pit) of a house and bought a nice little condo, my son had moved out on his own, and I was headed for my first trip to Europe. Life was about the least stressful it had been for a decade.  Go figure. Now I do asacol 6/day (tried reducing to 4, but after a few weeks felt the symptoms returning); some basic vitamins – calcium, vit e, iron and a multi.  I get massage for the joint pain; I also exercise at Curves for the joint pain and to increase my flexibility.  I walk as much as I can within the time limits of my job (still very stressful). I have avoided pain meds in an effort to keep my head clear…I live alone,  I need to work and can’t be drugged up during the day.  I have no active disease, some microscopic inflammation (per my last scope). No operations yet (knock on wood). I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

I take meds (asacol) and supplements now, but when I was first diagnosed mid 80s my disease (CD) was active and severe (and pan-colonic).  After 6 months on pred and sufasalzine and then 6 more on the sulfasalzine alone I went into a med free remission from 1987 to mid-1995.  I don;t know why.  I did nothing special, did not take any meds or supplements, and except for avoiding dairy (which I had also done pre-diagnosis) I had no special dietary restrictions.  I was working full-time, attending college and raising a teenage son, total stressville, yet I lived a normal life.   When the symptoms began coming back in 1995 I saw a dr immediately, had a scope, had active disease (but not nearly as bad as the first time) got put on asacol and the flare subsided pretty quickly. Strangely enough, by 1995 I had finished college, sold my monster (i.e. money pit) of a house and bought a nice little condo, my son had moved out on his own, and I was headed for my first trip to Europe. Life was about the least stressful it had been for a decade.  Go figure. Now I do asacol 6/day (tried reducing to 4, but after a few weeks felt the symptoms returning); some basic vitamins – calcium, vit e, iron and a multi.  I get massage for the joint pain; I also exercise at Curves for the joint pain and to increase my flexibility.  I walk as much as I can within the time limits of my job (still very stressful). I have avoided pain meds in an effort to keep my head clear…I live alone,  I need to work and can’t be drugged up during the day.  I have no active disease, some microscopic inflammation (per my last scope). No operations yet (knock on wood). – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

I have had to take my meds continuously over the past 12+ years including during times of remission.  I tried a few times to eliminate my meds and the results were not good. My question is, it appears there are people in this group who do not take meds except when they experience a flare up.  Is this true?  Can you tell me about your experience like: 1. Severity of your disease 2. Are you taking nutritional suppliments in lieu of meds 3. Any alternative therapies to manage the disease 4. Operations Sorry for the myriad of questions but I’m intrigued.

Response:

Your Cat's Names

Question:

The names that we choose for our pets all have different meanings and origins.  I was just looking to see if anyone had any interesting stories about how they came up with the names of their pets. I’m a TV freak so my cats’ names are all from TV shows.  Ned, my eleven year old black and white panda-esque cat, was named after a character on the soap "General Hospital".  My "middle" cat, eight year old Otto, was named after a character from the British comedy series "Allo Allo".  My youngest kitty, one year old Anya, was named after a demon from "Buffy the Vampire Slayer"… and certainly lives up to the name sometimes, too!  :) Rob Riemensnyder www.RobRiemensnyder.com Stop by and vote in the latest Poll of the Moment!  Who do YOU think was the most annoying TV personality of the 2003-2004 television season?  Was it the cast of "Friends"?  Cocky "American Idol" hopeful Fantasia Borrino?  Maybe it was "Boston" Rob?  Vote now!

Response:

Smokey – because she’s grey Tennessee Tuxedo – because he’s black with a white ‘bow tie’ at his ‘purr box’ and a white ‘cummerbund spot on his belly Ivy – because she was born a feral, and was caught in a patch of poison ivy Lizzie – because she’s a haughty regal cat (Lizzie is short for Queen Elizabeth) Weeble – because he was only a day or two old (no teeth, eyes not open and ears were tiny flaps on the side of his head) when I found him, and he would ‘walk’ around looking for food (formula) and he was all weebly-wobbly (his head was a bit heavy for him, and he almost ended up doing handstands resting on his nose) — The ONE and ONLY lefthanded-pathetic-paranoid-psychotic-sarcastic-wiseass-ditzy former-blonde in Bloomington! (And proud of it, too)

Running and asthma

Question:

Been there, done that.  Best they can do…. I have *never* heard of anyone who *only* suffers from EIA failing to respond to the appropriate medication.   It can be a tricky task to discover the drug combination that works best,

So doctor how about some advice. The very LAST thing you should be doing is to attempt to de-motivate her. Asthma has a psychological element.   Self-belief and self-awareness are critically important in all forms of disease management.  

All hail doctor fraser BAAAAHAAAAAWAAAAA. Almost as real as Dr Dolittle.

Response:

One, a particularly close friend, has recently developed excercise induced asthma.  She’s having a very hard time dealing with this; she can no longer keep up with her running buddies and cannot run long nor race. I’m not looking for sympathy, medical advice, or anything like that. This lady is tough as nails, she’s doing what she can to deal with this.   What I am looking for is some "de-motivational" help

I respect that you aren’t looking for medical advice.  But it is very odd to suddenly develop exercise induced asthma and be limited by it.  It is a very treatable condition.  Sorry for not respecting your posted desire for demotivational advice, but I wouldn’t want a vigorous competitive joyful sounding athlete like your friend to cut short her enjoyment any sooner than she must. Best regards, — Josh Steinberg MD, Syracuse

Response:

If you’re trying to de-motivate her, have her read anything wriiten by you.  I just got through your post, and I’ve got to say that I’m as de-motivated as I’ve ever been.

Would that that lack of motivation applied to your trolling. -Dondo

Response:

Ah!   I had a firm grasp of the wrong end of the dildo.  

An admission from an usenet masturbator.  I assumed you had designs on the young lady.  I see now that ‘friend’ meant ‘friend’. Two possibilities spring to mind.

Woman advice from a terminal virgin BAHAHAHAHAWAAAAAA.

Response:

If you’re trying to de-motivate her, have her read anything wriiten by you.  I just got through your post, and I’ve got to say that I’m as de-motivated as I’ve ever been.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The very LAST thing you should be doing is to attempt to de-motivate her. Asthma has a psychological element.   Self-belief and self-awareness are critically important in all forms of disease management.   She should always be working towards a goal, not looking back over her shoulder at where she once was. I agree.  I am trying to "de-motivate" her in the sense that I want to her to see running as fun, enjoyable, and thus encourage her to do more of it, irrespective of her absolute performance. Currently, she’s withdrawing from running because she no longer sees herself as competitive, and I think that’s wrong.  She ought to try and recapture the fun of running rather than competing.  That’s what I want to get her to see.

  She should treat EIA much as any other setback – it’s something to work to overcome.  Rare is the elite athlete who doesn’t get injured from time to time, but the common denominator is that they all work as had at their recovery as they do at their other training.  The ones who say, "eh, guess I’m screwed, I’ll drop out" don’t last. Think about it:  EIA    - Paula Radcliffe, and about 20% of the other elite athletes           out there… and a _ton_ of elite swimmers.  (Chlorine).  Cancer – Lance Armstrong, Peggy Flemming, many others  HIV    - Magic Johnson, Greg Lougains, Rudy Galindo…  … the list goes on.   The odds are good that she can beat her EIA if she puts her mind to it.  She needs to sit down, figure out her current capabilities with EIA, and figure out a reasonable set of goals to work towards, and consult the hell out of a good respiratory specialist.  She can be competitive again, and it’s that competitive fire that should drive her to work at recovery.  If that means running 9-10 minute miles for the next month, so be it – she should be out there running 9-10 minute miles knowing that that’s what it takes to get back to competition.  It’s the same things you have to do when you get injured – therapy, recovery, and building back up to where you were before.     Giving up and becoming demotivated are exactly the wrong thing. You’re right that it’ll be easier if she finds running at a slower pace fun, but whatever motivation helps her remain focused is good. If that’s "What lovely trees!", great, and if it’s "I’m going to kick ass at next year’s <whatever race," equally great.   -Dave — work: dga – at – lcs.mit.edu                   me:  angio – at – pobox.com       MIT Laboratory for Computer Science           http://www.angio.net/       (note that my reply-to address is vaguely despammed…)       bulk emailers:  I do not accept unsolicited email.  Do not mail me.

Response:

I’ve been trying to encourage her to change her view of running and cycling from the ultra-competitive view she has held to one that’s more recreational, run-for-the-fun-of-it kind of thing. This lady is tough as nails, she’s doing what she can to deal with this.  What I am looking for is some "de-motivational" help – how do you shift your focus from running marathons and 10Ks, placing in your age group, to barely being able to run 9-10 minute pace?  Any way to make that fun? How can I help someone through this transition?

Well, to be nice about it, either you have to change your outlook or leave her alone and get out of her life altogether!   Why?  I am highly a competitive person, who has allergies and asthma, the type that is worse than excersize enduced, but I manage it.  My doctor helps me.  I am managing it well.  I just finished the NYC Marathon on Sunday.  Guess What! So did my doctor!  Your friend needs to be encouraged.  You would be a real friend to do so. Steven

Response:

Sorry bud, but I agree with Roger.  In my humble opinion, exercise induced asthma doesn’t exist.  Asthma, on the other hand, does.  EIA is probably caused by the increased irritation of air / allergens / toxins insulting the bronchial tree when somebody breathes faster and deeper when running, thus causing acute exacerbation of uncontrolled asthma. Two examples of runners with ‘EIA’.  Firstly – me.  I used to have very bad asthma and couldn’t run at all.  Firstly, I got my treatment regime sorted out.  Secondly, I slowly built up my running, being mindful of my asthma. Since taking up running, my asthma has improved beyond my, and my doctors wildest expectations.  Moral: just because life shits on you, it doesn’t mean you can’t bounce back. Second example – Paula Radcliffe. Arguably the best runner in the world, who suffers from ‘EIA’ (OK – maybe her salbutamol is performance enhancing, but I’ll give her the benefit of the doubt).  Moral: who says you can’t be competitive with asthma? I think firstly, she needs to see another doc to get her meds sorted out. Secondly, she needs to educate herself about her asthma – know thyself and prevent the disease.  Thirdly, she need to ease back into running – don’t push it at first – and soon she’ll be back where she was before, probably even better because the knows her lungs’ capabilities that much better. Asthma is a pain in the arse, but many, many top athletes suffer from it. Me included….. only kidding!! Best wishes, Dave — To email, remove SPAM.com and replace with wadham DOT oxford DOT ac DOT uk

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Let me begin by saying that I am not a runner (this is obvious from my sig…) but I have running friends. One, a particularly close friend, has recently developed excercise induced asthma.  She’s having a very hard time dealing with this; she can no longer keep up with her running buddies and cannot run long nor race. I’ve been trying to encourage her to change her view of running and cycling from the ultra-competitive view she has held to one that’s more recreational, run-for-the-fun-of-it kind of thing. I’m not looking for sympathy, medical advice, or anything like that. This lady is tough as nails, she’s doing what she can to deal with this.   What I am looking for is some "de-motivational" help – how do you shift your focus from running marathons and 10Ks, placing in your age group, to barely being able to run 9-10 minute pace?  Any way to make that fun? How can I help someone through this transition?

—Well, maybe she doesn’t need to.  I have exer.-enduced asthma.  So does my training partner.  We are both far under 3 hours for the marathon.  I just got proper medication from my doctor…Serevent inhaler 30 minutes prior to hard workouts or races in cold/humid conditions. Andy Hass

Response:

I agree.  I am trying to "de-motivate" her in the sense that I want to her to see running as fun, enjoyable, and thus encourage her to do more of it, irrespective of her absolute performance. Well then, my large plastic friend, what are *you* doing to assist?   I always prefer leadership by example.   You still wrapped up in your competitive world, or are you prepared to take time out to assist your friend on her new journey?   I’m assuming that your friend means something to you i.e. that she’s worth all the effort this will entail.

Well, seeing as I’m married with children, and spending lots of time with another woman is not necessarily the road to marital bliss, I’m somewhat socially limited in what I can do…  But – we’ve been riding bikes quite a bit, at her pace (which is still pretty darn fast).  We’re off this weekend for a 100 mile bike ride, where I’ve encouraged her to ride with me – in spite of my buddies wanting to "time trial" the event, we’re going at a somewhat leisurely pace. She ought to try and recapture the fun of running rather than competing.  That’s what I want to get her to see. Easiest way to do this is the ‘complete change of environment’ technique. That is, take her running where she’s never run before, preferably in a completely different terrain/environment.   Let her set the goals for the run.   Let her choose the rewards for its completion.   Be supportive without being easy on her.   Encourage her to work reasonably hard (but be alert for signs of respiratory failure – always know where the local hospital is and how you’ll get her there – understand the mechanisms of asthma).   Teach her to lead her sporting life in a different manner.   To run where beauty exists.   To become part of the trail, rather than merely racing over it.

Yup.  I’m just trying to figure out the best way to do this – I’m not a road runner, though I occasionally (a couple of times a year) do some trail running.  I’m limited in my ability to run with her, as, asthma and all, she can kick my ass when it comes to running.  Perhaps that’s all the encouragement she needs – I can run with her so she can drop me at will :-) -Dondo

Response:

Well, seeing as I’m married with children, and spending lots of time with another woman is not necessarily the road to marital bliss, I’m somewhat socially limited in what I can do…  But – we’ve been riding bikes quite a bit, at her pace (which is still pretty darn fast).  We’re off this weekend for a 100 mile bike ride, where I’ve encouraged her to ride with me – in spite of my buddies wanting to "time trial" the event, we’re going at a somewhat leisurely pace.

Ah!   I had a firm grasp of the wrong end of the dildo.   I assumed you had designs on the young lady.  I see now that ‘friend’ meant ‘friend’. BTW, you time trial century rides?   Truly, roadies are a breed without a brain. Yup.  I’m just trying to figure out the best way to do this – I’m not a road runner, though I occasionally (a couple of times a year) do some trail running.  I’m limited in my ability to run with her, as, asthma and all, she can kick my ass when it comes to running.  Perhaps that’s all the encouragement she needs – I can run with her so she can drop me at will :-)

Two possibilities spring to mind.  Firstly, you practice your mountain bike skills whilst you accompany your chum on a nice trail run – with you carrying all her water, spare clothes, etc.   If I know roadies you’ll fall off/puncture at the first sign of a pebble so you may find you bike handling skills improving a notch or two.  Secondly, you could do yourself some good by getting your ass off the bike and asking *her* to coach *you*.  I’m sure your CV fitness will carry you through the stage where you reduce your ridiculously large thighs to a more normal size.   As a bonus you’ll probably find you’ve increased your climbing abilities on the bike (although you may find you lose a couple of minutes on a flat 50 mile TT course) PLUS you’ll be able to wop my ass in duathlons.   Fair trade I’d say… Roger.

Response:

For heaven’s sake, the days of EIA limiting athletic performance are well behind us.   Get thy friend to a doctor of respiratory medicine.   She’ll be back placing in her age group within one month of the establishment of an appropriate treatment regime.

Been there, done that.  Best they can do…. What’s next?   "Please teach me how to injure myself"?

No, actually, I manage to do that quite well… Any useful advice?  Or is flaming the best you can do? -Dondo

Response:

Been there, done that.  Best they can do….

I have *never* heard of anyone who *only* suffers from EIA failing to respond to the appropriate medication.   It can be a tricky task to discover the drug combination that works best, but any half-competent specialist in respiratory medicine will get her there.  If that’s the best that her present consultant can do, I suggest a change of consultant. OTOH, if she has respiratory conditions of which you, she or her consultant are unaware… The very LAST thing you should be doing is to attempt to de-motivate her. Asthma has a psychological element.   Self-belief and self-awareness are critically important in all forms of disease management.   She should always be working towards a goal, not looking back over her shoulder at where she once was. Roger.

Response:

The very LAST thing you should be doing is to attempt to de-motivate her. Asthma has a psychological element.   Self-belief and self-awareness are critically important in all forms of disease management.   She should always be working towards a goal, not looking back over her shoulder at where she once was.

I agree.  I am trying to "de-motivate" her in the sense that I want to her to see running as fun, enjoyable, and thus encourage her to do more of it, irrespective of her absolute performance. Currently, she’s withdrawing from running because she no longer sees herself as competitive, and I think that’s wrong.  She ought to try and recapture the fun of running rather than competing.  That’s what I want to get her to see. -Dondo

Response:

I agree.  I am trying to "de-motivate" her in the sense that I want to her to see running as fun, enjoyable, and thus encourage her to do more of it, irrespective of her absolute performance.

Well then, my large plastic friend, what are *you* doing to assist?   I always prefer leadership by example.   You still wrapped up in your competitive world, or are you prepared to take time out to assist your friend on her new journey?   I’m assuming that your friend means something to you i.e. that she’s worth all the effort this will entail. Currently, she’s withdrawing from running because she no longer sees herself as competitive, and I think that’s wrong.

Certainly is.   If we only measure ourselves against others we’re missing our biggest challenge – beating yourself.   It’s not as silly as it sounds. Personal expectations can usually be beaten, normally ’cause we set our aim rather low.   She needs to set herself challenges, and recognise that your perception of her isn’t measured by ‘who she beats’ but by ‘how she achieves’.   Perhaps you both need to work on this? She ought to try and recapture the fun of running rather than competing.  That’s what I want to get her to see.

Easiest way to do this is the ‘complete change of environment’ technique. That is, take her running where she’s never run before, preferably in a completely different terrain/environment.   Let her set the goals for the run.   Let her choose the rewards for its completion.   Be supportive without being easy on her.   Encourage her to work reasonably hard (but be alert for signs of respiratory failure – always know where the local hospital is and how you’ll get her there – understand the mechanisms of asthma).   Teach her to lead her sporting life in a different manner.   To run where beauty exists.   To become part of the trail, rather than merely racing over it. For most asthmatics – yup, I’m one – the pleasure of simply being able to run is more than compensation for the loss of a competitive career.   It hurts to begin with though; the loss of your self-confidence as a shit-hot athletic marvel sure is painful.  Once you’ve accepted your new situation, your goals *do* change and life gets better.   It’s nice if you’ve got someone who’s prepared to run alongside you while you come to terms with events.   That’s your job, I think. Roger.

Response:

I’m not looking for sympathy, medical advice, or anything like that. This lady is tough as nails, she’s doing what she can to deal with this.   What I am looking for is some "de-motivational" help – how do you shift your focus from running marathons and 10Ks, placing in your age group, to barely being able to run 9-10 minute pace?  Any way to make that fun?

Captain Dildo would be more appropriate. For heaven’s sake, the days of EIA limiting athletic performance are well behind us.   Get thy friend to a doctor of respiratory medicine.   She’ll be back placing in her age group within one month of the establishment of an appropriate treatment regime. "De-motivational" advice indeed!   What’s next?   "Please teach me how to injure myself"? Roger.

Response:

Let me begin by saying that I am not a runner (this is obvious from my sig…) but I have running friends. One, a particularly close friend, has recently developed excercise induced asthma.  She’s having a very hard time dealing with this; she can no longer keep up with her running buddies and cannot run long nor race. I’ve been trying to encourage her to change her view of running and cycling from the ultra-competitive view she has held to one that’s more recreational, run-for-the-fun-of-it kind of thing. I’m not looking for sympathy, medical advice, or anything like that. This lady is tough as nails, she’s doing what she can to deal with this.   What I am looking for is some "de-motivational" help – how do you shift your focus from running marathons and 10Ks, placing in your age group, to barely being able to run 9-10 minute pace?  Any way to make that fun? How can I help someone through this transition? -Dondo — What am I on? I’m on my bike,                         o__ 6 hours a day, busting my ass.          ,/’_ What are you on? –Lance Armstrong     (_)(_)

Response:

Another newbie intro

Question:

Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Hi and welcome :) — Roseann 250 (post baby 2001) 188.5 (3/2003) 140 (goal) Worrying does not empty tomorrow of its troubles, it empties today of its strength.

Response:

Hi Anna! Welcome aboard this great newsgroup. Congratulations on losing those 13 pounds. Isn’t WW’s great! You can eat almost every thing you want & still lose weight. I look forward to reading about your future successes. Elaine K 331.4/190.2/179 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Welcome, Anna ! You ‘ll like it here ! — Nathalie from Belgium 134.1/111/minigoal 109.1 Goal 68 Kg 295.6/244.7/minigoal 240.5/Goal 150 pounds NAFC 253.8/244.7/238

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Welcome to the group, Anna. — SuzyQ Weight 126.4 WW Lifetime Membership Feb 03 SSC http://www.chiefimaging.com/asdww/index.htm

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Welcome to the group Anna. My fondest vacation memories are of visits with my friends in Horseheath, Cambridgeshire. Oh the lovely rambles over the fields and ’round the barrows … — Anne Rudolph "It’s not having what you want; it’s wanting what you’ve got." — Sheryl Crow 162/130/132 http://home.covad.net/~arudolph/annes.htm

Response:

Welcome Anna! Sheila

Response:

Welcome to the group Anna!  You’ll get lots of support and information here. Brenda 209/190/140

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Hello and welcome to the NG. Congratulations on your progress thus far! — Prairie Roots 232/215.5/10% 209/157 == – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA.

Response:

I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool.

Hi Anna Hills are too stressful with asthma. What I used to do (but haven’t for ages, I admit) is drive down to the flat and then do my walk. My husband and I used to go out every night after dinner for a 3.5km walk along the flat. It took 40 minutes and gave me 2 exercise points. My hours of work have changed but I shouldn’t use that as an exuse not to go for regular walks. However, I am doing weights at the gym and have recently started swimming, neither of which are available to you. Walking is an excellent exercise and costs nothing but a decent pair of shoes. Walk only as far and as fast as your lungs will allow, and be wary of early morning, night-time cold air, which I find makes me wheezy. Kathy

Response:

Welcome, Anna!  I think you’ll love it here!  :)  Good Luck! — Kristin 272/231.8/172 NAFC – 222 40.2 pounds lost since 1/8/02

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o (

Response:

welcome!!! Lee

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Hi, Anna, You have beautiful name. I put weight on the same way.  You have very realistic attitude which will be a great help. — Take Care Catherine 154/131/126

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Welcome to the group, Anne and congrats on the losses so far! — Joy 285/244/150 Started WW At Home 1/1/02 at 285 Joined WW At Work 9/24/02 at 264.4 *New 10% Target: 26 (238.4)* Here’s our FAQ: http://www.didian.com/asdww/ and welcome notice: http://www.geocities.com/welcomenotice/index.html

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi Everyone, I’ve been lurking for a little while and thought I’d say "Hi!" and introduce myself. I live in Cambridgeshire, UK and I’m stay-at-home mum to three kids. I have been skinny for most of my life (although bizarrely imagining myself to be fat) but since the third baby I’ve put on a bit of weight (about 40lbs). Unfortunately, all the weight seems to have gone on my belly, so people keep asking me when the fourth baby is due! :o ( I decided about a month ago to start losing weight, after I was inspired by the BBC reality TV show "Diet Trials". Also, I was growing out of the sizes easily available in a small town and it is very depressing not being able to wear fashionable clothes. My other reason was that I have fairly bad asthma and my doctor says every pound I lose means my lungs and heart have to do that much less work (plus lots of fruit and veg have been shown to reduce the severity of asthma). I’m doing Weight-Watchers online, but I’m not alone because a whole bunch of my friends are doing it too. I really love this diet but I’m aware I’m in the "honeymoon period" so I might need some encouragement when it gets tougher. My goal weight is officially 10st 6lbs (146 pounds) and I started at 12 st 8 lbs (176 pounds). So far, I’m down to 11 st 13lbs (167 pounds). I’m currently on 20 Weight Watchers points per day, which is a little tight but manageable. I don’t like to save up points because of my previous history (I’ve been a bit of a binge-starver in the past), so I tend to eat pretty much up to my limit. My daily treat is some licorice wheels, which I’ve discovered to be only 1 point per piece! I worry I’m not taking enough exercise, but its difficult with my asthma. I walk the kids to school, which is 15 minutes each way (up a hill) and I tried doing an exercise video but nearly emptied my inhaler doing it. Has anyone got any tips? I think my biggest worry is that without enough exercise I’ll lose muscle-weight instead of fat. Unfortunately, I don’t have easy access to a gym or swimming pool. Anyway, enough about me. I’m looking forwards to getting to know you all – there are such inspiring, heroic people on this group! TIA. — Anna Hayward Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

Intro and Vegetalbe Portions Question

Question:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Both  or all – triggers, satisfaction and envir/psycho….  I ate too much last night.  Oh, I did not exceed my points but even five minutes before bed I was still hitting the dried mango and Miss Meringue! This is exactly how I am feeling tonite … like I ate too much, yet have not exceeded my points.  The problem lies more in *what I ate*.  Quick, carry in dinner from a spot that really has nothing to offer other than heavy, fat laden fast foods (italian beef, sausage, etc) – but dh has been crying for a pepper and egg sandwich for a few weeks now .. and I decided to be a good sport.  Dinner did not seem to satisfy me.  I successfully denied the pie offer, but am still battling those munchies – which so far have only included 6 mini meringues. Where do you find the dried mango?  I haven’t seen it around here and it sounds yummy! Costco has the dried mango but some natural food stores also sell it and maybe I’ve seen it at Trader Joes???  Oh, sausage does sound good. There’s an Italian restaurant by work which makes this incredible open face sausage sandwich covered by a terrific, thick tomato sauce and three kinds of thick gloppy melted cheeses.  See I’m not quite "healed" yet!  The sandwich has to be 30-40 points.  Altho, even before the diet, ahem, WW began, I was taking about half of it home. Still, not a slimmy lunch by any means.

I found some at Trader Joe’s but didn’t pick it up … this trip.  The store was ridiculously crowded and dh was getting antsy – kind of takes the fun out of shopping.  Have you tried the chicken italian sausage from Trader Joe’s?  If I recall correctly it was something like 90 calories per link and very little fat, came in several different flavor varieties.  We tried the italian flavor, couldn’t taste the difference from the regular stuff.  It has become a staple in our house (I love sausage and peppers).  I think we all have some food items that will always call out to us (remember me and my onion rings?) – learning that we can have them, but have to give on something else is the trick.  We CAN do this! This Italian restaurant the kids chose serves family style, suggests ordering entrees and sharing.  Last time we went, we ordered 3 entrees and 1 salad for 8 people … took home more than half of everything (I sent it home with eldest daughter).  It is definitely a place that I would not attempt to venture to without a larger group of people – much too dangerous for me. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Maybe what we consider "dangerous latitude" is what "normal" weight people just innately do or how they react to food.  They turn their attention elsewhere.  They do it naturally we need to be conscious of it.  I don’t have to face maintenance just yet.  Weeks or maybe months away. This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense.  She’ll take out a box of bagel bite things, and fix herself 2 or 3.  Me?  Give me the whole box or forget it!  I don’t think I was ever like her and have no idea where she got it from.  My logic is that if I don’t ever stop trying to *lose* weight, then I don’t have to worry about maintenance – right?  Backwards thinking, but I am still running scared. On the way home from the ski trip we were discussing weight and foods. My friend is becoming a real healthy food NUT!  But we were trying to define why we crave certain items and whether it is natural (genetic) or learned or what.  Since my sister seems like your daughter, I figure it is not learned/environmental.  We were pretty much raised in the same environment (she’s 3 years younger).   She’s maybe 100 pounds and always has been very thin at 5′5"   So I figure genetics plays a role.  So we have to fight some innate/inherent weight mechanism???  

I definitely think it is a genetic thing.  My youngest daughter and son have had the same meals served to them for the past 15 years – yet my sons tastes/desires tend to run toward the junk food/fast food items (chips, chips and more chips) and meat/potatoes.  My daughter detests fast food and leans more heavily towards the vegetables and salsa.  She eats very little in the form of potatoes/starchy foods or meat, and keeps portions well under control.  This is not something that she learned by example … not in this house anyway.   My mom always teased my dad over sardines.  She hated fish in any form and he loved it and particularly smelly sardines (I do those also for breakfast before longer hikes/ski trips) but would dutiful open them, dice onion and make him a sandwich. Ahhhhhhhhh, she is a much better woman than me!  I don’t humor the old man, I don’t fix his sardines or herring … if he wants them, he has to deal with them. <G  It works in reverse also – he refuses to touch a jar of mayo or anything that has it in it. <G I have never been much of a mayo person either.  I never did spread it on bread – maybe it was in the tuna sandwich but now that I prepare that stuff (and even for years), I just ate the tuna straight.

He’s a straight tuna guy also, I have to have something to make it *wet*.  LOL  I do adore tuna salad, but so far have avoided it.  One of these days I’ll mess around and figure out a friendlier version that I can enjoy. I do weigh only meats/casseroles, shredded cheese, things like that.  Guess it’s those higher calorie items that I want to make sure I am figuring correctly.   It always comes right back to that portion control issue, and I am overly fearful of how fast that could possibly get away from me if I allow it.   Fruits, veggies and such – I just pile ‘em on and take a point or two.  Rice and potatoes I’m pretty good at eyeballing. I’m not doing much rice but have been eyeballing the kasha.  It makes 3-something cups and I divide it roughly.  Again, like folks say – you did not get here eating too many vegetables, One spoonful extra or less of rice, kasha or even mashed potatoes will not kill a ‘diet’ or WW plan.   It is the cups of the stuff extra that did it and would again.  Clearly, as I get closer to goal maybe that spoonful will be my stumbling block but I will just walk a bit further at the mall.

I’m not convinced that the one spoonful is going to make or break us … it’s those half cups that are the killer. <G  I have learned to remove my plate immediately from the table when I am through.  As a family, we tend to sit at the table and talk for quite a bit after dinner – something I really don’t want to discourage.  But … that is the period that has done me in in the past, the continuous extra *bites* that are sitting in front of me.  By removing my plate, I remove the suggestion that I want or need more.   I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   I noticed in the trader joes flyer they now are offering something called baked potato sticks.  Not sure exactly what they are, but thought I would check them out tomorrow.  Might be a nice option when looking for *chips* That’s what I’m trying NOT to do.  Try adding too much to overcome what I’ve cut out.  I think I did that a few years ago with FF cookies.  Trader Joes was giving out BAGS of free potato chips the other day.  The woman before me got about 10 bags.  When it was my turn, he asked and I said NO.  He looked at me and I said, okay, two bags but they are already put away for a future trip.  I need to resist the old pulls (G)

Well dang, I missed the freebies!  <G  I won’t tell you then that those potato sticks were good … or at least I thought so.  Kind of had that styrofoam type appearance, but at least had a *real* flavor to them.  I guess I can get away with them since they aren’t a trigger food for me.  Keep those chocolate chip cookies out of my house though! Joyce — started ww 2/5/02 —  228.8/145.5/150ww goal/140ish personal goal WW GOAL!!!  2/21/03  — LIFETIME 4/4/03 NAFC website can be found at:  http://home.earthlink.net/~jaw179/

Response:

I definitely think it is a genetic thing.  My youngest daughter and son have had the same meals served to them for the past 15 years – yet my sons tastes/desires tend to run toward the junk food/fast food items (chips, chips and more chips) and meat/potatoes.  My daughter detests fast food and leans more heavily towards the vegetables and salsa.  She eats very little in the form of potatoes/starchy foods or meat, and keeps portions well under control.  This is not something that she learned by example … not in this house anyway.  

I agree about the genetics thing. My daughters are twins (fraternal, not identical) and thus had the same foods served to them from Day One. Neither one of them had any foods containing refined sugar or refined flour or chocolate until they were two years old. One daughter never did acquire a taste for chocolate until a couple of years ago after her baby was born. The other craves chocolate every time her TOM came around. One daughter prefers fruits and vegetables, the other goes for breads. Both of them experienced periods of lactose intolerance, one daughter from infancy to high school; the other daughter from 3rd grade to high school. I didn’t develop my lactose intolerance until I was in my 40s. I think it’s because of these differences that I observed in my children that I came to realize some things really are genetic and not indicators of character. Of course, applying that realization to real life is another matter. [g] — Prairie Roots 232/214/10% 209/157 ==

Response:

This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense.  She’ll take out a box of bagel bite things, and fix herself 2 or 3.  Me?  Give me the whole box or forget it!  I don’t think I was ever like her and have no idea where she got it from.  My logic is that if I don’t ever stop trying to *lose* weight, then I don’t have to worry about maintenance – right?  Backwards thinking, but I am still running scared.

Both of my DDs fit your daughter’s profile: They just stop eating when they’ve had enough. I remember one time when one of my girls requested a special dinner. Special requests from either of them were a rare occurrence so I happily indulged her. We sat down to eat, she filled her plate, and after eating barely 1/4 of what she’d served herself, she pushed her plate away and said she was done. A minute later, her sister did the same. What do you mean, you’re done? I asked. Didn’t you like it? They both assured me the food was delicious. Then how can you not eat it? I wondered. I got the most curious answer: I’m not hungry anymore. And then I asked the defining question: What does feeling hungry have to do with it? I got blank stares in return. They truly did not know what I was asking them. And I truly did not understand how they could push away their favorite food before they were so stuffed they could hardly stand up afterwards. — Prairie Roots 232/214/10% 209/157 ==

Response:

Hi Joyce, This is exactly how I am feeling tonite … like I ate too much, yet have not exceeded my points. If you’ve been eating very low-fat for a while, your body can have a bit of trouble digesting fat again. Which is a good thing, probably. Likewise, if you haven’t eaten a lot of dairy foods for a while, or if you haven’t eaten a lot of sugary foods. You body adapts to the diet you’ve been giving it and doesn’t always react so well to sudden change. So, either the food sits there in your stomach for hours, waiting to get digested, or it rushes right through and you aren’t satisfied.

Hehehe – I’ve had a good amount of experience in both those departments, can’t say I enjoy either one of them though. <G – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense. There’s a couple of things probably going on here. Firstly, some people simply have a better "appetite feed-back loop" which switches off hunger as soon as they’ve had enough (just like some people are better at maths, or some people are more athletic). If a person doesn’t grow up in the kind of environment where food was pushed on them even when they were full (you know, "Clean your plate" and "Just one more…" syndrome), they can be like this for life, and hence never get over- weight (lucky beggars!).

Thanks for the info, I find it very interesting!  Maybe I have helped her develop these eating skills without even knowing it.  I have never played the *clean your plate* game, is how I was brought up and I really hated it.  I swore I would never do it to my kids … and so far haven’t.  My son is a *better* eater – as far as eating heavier quantities.  He has recently lost about 40 pounds while away at college.  When he is home I have found that I have a tendency to want to fill him up.  I caught myself tonite when he pushed his plate away and it was still half full (was his second helping).  At first I took it personally and started to say something to him about cleaning that plate … don’t you like mama’s cooking (in jest) … whatever – then realized if he was done, leave the kid alone!  Why make him miserable or destroy all the hard work he has done to shed his excess weight? I guess time will tell with my youngest, if she will remain that skinny little thing that she currently is.  I do hope so, hate to think that she will one day struggle like the rest of us. Secondly, if you over-eat for a long time, your body actually disables the "full switch" (for the technically minded, I’m talking about the leptin hormone mechanism). But you can re-set it if you eat sensibly for a while. I forget how long, but the figure of 5 months seems to be lodged in my brain (?).

Again, very interesting!  This goes back to what Fred and I have discussed as far as getting even the portions of veggies under control.  Maybe we aren’t resetting our bodies by piling up high on them.  Definitely something to think about! The problem is, if you have a bit of a binge before that process has had a chance to occur, or if you later binge for psychological reasons, you can disable that switch all over again! :o (

So in a nutshell, this can always be a problem child unless we do get somewhat strict with ourselves? Fruits, veggies and such – I just pile ‘em on and take a point or two.  Rice and potatoes I’m pretty good at eyeballing. I’m making a conscious effort to cram as much fruit and veg into every meal that I can. This is partly general healthy eating, partly due to the research that shows it can improve asthma (I have quite bad asthma) and partly because if you eat that much fruit and veg, you frankly haven’t got room for anything fattening! (no matter how poor your appetite control mechanism!).

I’m doing the same, not for the asthma reason though (No asthma here – lucky me!). I agree, if I fill up on salad and veggies there isn’t much room for larger portions of the more fattening and less healthier items.  If I want an evening snack, I force myself to try a piece of fruit first and see if that satisfies me … usually it does and I don’t need anything else until those cookie cravings hit in the wee hours.  <G  Thank heavens for miss meringues! One "rule" I have for myself is: Side-salad with everything. Another rule is: Always finish with fruit. It did have unfortunately side- effects for the first two weeks, but now it seems to have settled down!

I have always loved salads but hated to fix them – so they usually were an item that was eaten when going out to dinner.  I changed that quickly.  Now salads appear very frequently, and in large quantities.  I toss the leftovers in a zipper bag, eat it for snacks and lunches – doesn’t last more than a day or two.  I also suffered from those side effects <G, but now it’s settled down to the point of making me wonder how to get it going again.  Does your body eventually get used to the increased amount of fiber and slow down the elimination?  (Gotta admit, I think those dried bing cherries did the trick for me today – lol) I noticed in the trader joes flyer they now are offering something called baked potato sticks.  Not sure exactly what they are, but thought I would check them out tomorrow.  Might be a nice option when looking for *chips* Have you tried carrot, beetroot and parsnip chips? They sell them here in UK in Marks & Spencers, but I’m sure you can get them elsewhere. They’re baked so they have hardly any points.

I haven’t seen them or heard of them around here.  We do have something called veggie chips, are kind of like a styrofoam texture/appearance but are pretty good. The problem being … they are so much higher in calories and fat, almost to the point of being equal to regular potato chips!  Definitely deceiving for those that don’t read the nutrition labels and only base their idea of healthy on seeing the word *vegetable* in the name of the product. Joyce — started ww 2/5/02 —  228.8/145.5/150ww goal/140ish personal goal WW GOAL!!!  2/21/03  — LIFETIME 4/4/03 NAFC website can be found at:  http://home.earthlink.net/~jaw179/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – That’s what I’m trying to figure out.  If I should reduce the very plentiful vegetable servings like a quarter of a cauliflower and one or two stalks of broccoli to something a bit less – just in case I’m keeping the stomach thinking it needs to be VERY FULL.  I think GREAT TASTE can be very satifying but a bit of oil/protein helps the full feeling.  Fries are only something I did at a restaurant as an accompaniment to a burger.  My mom and significant other never did such fried stuff at home and neither did I.    Yes, those 3 slices of pizza also went down easily – I did not feel stuffed.  And I did time the slices – not gobbling and quickly moving to the next.  Maybe I just needed more food.  I was hoping that I would feel full – maybe I should have quit anyway??? I’m guessing you were really hungry and did need the amount you ate – maybe more. But I do understand the concern.  I think we are so afraid of heading right back into the path we came from, and I can see how easily it can happen.  I sometimes think I obsess too much, measure portions too frequently.  My brain knows that it is impossible to put on all that I have lost by eating one larger meal … but I’m afraid of totally losing control as in the past.  This might be something that I need to make closer observations on.  WHAT items leave me feeling full in smaller quantities, WHAT items make me want to continue eating and eating.  Is it even particular food items or is it more environmental/psychological issues?   Both  or all – triggers, satisfaction and envir/psycho….  I ate too much last night.  Oh, I did not exceed my points but even five minutes before bed I was still hitting the dried mango and Miss Meringue! This is exactly how I am feeling tonite … like I ate too much, yet have not exceeded my points.  The problem lies more in *what I ate*.  Quick, carry in dinner from a spot that really has nothing to offer other than heavy, fat laden fast foods (italian beef, sausage, etc) – but dh has been crying for a pepper and egg sandwich for a few weeks now .. and I decided to be a good sport.  Dinner did not seem to satisfy me.  I successfully denied the pie offer, but am still battling those munchies – which so far have only included 6 mini meringues. Where do you find the dried mango?  I haven’t seen it around here and it sounds yummy!

Costco has the dried mango but some natural food stores also sell it and maybe I’ve seen it at Trader Joes???  Oh, sausage does sound good. There’s an Italian restaurant by work which makes this incredible open face sausage sandwich covered by a terrific, thick tomato sauce and three kinds of thick gloppy melted cheeses.  See I’m not quite "healed" yet!  The sandwich has to be 30-40 points.  Altho, even before the diet, ahem, WW began, I was taking about half of it home. Still, not a slimmy lunch by any means. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -That’s good.  Actually, yesterday when some folks noted the weightloss, they congratulated me on the hard work.  I had to admit (though reluctantly) that it has not been that hard.  I was reluctant to admit that since I don’t want to give myself the latitude to go OFF the deep end thinking that weightloss was not that hard.   So I’m inclined to think WW is reasonable for me, at least.   I’ve always felt the same way … this journey has been too easy, which scares me. I don’t feel like it was hard at all and still can’t believe it has been over a year since I started.  I’m finding it is harder to give myself the latitude to veer off program without feeling guilty or being hard on myself.  I also am afraid to *quit* the losing end of things and move on to maintanence.  It’s hard to give up the easy stuff and move on to the harder task … which I know has to be done sometime. Maybe what we consider "dangerous latitude" is what "normal" weight people just innately do or how they react to food.  They turn their attention elsewhere.  They do it naturally we need to be conscious of it.  I don’t have to face maintenance just yet.  Weeks or maybe months away. This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense.  She’ll take out a box of bagel bite things, and fix herself 2 or 3.  Me?  Give me the whole box or forget it!  I don’t think I was ever like her and have no idea where she got it from.  My logic is that if I don’t ever stop trying to *lose* weight, then I don’t have to worry about maintenance – right?  Backwards thinking, but I am still running scared.

On the way home from the ski trip we were discussing weight and foods. My friend is becoming a real healthy food NUT!  But we were trying to define why we crave certain items and whether it is natural (genetic) or learned or what.  Since my sister seems like your daughter, I figure it is not learned/environmental.  We were pretty much raised in the same environment (she’s 3 years younger).   She’s maybe 100 pounds and always has been very thin at 5′5"   So I figure genetics plays a role.  So we have to fight some innate/inherent weight mechanism???   – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.   I just really like the stuff.  Maybe the fish and its healthy oils really satisfy.  I wrote elsewhere, salt is not a problem for me – so far. I was teasing you. <G  Dh also loves his pickled herring, and I humor him.  It is supposed to be very good for you, so go with it!   My mom always teased my dad over sardines.  She hated fish in any form and he loved it and particularly smelly sardines (I do those also for breakfast before longer hikes/ski trips) but would dutiful open them, dice onion and make him a sandwich. Ahhhhhhhhh, she is a much better woman than me!  I don’t humor the old man, I don’t fix his sardines or herring … if he wants them, he has to deal with them. <G  It works in reverse also – he refuses to touch a jar of mayo or anything that has it in it. <G

I have never been much of a mayo person either.  I never did spread it on bread – maybe it was in the tuna sandwich but now that I prepare that stuff (and even for years), I just ate the tuna straight. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I have been buying the hardcopy spiral – works okay.  I’ve been surprisingly diligent about keeping it.  (G) I’ve just never gotten into manually writing a journal, I think it may be a privacy thing with me (or lack of … in this house).  I know if my journal is on the computer, no one else is going to be peeking over my shoulder.  If it is something laying around the house, I have a feeling it would be constantly viewed and would become a source of ridicule.  I take a beating already over my food scale.  <G  I recently went out to dinner with my younger brother, first thing out of his mouth when dinner was served, was *don’t eat that, you don’t know how much it weighs!*.   Little did he know that I probably DID know how much it weighed (or pretty dang close). I don’t add any personal thought – just food and weights! (G)   I don’t use the scale all that often.  Maybe as I slow the lose and hit maintenance I will.  Yes for meats or an unusual item or nuts and cheese. I don’t add personal thoughts to the journal either – just what I’ve eaten and point values.  I still know they would be me up over it – we all are a wacky bunch

Lead on! I do weigh only meats/casseroles, shredded cheese, things like that.  Guess it’s those higher calorie items that I want to make sure I am figuring correctly.   It always comes right back to that portion control issue, and I am overly fearful of how fast that could possibly get away from me if I allow it.   Fruits, veggies and such – I just pile ‘em on and take a point or two.  Rice and potatoes I’m pretty good at eyeballing.

I’m not doing much rice but have been eyeballing the kasha.  It makes 3-something cups and I divide it roughly.  Again, like folks say – you did not get here eating too many vegetables, One spoonful extra or less of rice, kasha or even mashed potatoes will not kill a ‘diet’ or WW plan.   It is the cups of the stuff extra that did it and would again.  Clearly, as I get closer to goal maybe that spoonful will be my stumbling block but I will just walk a bit further at the mall. I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   I noticed in the trader joes flyer they now are offering something called baked potato sticks.  Not sure exactly what they are, but thought I would check them out tomorrow.  Might be a nice option when looking for *chips*

That’s what I’m trying NOT to do.  Try adding too much to overcome what I’ve cut out.  I think I did that a few years ago with FF

… read more »

Response:

Hi Joyce, This is exactly how I am feeling tonite … like I ate too much, yet have not exceeded my points.

If you’ve been eating very low-fat for a while, your body can have a bit of trouble digesting fat again. Which is a good thing, probably. Likewise, if you haven’t eaten a lot of dairy foods for a while, or if you haven’t eaten a lot of sugary foods. You body adapts to the diet you’ve been giving it and doesn’t always react so well to sudden change. So, either the food sits there in your stomach for hours, waiting to get digested, or it rushes right through and you aren’t satisfied. This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense.

There’s a couple of things probably going on here. Firstly, some people simply have a better "appetite feed-back loop" which switches off hunger as soon as they’ve had enough (just like some people are better at maths, or some people are more athletic). If a person doesn’t grow up in the kind of environment where food was pushed on them even when they were full (you know, "Clean your plate" and "Just one more…" syndrome), they can be like this for life, and hence never get over- weight (lucky beggars!). Secondly, if you over-eat for a long time, your body actually disables the "full switch" (for the technically minded, I’m talking about the leptin hormone mechanism). But you can re-set it if you eat sensibly for a while. I forget how long, but the figure of 5 months seems to be lodged in my brain (?). The problem is, if you have a bit of a binge before that process has had a chance to occur, or if you later binge for psychological reasons, you can disable that switch all over again! :o ( Fruits, veggies and such – I just pile ‘em on and take a point or two.  Rice and potatoes I’m pretty good at eyeballing.

I’m making a conscious effort to cram as much fruit and veg into every meal that I can. This is partly general healthy eating, partly due to the research that shows it can improve asthma (I have quite bad asthma) and partly because if you eat that much fruit and veg, you frankly haven’t got room for anything fattening! (no matter how poor your appetite control mechanism!). One "rule" I have for myself is: Side-salad with everything. Another rule is: Always finish with fruit. It did have unfortunately side- effects for the first two weeks, but now it seems to have settled down! I noticed in the trader joes flyer they now are offering something called baked potato sticks.  Not sure exactly what they are, but thought I would check them out tomorrow.  Might be a nice option when looking for *chips*

Have you tried carrot, beetroot and parsnip chips? They sell them here in UK in Marks & Spencers, but I’m sure you can get them elsewhere. They’re baked so they have hardly any points. — Anna Hayward, Alien Visitor Email me at: alienvisitor AT ratbag DOT demon DOT co DOT uk Anna’s Pregnancy, Parenting and Autism page: http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Fruits and veggies have never been a problem, nor water consumption. Portions (I may have mentioned that about a 1,000 times or so) and lots of additional junk foods and desserts.   I do wonder about "keeping the stomach too stretched" with too many fruits and veggies. Or is that an old "wives’ tale?"  I know the calories are not the problem – just the bulk??? Funny you should mention that, as I was thinking the same thing recently.  I find that my portions are a bit smaller, but not much – yet caloric content is much less due to the healthier products being used.  It does make me think that it would be awfully easy to slip right back into those icky old habits if I don’t keep an ever watchful eye on things.  Does the stomach *really* shrink?  Sometimes I think yes, other times I think no.  I have found that at the local burger joint by me, ordering the kids meal burger is more my *size* now … than the adult version which I can only eat half of.  Then again … the 6 oz of turkey went down awfully easy this evening.  Is the difference really in the quantity or in the quality (again, those veggies as opposed to fries and excess fat). That’s what I’m trying to figure out.  If I should reduce the very plentiful vegetable servings like a quarter of a cauliflower and one or two stalks of broccoli to something a bit less – just in case I’m keeping the stomach thinking it needs to be VERY FULL.  I think GREAT TASTE can be very satifying but a bit of oil/protein helps the full feeling.  Fries are only something I did at a restaurant as an accompaniment to a burger.  My mom and significant other never did such fried stuff at home and neither did I.    Yes, those 3 slices of pizza also went down easily – I did not feel stuffed.  And I did time the slices – not gobbling and quickly moving to the next.  Maybe I just needed more food.  I was hoping that I would feel full – maybe I should have quit anyway??? I’m guessing you were really hungry and did need the amount you ate – maybe more. But I do understand the concern.  I think we are so afraid of heading right back into the path we came from, and I can see how easily it can happen.  I sometimes think I obsess too much, measure portions too frequently.  My brain knows that it is impossible to put on all that I have lost by eating one larger meal … but I’m afraid of totally losing control as in the past.  This might be something that I need to make closer observations on.  WHAT items leave me feeling full in smaller quantities, WHAT items make me want to continue eating and eating.  Is it even particular food items or is it more environmental/psychological issues?  

Both  or all – triggers, satisfaction and envir/psycho….  I ate too much last night.  Oh, I did not exceed my points but even five minutes before bed I was still hitting the dried mango and Miss Meringue! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Sounds like you have much of it under control.  Let me ask – does it seem like a DIET?  Does it occasionally or often feel like deprevation?  I was talking with someone at work today and she said she is plain tired of "dieting" and having to watch everything she eats.  She did Atkins much of last year. I have to say that not once in the past year have I felt like I was on a diet, that’s as honest as I can get.  I swear I almost eat more now than before.  I do make better/healthier choices – I don’t think I eat less.  I do watch what I eat, I am not tired of *that*.  If I want that damn cookie, then I have it – get it out of my system and move on.  Other times I find I *really* don’t want it.  Today was one of those *don’t really want it* days.  Dh opened a box of fudge covered oreos and left them sitting on the counter.  One of those things jumped right in my hand as I walked past … didn’t make it to my mouth though. <G   That’s good.  Actually, yesterday when some folks noted the weightloss, they congratulated me on the hard work.  I had to admit (though reluctantly) that it has not been that hard.  I was reluctant to admit that since I don’t want to give myself the latitude to go OFF the deep end thinking that weightloss was not that hard.   So I’m inclined to think WW is reasonable for me, at least.   I’ve always felt the same way … this journey has been too easy, which scares me. I don’t feel like it was hard at all and still can’t believe it has been over a year since I started.  I’m finding it is harder to give myself the latitude to veer off program without feeling guilty or being hard on myself.  I also am afraid to *quit* the losing end of things and move on to maintanence.  It’s hard to give up the easy stuff and move on to the harder task … which I know has to be done sometime.

Maybe what we consider "dangerous latitude" is what "normal" weight people just innately do or how they react to food.  They turn their attention elsewhere.  They do it naturally we need to be conscious of it.  I don’t have to face maintenance just yet.  Weeks or maybe months away. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -My daughter has followed Atkins for over a year and has been very successful.  She also has had many stumbling blocks and does complain that she is so tired of giving up certain items.  And when she finally does cave, the weight creeps back up quickly.  So far she has been able to control it, but I don’t see it being a life thing.   Cutting out fruits is just not for me.  It may work and if Atkins is to be believed, addictions to sugar need to be broken like alcohol anonymous.  But it seems that WW allows me reasonable ability to eat what I want as long as I remember HOW MUCH.  It that different than Atkins – he may think that cream and steak is good but he quickly reminds HOW MUCH carbo is important to his diet. The *old* me could cut out fruits without a problem, but I couldn’t cut out my breads or pasta, rice, pizza, guess all carbs in general.  I do enjoy them!  For me the problem is the idea of having any items being forbidden.  I believe this only promotes failure and makes me want those items more … to the point of becoming obsessed.  That’s why ww has been successful for me, it makes sense!  If I want that danged sundae, I can have it.  I don’t have to obsess … eat it and move on … adjust lifestyle/meals accordingly.  I did follow atkins when I was a young adult, maybe had all of 15 pounds I wanted to lose.  It was great for a quick, short term thing – but I can’t see it as a permanent option … not for me anyway.

Atkins might be a good start to a modest reduction but not for me for long term weight control. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.   I just really like the stuff.  Maybe the fish and its healthy oils really satisfy.  I wrote elsewhere, salt is not a problem for me – so far. I was teasing you. <G  Dh also loves his pickled herring, and I humor him.  It is supposed to be very good for you, so go with it!  

My mom always teased my dad over sardines.  She hated fish in any form and he loved it and particularly smelly sardines (I do those also for breakfast before longer hikes/ski trips) but would dutiful open them, dice onion and make him a sandwich. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -The ONLINE came up yesterday at our meeting.  A few folks mentioned that they like the journaling but not the general site.  Others liked none of the e-site. The journal is the only thing I find useful … and that is only for convenience reasons.  I can get the same thing using fitday, but then have to calculate my own point values .. which I still do.  But the ww website journal is great for quick and easy and keeping me on track instantly.  The rest of the website is just fluff. I have been buying the hardcopy spiral – works okay.  I’ve been surprisingly diligent about keeping it.  (G) I’ve just never gotten into manually writing a journal, I think it may be a privacy thing with me (or lack of … in this house).  I know if my journal is on the computer, no one else is going to be peeking over my shoulder.  If it is something laying around the house, I have a feeling it would be constantly viewed and would become a source of ridicule.  I take a beating already over my food scale.  <G  I recently went out to dinner with my younger brother, first thing out of his mouth when dinner was served, was *don’t eat that, you don’t know how much it weighs!*.   Little did he know that I probably DID know how much it weighed (or pretty dang close).

I don’t add any personal thought – just food and weights! (G)   I don’t use the scale all that often.  Maybe as I slow the lose and hit maintenance I will.  Yes for meats or an unusual item or nuts and cheese. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   I was looking at some sort of chips yesterday while at our local fish market. They looked like bagel type chips, but I think they were more of a sliced bread type thing – had some interesting flavors, tomato basil sounded great.  They also weren’t too bad in the point department,

… read more »

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -That’s what I’m trying to figure out.  If I should reduce the very plentiful vegetable servings like a quarter of a cauliflower and one or two stalks of broccoli to something a bit less – just in case I’m keeping the stomach thinking it needs to be VERY FULL.  I think GREAT TASTE can be very satifying but a bit of oil/protein helps the full feeling.  Fries are only something I did at a restaurant as an accompaniment to a burger.  My mom and significant other never did such fried stuff at home and neither did I.    Yes, those 3 slices of pizza also went down easily – I did not feel stuffed.  And I did time the slices – not gobbling and quickly moving to the next.  Maybe I just needed more food.  I was hoping that I would feel full – maybe I should have quit anyway??? I’m guessing you were really hungry and did need the amount you ate – maybe more. But I do understand the concern.  I think we are so afraid of heading right back into the path we came from, and I can see how easily it can happen.  I sometimes think I obsess too much, measure portions too frequently.  My brain knows that it is impossible to put on all that I have lost by eating one larger meal … but I’m afraid of totally losing control as in the past.  This might be something that I need to make closer observations on.  WHAT items leave me feeling full in smaller quantities, WHAT items make me want to continue eating and eating.  Is it even particular food items or is it more environmental/psychological issues?   Both  or all – triggers, satisfaction and envir/psycho….  I ate too much last night.  Oh, I did not exceed my points but even five minutes before bed I was still hitting the dried mango and Miss Meringue!

This is exactly how I am feeling tonite … like I ate too much, yet have not exceeded my points.  The problem lies more in *what I ate*.  Quick, carry in dinner from a spot that really has nothing to offer other than heavy, fat laden fast foods (italian beef, sausage, etc) – but dh has been crying for a pepper and egg sandwich for a few weeks now .. and I decided to be a good sport.  Dinner did not seem to satisfy me.  I successfully denied the pie offer, but am still battling those munchies – which so far have only included 6 mini meringues. Where do you find the dried mango?  I haven’t seen it around here and it sounds yummy! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -That’s good.  Actually, yesterday when some folks noted the weightloss, they congratulated me on the hard work.  I had to admit (though reluctantly) that it has not been that hard.  I was reluctant to admit that since I don’t want to give myself the latitude to go OFF the deep end thinking that weightloss was not that hard.   So I’m inclined to think WW is reasonable for me, at least.   I’ve always felt the same way … this journey has been too easy, which scares me. I don’t feel like it was hard at all and still can’t believe it has been over a year since I started.  I’m finding it is harder to give myself the latitude to veer off program without feeling guilty or being hard on myself.  I also am afraid to *quit* the losing end of things and move on to maintanence.  It’s hard to give up the easy stuff and move on to the harder task … which I know has to be done sometime. Maybe what we consider "dangerous latitude" is what "normal" weight people just innately do or how they react to food.  They turn their attention elsewhere.  They do it naturally we need to be conscious of it.  I don’t have to face maintenance just yet.  Weeks or maybe months away.

This is something I honestly don’t understand, yet my youngest girl appears to be one of those people who can successfully walk away (no wonder she is only 100 pounds).  She *appears* to be constantly eating, yet she eats very little.  At dinner, she just stops eating – then later tells me she is never full but has had enough.  I’m not sure that even makes sense.  She’ll take out a box of bagel bite things, and fix herself 2 or 3.  Me?  Give me the whole box or forget it!  I don’t think I was ever like her and have no idea where she got it from.  My logic is that if I don’t ever stop trying to *lose* weight, then I don’t have to worry about maintenance – right?  Backwards thinking, but I am still running scared. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.   I just really like the stuff.  Maybe the fish and its healthy oils really satisfy.  I wrote elsewhere, salt is not a problem for me – so far. I was teasing you. <G  Dh also loves his pickled herring, and I humor him.  It is supposed to be very good for you, so go with it!   My mom always teased my dad over sardines.  She hated fish in any form and he loved it and particularly smelly sardines (I do those also for breakfast before longer hikes/ski trips) but would dutiful open them, dice onion and make him a sandwich.

Ahhhhhhhhh, she is a much better woman than me!  I don’t humor the old man, I don’t fix his sardines or herring … if he wants them, he has to deal with them. <G  It works in reverse also – he refuses to touch a jar of mayo or anything that has it in it. <G – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I have been buying the hardcopy spiral – works okay.  I’ve been surprisingly diligent about keeping it.  (G) I’ve just never gotten into manually writing a journal, I think it may be a privacy thing with me (or lack of … in this house).  I know if my journal is on the computer, no one else is going to be peeking over my shoulder.  If it is something laying around the house, I have a feeling it would be constantly viewed and would become a source of ridicule.  I take a beating already over my food scale.  <G  I recently went out to dinner with my younger brother, first thing out of his mouth when dinner was served, was *don’t eat that, you don’t know how much it weighs!*.   Little did he know that I probably DID know how much it weighed (or pretty dang close). I don’t add any personal thought – just food and weights! (G)   I don’t use the scale all that often.  Maybe as I slow the lose and hit maintenance I will.  Yes for meats or an unusual item or nuts and cheese.

I don’t add personal thoughts to the journal either – just what I’ve eaten and point values.  I still know they would be me up over it – we all are a wacky bunch I do weigh only meats/casseroles, shredded cheese, things like that.  Guess it’s those higher calorie items that I want to make sure I am figuring correctly.   It always comes right back to that portion control issue, and I am overly fearful of how fast that could possibly get away from me if I allow it.   Fruits, veggies and such – I just pile ‘em on and take a point or two.  Rice and potatoes I’m pretty good at eyeballing. I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.  

I noticed in the trader joes flyer they now are offering something called baked potato sticks.  Not sure exactly what they are, but thought I would check them out tomorrow.  Might be a nice option when looking for *chips* I was looking at some sort of chips yesterday while at our local fish market. They looked like bagel type chips, but I think they were more of a sliced bread type thing – had some interesting flavors, tomato basil sounded great.  They also weren’t too bad in the point department, but I still took a pass on them figuring I was better off not bringing them into the house.  The yellowfin tuna steak was delightful though – my new passion! I’m really into swordfish.  I get my tuna raw as sushi! (G)  I usually buy extra swordfish when Costco has it in stock.  A very meaty fish. I think I may have gotten a bad piece of swordfish, and it turned me off.  It was very strong tasting, couldn’t eat more than 2 bites of the thing.  Is this normal for swordfish? It should not be overpowering but it does smell fishy when unwrapped.

This was definitely overpowering, as far as the taste.  It tasted very fishy, very strong – which immediately turns me off.  There’s not much I can’t/won’t eat (someday you’ll see a pic and understand how true that statement is) – so if I throw an entire dinner away, you know there is something wrong. Joyce — started ww 2/5/02 —  228.8/145.5/150ww goal/140ish personal goal WW GOAL!!!  2/21/03  — LIFETIME 4/4/03 NAFC website can be found at:  http://home.earthlink.net/~jaw179/

Response:

Thank you and all the others who helped answer my question.  I don’t actually treat potatoes as veges – although I don’t class sweet potatoes as potatoes.   I realize that some veges (like peas and corn, which is technically a grain, not a "vegetable" – go figure). are higher starch than others, but if I like them I just take the points hit and eat them. Thanks again. Diane

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – welcome to the group.  You are not being obsessive at all, I count a half cup as a veg or fruit.  unless the book says different.  I am sure you already got great answers here, and welcome again, Lee

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Fruits and veggies have never been a problem, nor water consumption. Portions (I may have mentioned that about a 1,000 times or so) and lots of additional junk foods and desserts.   I do wonder about "keeping the stomach too stretched" with too many fruits and veggies. Or is that an old "wives’ tale?"  I know the calories are not the problem – just the bulk??? Funny you should mention that, as I was thinking the same thing recently.  I find that my portions are a bit smaller, but not much – yet caloric content is much less due to the healthier products being used.  It does make me think that it would be awfully easy to slip right back into those icky old habits if I don’t keep an ever watchful eye on things.  Does the stomach *really* shrink?  Sometimes I think yes, other times I think no.  I have found that at the local burger joint by me, ordering the kids meal burger is more my *size* now … than the adult version which I can only eat half of.  Then again … the 6 oz of turkey went down awfully easy this evening.  Is the difference really in the quantity or in the quality (again, those veggies as opposed to fries and excess fat). That’s what I’m trying to figure out.  If I should reduce the very plentiful vegetable servings like a quarter of a cauliflower and one or two stalks of broccoli to something a bit less – just in case I’m keeping the stomach thinking it needs to be VERY FULL.  I think GREAT TASTE can be very satifying but a bit of oil/protein helps the full feeling.  Fries are only something I did at a restaurant as an accompaniment to a burger.  My mom and significant other never did such fried stuff at home and neither did I.    Yes, those 3 slices of pizza also went down easily – I did not feel stuffed.  And I did time the slices – not gobbling and quickly moving to the next.  Maybe I just needed more food.  I was hoping that I would feel full – maybe I should have quit anyway???

I’m guessing you were really hungry and did need the amount you ate – maybe more. But I do understand the concern.  I think we are so afraid of heading right back into the path we came from, and I can see how easily it can happen.  I sometimes think I obsess too much, measure portions too frequently.  My brain knows that it is impossible to put on all that I have lost by eating one larger meal … but I’m afraid of totally losing control as in the past.  This might be something that I need to make closer observations on.  WHAT items leave me feeling full in smaller quantities, WHAT items make me want to continue eating and eating.  Is it even particular food items or is it more environmental/psychological issues?   – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Sounds like you have much of it under control.  Let me ask – does it seem like a DIET?  Does it occasionally or often feel like deprevation?  I was talking with someone at work today and she said she is plain tired of "dieting" and having to watch everything she eats.  She did Atkins much of last year. I have to say that not once in the past year have I felt like I was on a diet, that’s as honest as I can get.  I swear I almost eat more now than before.  I do make better/healthier choices – I don’t think I eat less.  I do watch what I eat, I am not tired of *that*.  If I want that damn cookie, then I have it – get it out of my system and move on.  Other times I find I *really* don’t want it.  Today was one of those *don’t really want it* days.  Dh opened a box of fudge covered oreos and left them sitting on the counter.  One of those things jumped right in my hand as I walked past … didn’t make it to my mouth though. <G   That’s good.  Actually, yesterday when some folks noted the weightloss, they congratulated me on the hard work.  I had to admit (though reluctantly) that it has not been that hard.  I was reluctant to admit that since I don’t want to give myself the latitude to go OFF the deep end thinking that weightloss was not that hard.   So I’m inclined to think WW is reasonable for me, at least.  

I’ve always felt the same way … this journey has been too easy, which scares me. I don’t feel like it was hard at all and still can’t believe it has been over a year since I started.  I’m finding it is harder to give myself the latitude to veer off program without feeling guilty or being hard on myself.  I also am afraid to *quit* the losing end of things and move on to maintanence.  It’s hard to give up the easy stuff and move on to the harder task … which I know has to be done sometime. My daughter has followed Atkins for over a year and has been very successful.  She also has had many stumbling blocks and does complain that she is so tired of giving up certain items.  And when she finally does cave, the weight creeps back up quickly.  So far she has been able to control it, but I don’t see it being a life thing.   Cutting out fruits is just not for me.  It may work and if Atkins is to be believed, addictions to sugar need to be broken like alcohol anonymous.  But it seems that WW allows me reasonable ability to eat what I want as long as I remember HOW MUCH.  It that different than Atkins – he may think that cream and steak is good but he quickly reminds HOW MUCH carbo is important to his diet.

The *old* me could cut out fruits without a problem, but I couldn’t cut out my breads or pasta, rice, pizza, guess all carbs in general.  I do enjoy them!  For me the problem is the idea of having any items being forbidden.  I believe this only promotes failure and makes me want those items more … to the point of becoming obsessed.  That’s why ww has been successful for me, it makes sense!  If I want that danged sundae, I can have it.  I don’t have to obsess … eat it and move on … adjust lifestyle/meals accordingly.  I did follow atkins when I was a young adult, maybe had all of 15 pounds I wanted to lose.  It was great for a quick, short term thing – but I can’t see it as a permanent option … not for me anyway. I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.   I just really like the stuff.  Maybe the fish and its healthy oils really satisfy.  I wrote elsewhere, salt is not a problem for me – so far.

I was teasing you. <G  Dh also loves his pickled herring, and I humor him.  It is supposed to be very good for you, so go with it!   The ONLINE came up yesterday at our meeting.  A few folks mentioned that they like the journaling but not the general site.  Others liked none of the e-site. The journal is the only thing I find useful … and that is only for convenience reasons.  I can get the same thing using fitday, but then have to calculate my own point values .. which I still do.  But the ww website journal is great for quick and easy and keeping me on track instantly.  The rest of the website is just fluff. I have been buying the hardcopy spiral – works okay.  I’ve been surprisingly diligent about keeping it.  (G)

I’ve just never gotten into manually writing a journal, I think it may be a privacy thing with me (or lack of … in this house).  I know if my journal is on the computer, no one else is going to be peeking over my shoulder.  If it is something laying around the house, I have a feeling it would be constantly viewed and would become a source of ridicule.  I take a beating already over my food scale.  <G  I recently went out to dinner with my younger brother, first thing out of his mouth when dinner was served, was *don’t eat that, you don’t know how much it weighs!*.   Little did he know that I probably DID know how much it weighed (or pretty dang close). I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   I was looking at some sort of chips yesterday while at our local fish market. They looked like bagel type chips, but I think they were more of a sliced bread type thing – had some interesting flavors, tomato basil sounded great.  They also weren’t too bad in the point department, but I still took a pass on them figuring I was better off not bringing them into the house.  The yellowfin tuna steak was delightful though – my new passion! I’m really into swordfish.  I get my tuna raw as sushi! (G)  I usually buy extra swordfish when Costco has it in stock.  A very meaty fish.

I think I may have gotten a bad piece of swordfish, and it turned me off.  It was very strong tasting, couldn’t eat more than 2 bites of the thing.  Is this normal for swordfish? Joyce — started ww 2/5/02 —  228.8/145.5/150ww goal/140ish personal goal WW GOAL!!!  2/21/03 NAFC website can be found at:  http://home.earthlink.net/~jaw179/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Fruits and veggies have never been a problem, nor water consumption. Portions (I may have mentioned that about a 1,000 times or so) and lots of additional junk foods and desserts.   I do wonder about "keeping the stomach too stretched" with too many fruits and veggies. Or is that an old "wives’ tale?"  I know the calories are not the problem – just the bulk??? Funny you should mention that, as I was thinking the same thing recently.  I find that my portions are a bit smaller, but not much – yet caloric content is much less due to the healthier products being used.  It does make me think that it would be awfully easy to slip right back into those icky old habits if I don’t keep an ever watchful eye on things.  Does the stomach *really* shrink?  Sometimes I think yes, other times I think no.  I have found that at the local burger joint by me, ordering the kids meal burger is more my *size* now … than the adult version which I can only eat half of.  Then again … the 6 oz of turkey went down awfully easy this evening.  Is the difference really in the quantity or in the quality (again, those veggies as opposed to fries and excess fat).

That’s what I’m trying to figure out.  If I should reduce the very plentiful vegetable servings like a quarter of a cauliflower and one or two stalks of broccoli to something a bit less – just in case I’m keeping the stomach thinking it needs to be VERY FULL.  I think GREAT TASTE can be very satifying but a bit of oil/protein helps the full feeling.  Fries are only something I did at a restaurant as an accompaniment to a burger.  My mom and significant other never did such fried stuff at home and neither did I.    Yes, those 3 slices of pizza also went down easily – I did not feel stuffed.  And I did time the slices – not gobbling and quickly moving to the next.  Maybe I just needed more food.  I was hoping that I would feel full – maybe I should have quit anyway??? Sounds like you have much of it under control.  Let me ask – does it seem like a DIET?  Does it occasionally or often feel like deprevation?  I was talking with someone at work today and she said she is plain tired of "dieting" and having to watch everything she eats.  She did Atkins much of last year. I have to say that not once in the past year have I felt like I was on a diet, that’s as honest as I can get.  I swear I almost eat more now than before.  I do make better/healthier choices – I don’t think I eat less.  I do watch what I eat, I am not tired of *that*.  If I want that damn cookie, then I have it – get it out of my system and move on.  Other times I find I *really* don’t want it.  Today was one of those *don’t really want it* days.  Dh opened a box of fudge covered oreos and left them sitting on the counter.  One of those things jumped right in my hand as I walked past … didn’t make it to my mouth though. <G  

That’s good.  Actually, yesterday when some folks noted the weightloss, they congratulated me on the hard work.  I had to admit (though reluctantly) that it has not been that hard.  I was reluctant to admit that since I don’t want to give myself the latitude to go OFF the deep end thinking that weightloss was not that hard.   So I’m inclined to think WW is reasonable for me, at least.   My daughter has followed Atkins for over a year and has been very successful.  She also has had many stumbling blocks and does complain that she is so tired of giving up certain items.  And when she finally does cave, the weight creeps back up quickly.  So far she has been able to control it, but I don’t see it being a life thing.  

Cutting out fruits is just not for me.  It may work and if Atkins is to be believed, addictions to sugar need to be broken like alcohol anonymous.  But it seems that WW allows me reasonable ability to eat what I want as long as I remember HOW MUCH.  It that different than Atkins – he may think that cream and steak is good but he quickly reminds HOW MUCH carbo is important to his diet. I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.  

I just really like the stuff.  Maybe the fish and its healthy oils really satisfy.  I wrote elsewhere, salt is not a problem for me – so far. The ONLINE came up yesterday at our meeting.  A few folks mentioned that they like the journaling but not the general site.  Others liked none of the e-site. The journal is the only thing I find useful … and that is only for convenience reasons.  I can get the same thing using fitday, but then have to calculate my own point values .. which I still do.  But the ww website journal is great for quick and easy and keeping me on track instantly.  The rest of the website is just fluff.

I have been buying the hardcopy spiral – works okay.  I’ve been surprisingly diligent about keeping it.  (G) I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   I was looking at some sort of chips yesterday while at our local fish market. They looked like bagel type chips, but I think they were more of a sliced bread type thing – had some interesting flavors, tomato basil sounded great.  They also weren’t too bad in the point department, but I still took a pass on them figuring I was better off not bringing them into the house.  The yellowfin tuna steak was delightful though – my new passion!

I’m really into swordfish.  I get my tuna raw as sushi! (G)  I usually buy extra swordfish when Costco has it in stock.  A very meaty fish.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Onion Rings a vegetable, huh.  Oh, boy.  But like my Pastrami sub – if it works for you, it works.  That really is dawning on me.  WW will allow our diversions and indiscretions as long as we figure them in. I like me onion rings. <g  Don’t have them often, but will admit that this is one thing I won’t give up.   Today was another one of those *not enough fruits/veggies* days.  I feel like I ate a ton, but I don’t think it added up to the 5 servings … maybe it did, was hard to do an actual count.  Lunch consisted of leftover tomato/veggie soup.  I had 2 cups of soup, counted it as one veggie serving … but maybe it was 2?  I made a huge bowl of cut up fresh fruit to go with dinner (fake egg baked omelet, canadian bacon, light wheat toast, hash browns for those that wanted) – had a small bowl of fruit while waiting for daughter to return from softball – then a larger portion at dinner.  Again, only counted each as 1 serving.  So I figure this anywhere from 3-5 servings … not sure where it ended up, but I’m not gonna lose any sleep over it.  The old me wouldn’t have even bothered making it at all! There’s a burger joint (drooling already) that makes great onion rings (slurp).  Damn! Fruits and veggies have never been a problem, nor water consumption. Portions (I may have mentioned that about a 1,000 times or so) and lots of additional junk foods and desserts.   I do wonder about "keeping the stomach too stretched" with too many fruits and veggies. Or is that an old "wives’ tale?"  I know the calories are not the problem – just the bulk???

Funny you should mention that, as I was thinking the same thing recently.  I find that my portions are a bit smaller, but not much – yet caloric content is much less due to the healthier products being used.  It does make me think that it would be awfully easy to slip right back into those icky old habits if I don’t keep an ever watchful eye on things.  Does the stomach *really* shrink?  Sometimes I think yes, other times I think no.  I have found that at the local burger joint by me, ordering the kids meal burger is more my *size* now … than the adult version which I can only eat half of.  Then again … the 6 oz of turkey went down awfully easy this evening.  Is the difference really in the quantity or in the quality (again, those veggies as opposed to fries and excess fat). Sounds like you have much of it under control.  Let me ask – does it seem like a DIET?  Does it occasionally or often feel like deprevation?  I was talking with someone at work today and she said she is plain tired of "dieting" and having to watch everything she eats.  She did Atkins much of last year.

I have to say that not once in the past year have I felt like I was on a diet, that’s as honest as I can get.  I swear I almost eat more now than before.  I do make better/healthier choices – I don’t think I eat less.  I do watch what I eat, I am not tired of *that*.  If I want that damn cookie, then I have it – get it out of my system and move on.  Other times I find I *really* don’t want it.  Today was one of those *don’t really want it* days.  Dh opened a box of fudge covered oreos and left them sitting on the counter.  One of those things jumped right in my hand as I walked past … didn’t make it to my mouth though. <G   My daughter has followed Atkins for over a year and has been very successful.  She also has had many stumbling blocks and does complain that she is so tired of giving up certain items.  And when she finally does cave, the weight creeps back up quickly.  So far she has been able to control it, but I don’t see it being a life thing.   mmmmmmmmm, I love the skin – is the best part!  Last week I discovered a great potato topper.  Hidden Valley Ranch markets a dry dressing packet called *fiesta dip* – kind of on the southwestern side, a little zippy but not overly spicy.  Mix it with one cup of fat free sour cream and 8 ounces of softened fat free cream cheese.  I used a hand mixer to blend it with, so it would be smooth.  Chill for about an hour.  Nice and thick, very flavorful.  2T came out to about half a point … 1 full point if you use the light cream cheese instead of fat free.  I’ve tried it both ways and honestly can’t tell the difference (and I really don’t like the fat free cream cheese).  This also makes a great veggie dip! I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato.

You and that pickled herring!  LOL  I tend to vary, sometimes eat those potatoes plain, sometimes with my ff promise, or ff sour cream – whatever is hanging around.  I figure it’s still much better than using the regular butter (and lots of it!).  I don’t use salt though, it never makes it to our table.  Guess I gave that up long ago due to dh’s blood pressure problems.   As for sending you on a mission – I thought that the WW Online would have the info she was looking for and since you are an OLD (g) hand at WW-Online, you would be able to tell her where to look.  I probably need to sit down and re-read the pamphlets again so reacquaintment myself with portions, too.   the ww website is really clunky to use, very difficult to find any specific information.  I really only use it for the journal and food database info.  I don’t ever recall seeing anything stating exactly what size a serving should be … other than 3 ounces of meat is equal to the size of your palm, that type of thing.   The ONLINE came up yesterday at our meeting.  A few folks mentioned that they like the journaling but not the general site.  Others liked none of the e-site.

The journal is the only thing I find useful … and that is only for convenience reasons.  I can get the same thing using fitday, but then have to calculate my own point values .. which I still do.  But the ww website journal is great for quick and easy and keeping me on track instantly.  The rest of the website is just fluff. Last night, for some reason in a more ravenous mood, Salsa at 9:30pm! About a cup.  More veggies! I love salsa, but also like it with tortilla chips – so I tend to stay away from it.  It’s one of those trigger foods.  I do use it in eggs though, and mix with fat free sour cream for salad dressing.  I’m wierd!  LOL I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.  

I was looking at some sort of chips yesterday while at our local fish market. They looked like bagel type chips, but I think they were more of a sliced bread type thing – had some interesting flavors, tomato basil sounded great.  They also weren’t too bad in the point department, but I still took a pass on them figuring I was better off not bringing them into the house.  The yellowfin tuna steak was delightful though – my new passion! Joyce 228.8/145.5/150 — 2/21/03 – total lost 83.3 lbs. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Fred 219.2/178/176 (next 10% goal)

Response:

welcome to the group.  You are not being obsessive at all, I count a half cup as a veg or fruit.  unless the book says different.  I am sure you already got great answers here, and welcome again, Lee

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi, I’m Diane.  I’ve posted a few times today, but mostly I’ve been lurking for the last few weeks.  I started the on-line weight watchers program about 2 weeks ago, and have been very pleased with it.  I hate "diets", but this isn’t so much "dieting" as controlling what I eat (okay, the difference is subtle, but it’s meaningful to me).  I like the flexibility – my husband and I can eat the same food, I just eat less.  And I like being able to allow for some "junk" (I have a weakness for Sorbet).  I don’t want to focus on how much I weigh or how much I’m losing, I’d rather focus on the process and try to make this a life change.  Let’s just say I want to lose quite a few pounds, but I’m not in a hurry.  ;-) Anyway, on to the question:  Can anyone point me to a guide that tells how big a "portion" of vegetables is?  On the journal, there are 5 little vegetable symbols that need to be checked off as I eat 5 portions of veges each day.  But I have no idea what *one* vegetable is, and I can’t find the info in the on-line literature.  I will sometimes eat a cup of sweet potato as an emergency dinner (when I work late) – is this one vegetable?  Two? How about spahetti sauce?  If I eat a small banana, is that 1/2 vege  take one point for it, since a large banana is 2 points) ?  I guess this is a bit obsessive, but I want to learn what is "right". Any input would be appreciated.  TIA. Diane

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Onion Rings a vegetable, huh.  Oh, boy.  But like my Pastrami sub – if it works for you, it works.  That really is dawning on me.  WW will allow our diversions and indiscretions as long as we figure them in. I like me onion rings. <g  Don’t have them often, but will admit that this is one thing I won’t give up.   Today was another one of those *not enough fruits/veggies* days.  I feel like I ate a ton, but I don’t think it added up to the 5 servings … maybe it did, was hard to do an actual count.  Lunch consisted of leftover tomato/veggie soup.  I had 2 cups of soup, counted it as one veggie serving … but maybe it was 2?  I made a huge bowl of cut up fresh fruit to go with dinner (fake egg baked omelet, canadian bacon, light wheat toast, hash browns for those that wanted) – had a small bowl of fruit while waiting for daughter to return from softball – then a larger portion at dinner.  Again, only counted each as 1 serving.  So I figure this anywhere from 3-5 servings … not sure where it ended up, but I’m not gonna lose any sleep over it.  The old me wouldn’t have even bothered making it at all!

There’s a burger joint (drooling already) that makes great onion rings (slurp).  Damn! Fruits and veggies have never been a problem, nor water consumption. Portions (I may have mentioned that about a 1,000 times or so) and lots of additional junk foods and desserts.   I do wonder about "keeping the stomach too stretched" with too many fruits and veggies. Or is that an old "wives’ tale?"  I know the calories are not the problem – just the bulk??? Sounds like you have much of it under control.  Let me ask – does it seem like a DIET?  Does it occasionally or often feel like deprevation?  I was talking with someone at work today and she said she is plain tired of "dieting" and having to watch everything she eats.  She did Atkins much of last year. I think potatoes have always been in the carbo/grain portion of the pyramid.  Altho, maybe I should get credit for eating the skin (G) Altho, I’m sure the pesticides counter any beneficial fiber. mmmmmmmmm, I love the skin – is the best part!  Last week I discovered a great potato topper.  Hidden Valley Ranch markets a dry dressing packet called *fiesta dip* – kind of on the southwestern side, a little zippy but not overly spicy.  Mix it with one cup of fat free sour cream and 8 ounces of softened fat free cream cheese.  I used a hand mixer to blend it with, so it would be smooth.  Chill for about an hour.  Nice and thick, very flavorful.  2T came out to about half a point … 1 full point if you use the light cream cheese instead of fat free.  I’ve tried it both ways and honestly can’t tell the difference (and I really don’t like the fat free cream cheese).  This also makes a great veggie dip!

I weaned myself from stuff of any kind of my potatoes a few years back other than salt and pepper.  Sometimes I will put salsa on them.  Or I eat them (here he goes again) with picked herring (hot potato and cold herring is perfect!) and the herring "juice" will flavor the potato. As for sending you on a mission – I thought that the WW Online would have the info she was looking for and since you are an OLD (g) hand at WW-Online, you would be able to tell her where to look.  I probably need to sit down and re-read the pamphlets again so reacquaintment myself with portions, too.   the ww website is really clunky to use, very difficult to find any specific information.  I really only use it for the journal and food database info.  I don’t ever recall seeing anything stating exactly what size a serving should be … other than 3 ounces of meat is equal to the size of your palm, that type of thing.  

The ONLINE came up yesterday at our meeting.  A few folks mentioned that they like the journaling but not the general site.  Others liked none of the e-site. WI in about 2 hours.  Is there one more week of NAFC?  Or do I need to find Shylock this morning for my pound of flesh to reach my nafc goal!!!!! Yup, one more week to go on the NAFC.  I see you are really close to your goal, bet you’ll see it this next week!  

We shall see.  I should drop my points and get a ton of exercise (G) Last night, for some reason in a more ravenous mood, Salsa at 9:30pm! About a cup.  More veggies! I love salsa, but also like it with tortilla chips – so I tend to stay away from it.  It’s one of those trigger foods.  I do use it in eggs though, and mix with fat free sour cream for salad dressing.  I’m wierd!  LOL

I have always preferred potato chips to the others but found a few like black bean chips and some flavored with lime juice terrific.   Fred 219.2/178/176 (next 10% goal)

Response:

Onion Rings a vegetable, huh.  Oh, boy.  But like my Pastrami sub – if it works for you, it works.  That really is dawning on me.  WW will allow our diversions and indiscretions as long as we figure them in.

I like me onion rings. <g  Don’t have them often, but will admit that this is one thing I won’t give up.   Today was another one of those *not enough fruits/veggies* days.  I feel like I ate a ton, but I don’t think it added up to the 5 servings … maybe it did, was hard to do an actual count.  Lunch consisted of leftover tomato/veggie soup.  I had 2 cups of soup, counted it as one veggie serving … but maybe it was 2?  I made a huge bowl of cut up fresh fruit to go with dinner (fake egg baked omelet, canadian bacon, light wheat toast, hash browns for those that wanted) – had a small bowl of fruit while waiting for daughter to return from softball – then a larger portion at dinner.  Again, only counted each as 1 serving.  So I figure this anywhere from 3-5 servings … not sure where it ended up, but I’m not gonna lose any sleep over it.  The old me wouldn’t have even bothered making it at all! I think potatoes have always been in the carbo/grain portion of the pyramid.  Altho, maybe I should get credit for eating the skin (G) Altho, I’m sure the pesticides counter any beneficial fiber.

mmmmmmmmm, I love the skin – is the best part!  Last week I discovered a great potato topper.  Hidden Valley Ranch markets a dry dressing packet called *fiesta dip* – kind of on the southwestern side, a little zippy but not overly spicy.  Mix it with one cup of fat free sour cream and 8 ounces of softened fat free cream cheese.  I used a hand mixer to blend it with, so it would be smooth.  Chill for about an hour.  Nice and thick, very flavorful.  2T came out to about half a point … 1 full point if you use the light cream cheese instead of fat free.  I’ve tried it both ways and honestly can’t tell the difference (and I really don’t like the fat free cream cheese).  This also makes a great veggie dip! As for sending you on a mission – I thought that the WW Online would have the info she was looking for and since you are an OLD (g) hand at WW-Online, you would be able to tell her where to look.  I probably need to sit down and re-read the pamphlets again so reacquaintment myself with portions, too.  

the ww website is really clunky to use, very difficult to find any specific information.  I really only use it for the journal and food database info.  I don’t ever recall seeing anything stating exactly what size a serving should be … other than 3 ounces of meat is equal to the size of your palm, that type of thing.   WI in about 2 hours.  Is there one more week of NAFC?  Or do I need to find Shylock this morning for my pound of flesh to reach my nafc goal!!!!!

Yup, one more week to go on the NAFC.  I see you are really close to your goal, bet you’ll see it this next week!   Last night, for some reason in a more ravenous mood, Salsa at 9:30pm! About a cup.  More veggies!

I love salsa, but also like it with tortilla chips – so I tend to stay away from it.  It’s one of those trigger foods.  I do use it in eggs though, and mix with fat free sour cream for salad dressing.  I’m wierd!  LOL Joyce 228.8/146.5/150 — 2/21/03 – total lost 82.3 lbs. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sure Fred, send ME on a mission!  <grin  I did find a link for the food pyramid that also gave serving size equivalents.  Thanks for sending the challenge my way. <g Like you, I don’t count potatoes as veggies either.  I did in the beginning, but found that I really wasn’t eating enough *real* fruit/veggies then.  Most of the time it’s easy for me to get those fruits and veggies in, but I do have my moments.  Have had to resort to counting onion rings as a vegetable on occassion. <g Joyce 228.8/146.5/150 — 2/21/03 – total lost 82.3 lbs. Potato is NOT a veggie.  A baked sweet potato is 3 points.  Same for a white potato.  I think 1 cup is the same for both. I just tend to eat my veggies without worring too much.  Carrots can start adding up but only after a cup or more towards points. Joyce might be able to help you locate stuff ONLINE Welcome and good luck. Hi, I’m Diane.  I’ve posted a few times today, but mostly I’ve been lurking for the last few weeks.  I started the on-line weight watchers program about 2 weeks ago, and have been very pleased with it.  I hate "diets", but this isn’t so much "dieting" as controlling what I eat (okay, the difference is subtle, but it’s meaningful to me).  I like the flexibility – my husband and I can eat the same food, I just eat less.  And I like being able to allow for some "junk" (I have a weakness for Sorbet).  I don’t want to focus on how much I weigh or how much I’m losing, I’d rather focus on the process and try to make this a life change.  Let’s just say I want to lose quite a few pounds, but I’m not in a hurry.  ;-) Anyway, on to the question:  Can anyone point me to a guide that tells how big a "portion" of vegetables is?  On the journal, there are 5 little vegetable symbols that need to be checked off as I eat 5 portions of veges each day.  But I have no idea what *one* vegetable is, and I can’t find the info in the on-line literature.  I will sometimes eat a cup of sweet potato as an emergency dinner (when I work late) – is this one vegetable?  Two? How about spahetti sauce?  If I eat a small banana, is that 1/2 vege ( take one point for it, since a large banana is 2 points) ?  I guess this is a bit obsessive, but I want to learn what is "right". Any input would be appreciated.  TIA. Diane Fred 219.2/178.2/176 (next 10% goal) Fred 219.2/178.2/176 (next 10% goal)

Response:

Onion Rings a vegetable, huh.  Oh, boy.  But like my Pastrami sub – if it works for you, it works.  That really is dawning on me.  WW will allow our diversions and indiscretions as long as we figure them in. I think potatoes have always been in the carbo/grain portion of the pyramid.  Altho, maybe I should get credit for eating the skin (G) Altho, I’m sure the pesticides counter any beneficial fiber. As for sending you on a mission – I thought that the WW Online would have the info she was looking for and since you are an OLD (g) hand at WW-Online, you would be able to tell her where to look.  I probably need to sit down and re-read the pamphlets again so reacquaintment myself with portions, too.  WI in about 2 hours.  Is there one more week of NAFC?  Or do I need to find Shylock this morning for my pound of flesh to reach my nafc goal!!!!! Last night, for some reason in a more ravenous mood, Salsa at 9:30pm! About a cup.  More veggies! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sure Fred, send ME on a mission!  <grin  I did find a link for the food pyramid that also gave serving size equivalents.  Thanks for sending the challenge my way. <g Like you, I don’t count potatoes as veggies either.  I did in the beginning, but found that I really wasn’t eating enough *real* fruit/veggies then.  Most of the time it’s easy for me to get those fruits and veggies in, but I do have my moments.  Have had to resort to counting onion rings as a vegetable on occassion. <g Joyce 228.8/146.5/150 — 2/21/03 – total lost 82.3 lbs. Potato is NOT a veggie.  A baked sweet potato is 3 points.  Same for a white potato.  I think 1 cup is the same for both. I just tend to eat my veggies without worring too much.  Carrots can start adding up but only after a cup or more towards points. Joyce might be able to help you locate stuff ONLINE Welcome and good luck. Hi, I’m Diane.  I’ve posted a few times today, but mostly I’ve been lurking for the last few weeks.  I started the on-line weight watchers program about 2 weeks ago, and have been very pleased with it.  I hate "diets", but this isn’t so much "dieting" as controlling what I eat (okay, the difference is subtle, but it’s meaningful to me).  I like the flexibility – my husband and I can eat the same food, I just eat less.  And I like being able to allow for some "junk" (I have a weakness for Sorbet).  I don’t want to focus on how much I weigh or how much I’m losing, I’d rather focus on the process and try to make this a life change.  Let’s just say I want to lose quite a few pounds, but I’m not in a hurry.  ;-) Anyway, on to the question:  Can anyone point me to a guide that tells how big a "portion" of vegetables is?  On the journal, there are 5 little vegetable symbols that need to be checked off as I eat 5 portions of veges each day.  But I have no idea what *one* vegetable is, and I can’t find the info in the on-line literature.  I will sometimes eat a cup of sweet potato as an emergency dinner (when I work late) – is this one vegetable?  Two? How about spahetti sauce?  If I eat a small banana, is that 1/2 vege ( take one point for it, since a large banana is 2 points) ?  I guess this is a bit obsessive, but I want to learn what is "right". Any input would be appreciated.  TIA. Diane Fred 219.2/178.2/176 (next 10% goal)

Fred 219.2/178.2/176 (next 10% goal)

Response:

I use www.weightlossresources.co.uk to journal all my food intake and it calculates the portions for me. They have a UK and a US database and I find it excellent. It costs me

"The benefits of aging" – Swiss

Question:

From: accader…@yahoo.com  (acca) From the land of an Urban Myth?

You spent too much time there and its affecting your spelling skills. See:

Multiple Pesonality Disorder and  varialbe incidence of medical conditions: http://www.philnlp.com/jan2000.htm

I looked at this. I like Oprah’s Dr Phil better. AneeBear ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ "Live as if there’s no tomorrow,  love as if you’ve never been hurt,  and dance as if no one is looking."           Satchel Paige

Response:

Chris, my late Father was asthmatic as a child, "sickly and underweight" as a teenager, but generally healthy as an adult until he started having heart problems and eventually Alzheimers in old age.  On the other hand, a (male) friend whom I have known since elementary school was always having allergies, and at 56, with a heart murmur, his allergies have become much worse and he is on medication all the time.  I am not asthmatic but I had a lot of allergies as a child, which I gradually seem to have outgrown (I’m speaking of respiratory ones).  I think this is another case of mileages may vary.  RuthJ – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Chris Malcolm wrote:

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Chris Malcolm wrote: Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except in special rare circumstances. Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free. I had bad asthma at 8, needs daily medication for some parts of year. At 16 need medication at most a few times a week. At 18 stop medication and have minor attacks about six times a year. At 25 have attacks about twice a year. At 35 have attacks about once every two years. Since about 45 can’t recall having an attack. — Chris Malcolm     c…@dai.ed.ac.uk         +44 (0)131 650 3085 School of Artificial Intelligence,     Division of Informatics Edinburgh University,   5 Forrest Hill, Edinburgh, EH1 2QL, UK [http://www.dai.ed.ac.uk/daidb/people/homes/cam/ ]    DoD #205

Response:

Frankenmel wrote:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 11:16 PM Pacific Standard Time It reaches a point, where ventolin is not enough and then you need the steroids. For some,yes. For me,just once.

You are lucky, I hope it stays that way for you.

We have a drug plan and only have to pay a co-pay. Well good deal. We pay over $500/month,no drug coverage. The health insurance and drug plan is why DH has to keep working another 8 yrs, if he can. I hope he likes his job. Speaking only for myself,I cringe at the thoughts of working *only* for the benefits. I still have flashbacks to the horrid last job I had with all kinds of stress and backstabbing.

He will not say he likes his job, but I know that he does and he enjoys the challenge. He had originaly been planing on working until he was 65, now it will be 68, the last two or three years he will be able to work part time and still be able to get the health insurance. With 10 yrs on the job, he will on have to pay 25 percent of the cost of insurance, if he retires before that, it would be 100 percent. Sue

Response:

"acca" <accader…@yahoo.com

wrote in message

news:4c16c425.0303050723.6b0a3df6@posting.google.com… > FurPaw <furpawnews…@comcast.net

wrote in message

<news:3E655D5E.3020309@comcast.net

… acca wrote: The prevalence of depression decreases in women between 30 and 60 years of age. I’ve read stats to the contrary.  But can’t put my hands on them at the moment. Does not answer your question about incidence of depression over time, but shows at least it is starting to get investigated in relation to "menopause". One study from years ago found the highest rates of depression among puberty-age young women and no increases at menopause:

————– I was under the impression that the group with the highest rate of depression was elderly *men*. Eva

Response:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 11:16 PM Pacific Standard Time Are you allergic to grass, or was it just so much, that it would bother anyone?

It was a combination of the dried grass and dirt…blown by fans. I don’t think I’m allergic to grass.

It reaches a point, where ventolin is not enough and then you need the steroids.

For some,yes. For me,just once.

Have you ever tried Singulair, it is not a steroid, but it does reduce the inflammation

No real need…mine is pretty much under control. I think maybe all my daily walking helps a lot. I walk 3 1/2 miles daily and sometimes as much as 5 or 6 miles.

We have a drug plan and only have to pay a co-pay.

Well good deal. We pay over $500/month,no drug coverage.

The health insurance and drug plan is why DH has to keep working another 8 yrs, if he can.

I hope he likes his job. Speaking only for myself,I cringe at the thoughts of working *only* for the benefits. I still have flashbacks to the horrid last job I had with all kinds of stress and backstabbing. Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 9:26 PM Pacific Standard Time Altho steroids are the drug of choice so to speak, I think they are prescribed to quickly.

I had to use a steroid inhaler once when I was in severe trouble. We had done a show in a tent,and the grass dried out and blew all over,and I could BARELY breathe. I of course,used my Ventolin,but the inflammation in  my bronchii was so bad that I had to go on a course of the steroid and then the Ventolin. I could not believe how expensive the steroid inhaler was! Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

Frankenmel wrote:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 9:26 PM Pacific Standard Time Altho steroids are the drug of choice so to speak, I think they are prescribed to quickly. I had to use a steroid inhaler once when I was in severe trouble. We had done a show in a tent,and the grass dried out and blew all over,and I could BARELY breathe.

Are you allergic to grass, or was it just so much, that it would bother anyone?

I of course,used my Ventolin,but the inflammation in  my bronchii was so bad that I had to go on a course of the steroid and then the Ventolin.

It reaches a point, where ventolin is not enough and then you need the steroids. Have you ever tried Singulair, it is not a steroid, but it does reduce the inflammation. It works very good for some and not at all for others. Since I started to take it, I am not needing my inhaler as much at night, as I do without it. I don’t know if singulair would be right for you or not, also don’t know how expensive it is.

I could not believe how expensive the steroid inhaler was!

We have a drug plan and only have to pay a co-pay. I remember with an old insurance co, we had to pay and then wait to get 80% back. In those days, it cost us about 400.00 a month for my asthma and blood pressure meds. The health insurance and drug plan is why DH has to keep working another 8 yrs, if he can. sue – who needs to go to sleep

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Frankenmel wrote:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 9:12 PM Pacific Standard Time Sharon, an inhaler is medication for asthma. Okay,I’ll accept that. I meant Theo-Dur or steroid inhalers. What inhaler do you use? Ventolin Nowadays most people with asthma, take a steroid inhaler on a daily basis. Most? I certainly don’t feel the need for one,and they are godawful expensive. We have no prescription coverage at our HMO. This prevents the need, in a lot of cases, for a rescue inhaler Yes,but I don’t mind using Ventolin when necessary. Over time,IIRC,one can get a fair dose of steroids,and I don’t feel comfortable doing that.

I was just curious(grin). I have already had cataract surgery in both eyes because of steroids and hate having to take any steroids. Unfortunatly I must, in order to breath. Altho steroids are the drug of choice so to speak, I think they are prescribed to quickly. Sue

Response:

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 9:12 PM Pacific Standard Time Sharon, an inhaler is medication for asthma.

Okay,I’ll accept that. I meant Theo-Dur or steroid inhalers.

What inhaler do you use?

Ventolin

Nowadays most people with asthma, take a steroid inhaler on a daily basis.

Most? I certainly don’t feel the need for one,and they are godawful expensive. We have no prescription coverage at our HMO.

This prevents the need, in a lot of cases, for a rescue inhaler

Yes,but I don’t mind using Ventolin when necessary. Over time,IIRC,one can get a fair dose of steroids,and I don’t feel comfortable doing that. Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

Frankenmel wrote:

 

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 8:14

 

PM Pacific Standard Time

 

 

Chris Malcolm wrote:

 >

 

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes:

 >>

 >>

Chris Malcolm wrote:

 >>

 >>

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes:

 >>>

 

Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is

 

not one of

 >>>>

 

them.

 >

 

The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some

 

improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except

 

in special rare circumstances.

 >>>

 

Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought

 

to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later

 

in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of

 

any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free.

 >>

 >>

 

I had bad asthma at 8, needs daily medication for some parts of

 

year. At 16 need medication at most a few times a week. At 18

 

stop medication and have minor attacks about six times a year. At

 

25 have attacks about twice a year. At 35 have attacks about once

 

every two years. Since about 45 can’t recall having an attack. —

 >>

 >

 

Well, I guess there is hope for me yet(grin). It would be

 

wonderfull not to take medicine for asthma on a daily basis. It

 

would be even better, if I never had to take medrol/prednisone ever

 

again.

 

 

Chris,I am wondering if by "attack" you mean full – blown or just

 

shortness of breath. I haven’t been on medication per se since 12

 

years ago. I use my inhaler a few times per day.

Sharon, an inhaler is medication for asthma. What inhaler do you use? Nowadays most people with asthma, take a steroid inhaler on a daily basis. This prevents the need, in a lot of cases, for a rescue inhaler(ventolin, provental etc). I can’t take the steroid inhalers because of my CFS, I do take medrol when I need it.  

Sue,do you find stress causes a flareup? You’re not around cigarette

 

smoking or incense,are you? Do you find that perfume or things like

 

pesticides bothers you? What about cleaning liquids?

 

No problems with stress and smoking, incense, candles are not allowed in my house. Perfume, cleaning chemical, pesticides all bother me, but at home I am able to avoid most of them. I did have a problem on the cruise, they were using stong chemicals, to prevent further outbreaks of the Norwalk virus. This question is more interesting then normal. As you know I have been having naet treatments and I have very few food allergies left. I have also been treated for animal dander, smoke, dust and mold and am rid of those allergies. Still have more treatments coming and will very soon be working on perfume and chemicals. My doctor is hoping that as we do more treatments, my asthma will improve even more. Even before these naet treatments, just eliminating certain food has made a big difference in my asthma. sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net Date: 3/5/03 8:14 PM Pacific Standard Time Chris Malcolm wrote: Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Chris Malcolm wrote: Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except in special rare circumstances. Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free. I had bad asthma at 8, needs daily medication for some parts of year. At 16 need medication at most a few times a week. At 18 stop medication and have minor attacks about six times a year. At 25 have attacks about twice a year. At 35 have attacks about once every two years. Since about 45 can’t recall having an attack. — Well, I guess there is hope for me yet(grin). It would be wonderfull not to take medicine for asthma on a daily basis. It would be even better, if I never had to take medrol/prednisone ever again.

Chris,I am wondering if by "attack" you mean full – blown or just shortness of breath. I haven’t been on medication per se since 12 years ago. I use my inhaler a few times per day. I think one factor that helped was our getting rid of the fleas on our cats. I don’t know if it was the flea "leavings" or the saliva from the constant bathing that caused my asthma to flare up. Sue,do you find stress causes a flareup? You’re not around cigarette smoking or incense,are you? Do you find that perfume or things like pesticides bothers you? What about cleaning liquids? Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

And then there are the illnesses that tend to surface as one grows older – in one’s 40’s or 50’s: rheumatoid arthritis, the osteo variety of arthritis, thyroid probs… Cathy — "Staccato signals of constant information…" ("The Boy in the Bubble")  Paul Simon "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net

wrote in message

news:3E655FE0.8020304@comcast.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

FurPaw wrote: acca wrote: 1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R. We can only hope that the abstract is a bad translation!  I understand the point that they’re trying to make – that some illnesses are self-resolving – but the choices they list here contain some that might last for forty years, and others, like myopia that AFAIK, generally do not spontaneously resolve.  A very strange study … Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. sue

Response:

"Cathy Friedmann" <c…@adelphia.net

wrote in message

news:b43n7o$1r700m$1@ID-103542.news.dfncis.de… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> "FurPaw" <furpawnews…@comcast.net

wrote in message

> news:3E655D5E.3020309@comcast.net… > > acca wrote: > <snipped> > > > However, prognosis is reserved when initial symptoms are severe or if > > > they are connected to sexual abuse, domestic violence or depression. > > > Other diseases have a spontaneous favourable course such as myopia, > > Myopia?  MYOPIA? > > FurPaw > This certainly grabbed my attention.  While it’s true that my left eye

D’uh – make that my right eye. Cathy — "Staccato signals of constant information…" ("The Boy in the Bubble")  Paul Simon – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

spontaneously improved from a -3.25 to a -2.50 (the left eye remained the same at a -4.5) when I was 50, it’s also true that I remain very myopic. And, the right eye went on to regress a bit, back to a -2.75, several

months

after the improvement.  The allergies bit also grabbed my attention.  At least 31 years, & counting… (perennial allergic rhinitus -sp??). Cathy — "Staccato signals of constant information…" ("The Boy in the Bubble")  Paul Simon

Response:

From: FurPaw We can only hope that the abstract is a bad translation!  

If you were Swiss and spoke French, it would all be clear to you. <G

AneeBear ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ "Live as if there’s no tomorrow,  love as if you’ve never been hurt,  and dance as if no one is looking."           Satchel Paige

Response:

FurPaw <furpawnews…@comcast.net

wrote in message <news:3E655D5E.3020309@comcast.net… acca wrote: The prevalence of depression decreases in women between 30 and 60 years of age. I’ve read stats to the contrary.  But can’t put my hands on them at the moment.

Does not answer your question about incidence of depression over time, but shows at least it is starting to get investigated in relation to "menopause". One study from years ago found the highest rates of depression among puberty-age young women and no increases at menopause:  1: Arch Gen Psychiatry 2003 Jan;60(1):29-36 Depression and its influence on reproductive endocrine and menstrual cycle markers associated with perimenopause: the Harvard Study of Moods and Cycles. Harlow BL, Wise LA, Otto MW, Soares CN, Cohen LS. Obstetrics and Gynecology Epidemiology Center, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, 221 Longwood Ave, Boston, MA 02115, USA. bhar…@rics.bwh.harvard.edu BACKGROUND: Few studies have determined the impact of a lifetime history of major depression on an early transition to menopause. METHODS: Reproductive and psychiatric interviews and early follicular-phase blood specimens were obtained at study enrollment and every 6 months during 36 months of follow-up from 332 women with and 644 women without a history of major depression, 36 to 45 years of age.  We used menstrual cycle markers to determine inception of perimenopause, defined as time from study enrollment to a follow-up interview with: (1) 7-day or more change in menstrual cycle length; (2) a change in menstrual flow amount or duration; or (3) amenorrhea lasting at least 3 months. RESULTS: Women with a history of depression had 1.2 times the rate of perimenopause of women with no such history (95% confidence interval, 0.9-1.6). Compared with nondepressed women, depressed women with more pronounced depressive symptoms at study enrollment (Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression scores

8) had twice the risk of an earlier

perimenopausal transition.  Among the women with greater depressive symptoms (Hamilton scores

8), those who also reported use of antidepressants had nearly 3 times

the risk of an earlier perimenopausal transition (hazard ratio, 2.7; 95% confidence interval, 1.5-4.8) of nondepressed women.  Women with a lifetime history of depression also had higher follicle-stimulating hormone and luteinizing hormone levels and lower estradiol levels at study enrollment and during the follow-up period after adjustment for covariates.  CONCLUSION: A lifetime history of major depression may be associated with an early decline in ovarian function.

Response:

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net

wrote in message

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except in special rare circumstances. Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free. I would be extremly happy if this would happen to me(grin). This is based on what I have read, not on any scientific studies. sue

From the land of an Urban Myth? Multiple Pesonality Disorder and  varialbe incidence of medical conditions: http://www.philnlp.com/jan2000.htm

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Chris Malcolm wrote:

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Chris Malcolm wrote: Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except in special rare circumstances. Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free. I had bad asthma at 8, needs daily medication for some parts of year. At 16 need medication at most a few times a week. At 18 stop medication and have minor attacks about six times a year. At 25 have attacks about twice a year. At 35 have attacks about once every two years. Since about 45 can’t recall having an attack. —

Well, I guess there is hope for me yet(grin). It would be wonderfull not to take medicine for asthma on a daily basis. It would be even better, if I never had to take medrol/prednisone ever again. sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Chris Malcolm wrote:

Kevin and Sue Mullen <kjmul…@comcast.net writes: FurPaw wrote: acca wrote: 1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R. We can only hope that the abstract is a bad translation!  I understand the point that they’re trying to make – that some illnesses are self-resolving – but the choices they list here contain some that might last for forty years, and others, like myopia that AFAIK, generally do not spontaneously resolve.  A very strange study … Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. The point is that *some* asthmatics improve with age, some improving enough to be almost completely non-asthmatic except in special rare circumstances.

Children who have asthma, in some cases might improve enought to be non-asthmatic. Most of those will redevelop asthma later in life, it is like going into remission. I have not heard of any adults with asthma, improving enough to be asthma free. I would be extremly happy if this would happen to me(grin). This is based on what I have read, not on any scientific studies. sue

Response:

acca wrote:

1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R.

We can only hope that the abstract is a bad translation!  I understand the point that they’re trying to make – that some illnesses are self-resolving – but the choices they list here contain some that might last for forty years, and others, like myopia that AFAIK, generally do not spontaneously resolve.  A very strange study …

Some chronic diseases have a favourable course and are cured spontaneously. Migraines have also a good evolution in children and after menopause.

Eh? If someone had told me when I was twelve that my migraines would likely disappear by the time I went through menopause (50ish), I would have been *so* reassured…

Many symptoms due to menstruation such as dysmenorrhea, premenstrual syndrome or anemia, disappear after menopause

One would hope so!

as well as diseases due to estrogens such as uterine leiomyoma, endometriosis and prolactinoma. The prevalence of depression decreases in women between 30 and 60 years of age.

I’ve read stats to the contrary.  But can’t put my hands on them at the moment.

 Functional somatic syndromes such as fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome or dyspepsia decrease in 2/3 of cases within 5 to 10 years if there is no history of anxio-depressive symptoms.

I don’t believe this. I’d like to see the data.

However, prognosis is reserved when initial symptoms are severe or if they are connected to sexual abuse, domestic violence or depression. Other diseases have a spontaneous favourable course such as myopia,

Myopia?  MYOPIA? FurPaw

idiopathic infertility, polycystic ovary disease or ventricular arrhythmia. The knowledge of a good prognosis enables to avoid unnecessary treatments and to reassure many patients.

— To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -FurPaw wrote:

acca wrote: 1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R. We can only hope that the abstract is a bad translation!  I understand the point that they’re trying to make – that some illnesses are self-resolving – but the choices they list here contain some that might last for forty years, and others, like myopia that AFAIK, generally do not spontaneously resolve.  A very strange study …

Yes some illnesses are self-resolving, but Asthma sure is not one of them. sue

Response:

"FurPaw" <furpawnews…@comcast.net

wrote in message

news:3E655D5E.3020309@comcast.net…

acca wrote:

<snipped

However, prognosis is reserved when initial symptoms are severe or if they are connected to sexual abuse, domestic violence or depression. Other diseases have a spontaneous favourable course such as myopia, Myopia?  MYOPIA? FurPaw

This certainly grabbed my attention.  While it’s true that my left eye spontaneously improved from a -3.25 to a -2.50 (the left eye remained the same at a -4.5) when I was 50, it’s also true that I remain very myopic. And, the right eye went on to regress a bit, back to a -2.75, several months after the improvement.  The allergies bit also grabbed my attention.  At least 31 years, & counting… (perennial allergic rhinitus -sp??). Cathy — "Staccato signals of constant information…" ("The Boy in the Bubble")  Paul Simon

Response:

acca <accader…@yahoo.com

wrote in message

news:4c16c425.0303041754.d18af84@posting.google.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R. Some chronic diseases have a favourable course and are cured spontaneously. Allergic diseases such as eczema, hay fever and asthma have a good outcome in more than 75% of cases within 7 to 25 years, depending on the kind of allergy. Migraines have also a good evolution in children and after menopause. Many symptoms due to menstruation such as dysmenorrhea, premenstrual syndrome or anemia, disappear after menopause as well as diseases due to estrogens such as uterine leiomyoma, endometriosis

note: when HRT or ERT are not given, and when the woman with endometriosis survives intact through natural menopause. Again, I tried to do this, in my case my bowels blocked (strangulated) in two locations (upper right and lower left) at age 48. I was still menstruating regularly at that time with no missed periods whatsoever, so chose to cut off the estrogen supply by TAH-BSO rather than risk a second surgery (the one in question nearly killed me as it was), and then had to resist strong recommendations of estrogen replacement. For me so far, so good. But without surgery, I’d have died. I have a large medical file to show for it which I have read. There was nothing amiss with my surgery. It was lifesaving. Linda Scheimann  and – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

prolactinoma. The risk of epilepsy relapse after a first seizure is about 40% after 2 years. The risk is lower in children.  Attention deficit disorder affects 3 to 5% of children but is present in only 30% of them in adult age. The prevalence of depression decreases in women between 30 and 60 years of age.  Functional somatic syndromes such as fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome or dyspepsia decrease in 2/3 of cases within 5 to 10 years if there is no history of anxio-depressive symptoms. However, prognosis is reserved when initial symptoms are severe or if they are connected to sexual abuse, domestic violence or depression. Other diseases have a spontaneous favourable course such as myopia, idiopathic infertility, polycystic ovary disease or ventricular arrhythmia. The knowledge of a good prognosis enables to avoid unnecessary treatments and to reassure many patients.

Response:

1: Rev Med Suisse Romande 2001 Sep;121(9):683-7 Related Articles, Links [The benefits of aging. I. Patience and cure: spontaneous beneficial course of certain diseases] [Article in French] Martin-Du Pan R. Some chronic diseases have a favourable course and are cured spontaneously. Allergic diseases such as eczema, hay fever and asthma have a good outcome in more than 75% of cases within 7 to 25 years, depending on the kind of allergy. Migraines have also a good evolution in children and after menopause. Many symptoms due to menstruation such as dysmenorrhea, premenstrual syndrome or anemia, disappear after menopause as well as diseases due to estrogens such as uterine leiomyoma, endometriosis and prolactinoma. The risk of epilepsy relapse after a first seizure is about 40% after 2 years. The risk is lower in children.  Attention deficit disorder affects 3 to 5% of children but is present in only 30% of them in adult age. The prevalence of depression decreases in women between 30 and 60 years of age.  Functional somatic syndromes such as fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome or dyspepsia decrease in 2/3 of cases within 5 to 10 years if there is no history of anxio-depressive symptoms. However, prognosis is reserved when initial symptoms are severe or if they are connected to sexual abuse, domestic violence or depression. Other diseases have a spontaneous favourable course such as myopia, idiopathic infertility, polycystic ovary disease or ventricular arrhythmia. The knowledge of a good prognosis enables to avoid unnecessary treatments and to reassure many patients.

Response:

Suggestions for buying a CPAP on Ebay?

Question:

I find your post very gratifying.   Gratifying that you recognize the value of our collective experience, but especially because you presented your own logic and conclusions such as "most effective approach", "all the challenges of adjusting", "like to have full data". "I called elsewhere", "less convenient, but worth it", IMHO, brilliant.  I don’t recall any of the posts to you containing these phrases, so it certainly appears you have been thinking for yourself.  And you’ve already begun to help others, John, in particular.  That’s the way of this newsgroup. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Marianne Eagan wrote:

John, I was planning on doing exactly what you are thinking of doing, but the people in this group convinced me to get a sleep study, which is what I’m going to do now. I think these people have enough experience to know what the safest, most effective approach is. Aside from that, just reading about all the challenges of adjusting to the CPAP or similar machines, I would like to have the full data of my sleep so that my doctors will be able to help me chose the best options. Sleep studies in my town run about $2,800 PLUS the fee of sleep doctor reading the results which could run over $500 I was told. But, I called elsewhere (looked up other sleep certified labs) and found prices are about $1,000 lower in the big city. Less convenient, but worth it. So, once I see my regular doctor on Feb 25 to get the "official" referral and his support, I am heading to the sleep doctor. Marianne "John Flanagan" <john.flana…@onemain.com wrote in message news:3e449da9.169229328@news.blacksburg.net… I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route. My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. I’ve waded through a lot of messages but haven’t really found anything to address my needs yet. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

I’m not aware of any contraindications if you have asthma.  I have had chronic bronchitis for years and developed adult onset asthma recently.  In addition, I believe there are other long time users posting here who have bad, bad, asthma, much worse than mine. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Marianne Eagan wrote:

Why is PAP contraindicated for asthma sufferers? I have asthma but have never had a conventional asthma attack. I only notice the asthma when I exercise as a kind of difficulty getting the air deep enough into my lung –the main symptom (though I was diagnosed with FULL asthma not just Exercise-Induced kind) and also when I’m around smoke of any kind (incense, cigarettes, etc).. I had a series of pulmonary tests to confirm this. So, if I am diagnosed with apnea, what are the alternatives? Marianne "LizNwilbur" <liznwil…@aol.com wrote in message news:20030208105356.01250.00000091@mb-fh.aol.com… My first suggestion would be to call a sleep lab, tell them you are private pay, ask for their lowest price for a "split-night" study.  They will probably be willing to do a split night for as much as a 50% discount if you are paying by cash or credit card, saving them the filing time and discounts applied by so many insurance carriers.  However, that being said, if you persist in your decision to purchase a used pap without a prescription, I would strongly recommend you only consider an AUTOPAP self-titrating machine, all the better if it comes with download software and cables.  Some brands of autopap  include autosetT, Goodknight 418A  or 418P,and Spirit autoset….read up on these before buying a cpap or bipap.You will most likely also want a heated humidifier that is compatible with your system. Keep in mind if you also have asthma, copd, and some other conditions, PAP may be contraindicated…or require close supervision by a pulmonary physician.

Response:

On Sun, 09 Feb 2003 22:23:21 GMT, NormC <no…@socal.rr.com

wrote: I find your post very gratifying.   Gratifying that you recognize the value of our collective experience, but especially because you presented your own logic and conclusions such as "most effective approach", "all the challenges of adjusting", "like to have full data". "I called elsewhere", "less convenient, but worth it", IMHO, brilliant.  I don’t recall any of the posts to you containing these phrases, so it certainly appears you have been thinking for yourself.  And you’ve already begun to help others, John, in particular.  That’s the way of this newsgroup.

Anything at this point is helpful of course, it at least gives me something to think about.  But what I really need are reasons "why" self remedy is dangerous.  Is there something that can happen to me? Pop a lung, etc :^)? I’ll be checking into the autopap that another poster mentioned but we shall see. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

"John Flanagan" <john.flana…@onemain.com

wrote in message

news:3e475bb0.348964244@news.blacksburg.net…

On Sun, 09 Feb 2003 22:23:21 GMT, NormC <no…@socal.rr.com wrote: But what I really need are reasons "why" self remedy is dangerous.  Is there something that can happen to me? Pop a lung, etc :^)? I’ll be checking into the autopap that another poster mentioned but we shall see. John

"Both of these devices (CPAP/BiPAP) currently require a sleep study (polysomnogram) to determine the proper pressure to use. If the pressure is too low, the airway may still collapse and obstruct, and if the pressure is too high, the device may not be tolerated or a different type of apnea (central apnea) may occur." http://www.talkaboutsleep.com/disorders/apnea/Apnea_Treatments.htm "CPAP pressure must be individually titrated (determine the amount to be used for a given result) and may need periodic adjustments if signs of symptoms warrant. Incorrect pressure settings may under-treat apnea resulting in arousal and movement, which may dislodge the device.  Alternately, too high a pressure increases spontaneous arousal, central apnea, and patient intolerance." http://www.mcw.edu/oto/treatment-osas.htm John, I understand being uninsured/under insured but apnea is one area you should really weight the consequences. Reality is that you will probably set the pressure to low and get almost no benefit or go to high on the pressure and still wake up feeling like crapola. Unless you have had a sleep study and know you have apnea, what about trying a cheap apnea test just for a starter. http://www.cpapman.com/influent.html You can go thru any doctor and the test is only $50. You could get $50 worth of free advice from joe (Cpapman) over the phone about what you are trying to accomplish. Just a thought! Mike

Response:

Anything at this point is helpful of course, it at least gives me something to think about.  But what I really need are reasons "why" self remedy is dangerous.  Is there something that can happen to me? Pop a lung, etc :^)?

as stated by others….. too low a pressure and you may THINK you have solved the problem but are still having apnea events still causing long term damage having too high a pressure has been known to cause central apnea – thereofre you’re defeating the problem of treating in the first place – and possibly making things worse.  There have been indications that it could even lead to death – which is why trained professionals monitor you during a sleep study. Also, if you don’t know what TYPE of apnea you have, you just cannot know what way to treat it. as for autopaps, you have to remember, that they dont’ always detect apnea in some people, so again, you need to have it monitored through a sleep study to know for sure. — Beth in Australia =================== FAQ for alt.support.sleep-disorder can be found here http://www.anchorweb.com.au/sleepdisorders this site is a work in progress – feel free to submit info/articles

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Marianne Eagan wrote:

John, I was planning on doing exactly what you are thinking of doing, but the people in this group convinced me to get a sleep study, which is what I’m going to do now. I think these people have enough experience to know what the safest, most effective approach is. Aside from that, just reading about all the challenges of adjusting to the CPAP or similar machines, I would like to have the full data of my sleep so that my doctors will be able to help me chose the best options. Sleep studies in my town run about $2,800 PLUS the fee of sleep doctor reading the results which could run over $500 I was told. But, I called elsewhere (looked up other sleep certified labs) and found prices are about $1,000 lower in the big city. Less convenient, but worth it. So, once I see my regular doctor on Feb 25 to get the "official" referral and his support, I am heading to the sleep doctor. Marianne

Marianne, I’m glad you are looking into a sleep study. Do check at – http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/gui to see if they have anything going on around you. Where you live you might also call the universities or teaching hospitals to see if they might have something. Trying to diagnose and titrate yourself is foolish. If you don’t have APNEA and try to treat yourself,  you can blow a bunch of money for equipment you might not need. In titrating yourself you can either have something hanging off your nose blowing air up it all night and annoying you while doing no good.  You can go the other way and have too high a pressure and induce central APNEA’s and possibly making yourself stop breathing. That is counterproductive to life. There are also other disorders that are picked up in the studies. Some will argue with the central APNEA’s and stopping breathing but I’ve been told this by board certified sleep doctors and sleep tech’s. Do you want to take that chance? If one could guess what pressure they need, why do they have titration? Many forget what exactly a CPAP does, it "splints" open the airway so you can breathe, it holds open the obstruction. It doesn’t just blast air down your airway so you can breathe. — Bob Gootee When you get to the end of your rope, tie a knot and hang on.

Response:

On Mon, 10 Feb 2003 03:29:18 -0600, "Lori&Mike" – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -<mpow…@nospamthe-beach.net

wrote: "Both of these devices (CPAP/BiPAP) currently require a sleep study (polysomnogram) to determine the proper pressure to use. If the pressure is too low, the airway may still collapse and obstruct, and if the pressure is too high, the device may not be tolerated or a different type of apnea (central apnea) may occur." http://www.talkaboutsleep.com/disorders/apnea/Apnea_Treatments.htm "CPAP pressure must be individually titrated (determine the amount to be used for a given result) and may need periodic adjustments if signs of symptoms warrant. Incorrect pressure settings may under-treat apnea resulting in arousal and movement, which may dislodge the device.  Alternately, too high a pressure increases spontaneous arousal, central apnea, and patient intolerance." http://www.mcw.edu/oto/treatment-osas.htm John, I understand being uninsured/under insured but apnea is one area you should really weight the consequences. Reality is that you will probably set the pressure to low and get almost no benefit or go to high on the pressure and still wake up feeling like crapola. Unless you have had a sleep study and know you have apnea, what about trying a cheap apnea test just for a starter. http://www.cpapman.com/influent.html You can go thru any doctor and the test is only $50. You could get $50 worth of free advice from joe (Cpapman) over the phone about what you are trying to accomplish. Just a thought! Mike

Thanks a lot Mike.  I know I have apnea, pretty certain it’s OSA, had some thoughts it could be CSA or possibly both.  I’ll check out the links you posted. Thanks again, John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

In article <3e460d72.263382…@news.blacksburg.net

,

john.flana…@onemain.com wrote:

I think you may be right about the correlation between her and her relatives.  My father has had a sleep study done because he has apnea (as his sister does too).  Perhaps I can go over the results of his study and see what the suggested remedy was.

Ross is referring to the fact that my setting was the lower of my two parents’. That said, their settings were close enough (9 and 10), that either would have worked for me. Still, knowing your father and aunt’s history might help. It might also make it easier to convince a physician. When I said that both my parents had apnea and were on CPAP, my doctor’s ears perked up. — _Deirdre                                             http://deirdre.net A: No. Q: Should I include quotations after my reply?

Response:

John, I was planning on doing exactly what you are thinking of doing, but the people in this group convinced me to get a sleep study, which is what I’m going to do now. I think these people have enough experience to know what the safest, most effective approach is. Aside from that, just reading about all the challenges of adjusting to the CPAP or similar machines, I would like to have the full data of my sleep so that my doctors will be able to help me chose the best options. Sleep studies in my town run about $2,800 PLUS the fee of sleep doctor reading the results which could run over $500 I was told. But, I called elsewhere (looked up other sleep certified labs) and found prices are about $1,000 lower in the big city. Less convenient, but worth it. So, once I see my regular doctor on Feb 25 to get the "official" referral and his support, I am heading to the sleep doctor. Marianne "John Flanagan" <john.flana…@onemain.com

wrote in message

news:3e449da9.169229328@news.blacksburg.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route. My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. I’ve waded through a lot of messages but haven’t really found anything to address my needs yet. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk

email I get.

So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

Why is PAP contraindicated for asthma sufferers? I have asthma but have never had a conventional asthma attack. I only notice the asthma when I exercise as a kind of difficulty getting the air deep enough into my lung –the main symptom (though I was diagnosed with FULL asthma not just Exercise-Induced kind) and also when I’m around smoke of any kind (incense, cigarettes, etc).. I had a series of pulmonary tests to confirm this. So, if I am diagnosed with apnea, what are the alternatives? Marianne "LizNwilbur" <liznwil…@aol.com

wrote in message

news:20030208105356.01250.00000091@mb-fh.aol.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

My first suggestion would be to call a sleep lab, tell them you are

private

pay, ask for their lowest price for a "split-night" study.  They will

probably

be willing to do a split night for as much as a 50% discount if you are

paying

by cash or credit card, saving them the filing time and discounts applied

by so

many insurance carriers.  However, that being said, if you persist in your decision to purchase a

used

pap without a prescription, I would strongly recommend you only consider

an

AUTOPAP self-titrating machine, all the better if it comes with download software and cables.  Some brands of autopap  include autosetT, Goodknight

418A

 or 418P,and Spirit autoset….read up on these before buying a cpap or bipap.You will most likely also want a heated humidifier that is

compatible

with your system. Keep in mind if you also have asthma, copd, and some

other

conditions, PAP may be contraindicated…or require close supervision by a pulmonary physician.

Response:

"bob" <bnj…@infi.net

wrote in message

news:b22r27$s8u$1@slb3.atl.mindspring.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

My question is the following:  If a person snores he may or may not have sleep apnea.  To have a sleep lab is expensive.  The costs run from $1000-$3000.  If you find that you have sleep apnea, the doctors normally require a second sleep study to determine the cpap  pressure requirements So That  will cost you another $1,000 – $3000.  They use to do split sleep labs tests, thus eliminating the need for two separate sleep lab tests. Now  they don’t want to do the split lab tests.  There are auto cpap

machine

(Computerized)  which use the flow  concept  to analyze a persons

breathing

to determine how to adjust the machines pressure A overnight test using

one

of these machines  could be used to determine if a person has apneas.  I

am

soliciting comments on this approach.

SNIP

Split studies still are done quite often. I had one last May at a fully-accredited lab.  I know several others who have the split studies at other labs. Cheers, Hal

Response:

"Tal" <talie…@i-o.net.au

wrote in message

news:b22udq$1818sm$1@ID-148111.news.dfncis.de… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

My question is the following:  If a person snores he may or may not have sleep apnea.  To have a sleep lab is expensive.  The costs run from $1000-$3000.  If you find that you have sleep apnea, the doctors

normally

require a second sleep study to determine the cpap  pressure

requirements

So That  will cost you another $1,000 – $3000.  They use to do split

sleep

labs tests, thus eliminating the need for two separate sleep lab tests. Now  they don’t want to do the split lab tests.  There are auto cpap machine (Computerized)  which use the flow  concept  to analyze a persons breathing to determine how to adjust the machines pressure A overnight test using one of these machines  could be used to determine if a person has apneas.  I am soliciting comments on this approach. I woudln’t advise this approach For a start, i’m not sure how many peopl ehave had to fork out the $6000+ you indicate – out of pocket…. most of the time insurance plays a part,

i

mean…isn’t that what insurances is for?

OP indicated lack of insurance and cash, so wouldn’t apply. About prices, I was floored when I receive the statement of coverage from my insurance! The study was $1650US, but they gave the insurance a deep discount of $850, so they just had to pay $800! Too bad they don’t charge that price for those without insurance! They are the ones that really need a break!!

Secondly, last i heard, split night studies were still quite common… perhaps YOUR sleep lab doesn’t do split studies anymore, but that doesn’t mean that that pracitce is world wide, or even country wide for that

matter Problem with split study is if you don’t get enough sleep. They tried to do a split study with me, but by the time I fell asleep and they confirmed OSA, they were out of time to titrate me. Thankfully, I do have insurance.

Having no trained professionals involved in your health care is never a

good

way to go. More importantly, autopaps dont’ always pick up all apnea.  ESPECIALLY if you’re apnea events aren’t associated with significant snoring.  You are also missing any other underlying problems, like narcolepsy, restless leg syndrome, periodic limb movment disorder, lack of REM sleep or lack of

Deep

sleep…all these things are VERY important!!

I have a very good friend in the OP’s position, no insurance and no cash. And by speaking with his wife, very, very likely with OSA. Bad combination! I wish I could offer an inexpensive solution, but I agree that there are too many variables you won’t be able to diagnose with playing with settings on a CPAP. May be better than not being able to try anything at all, though. I keep telling him to beg, borrow or steal the money as the benefits will allow him to feel much better and be better able to earn income in the first place. Well, maybe not steal, but get the money somehow! But then again, my setting on CPAP came at a guess. The GP prescribed 7, when that didn’t work, he upped me to 10 and ordered the sleep study. The study indicated 16, but I feel awful at 16. I have tried 14, same thing. 12 isn’t too bad, but I honestly feel best at 10. That’s where I’ve been since. Go figure! — Robert "If God had intended for us to see the sunrise, He would have scheduled it later in the day." (perform an exorcism for e-mail reply)

Response:

On Sat, 8 Feb 2003 14:57:14 -0700, "Robert" <rg…@commspeeddemon.net

wrote:

About prices, I was floored when I receive the statement of coverage from my insurance! The study was $1650US, but they gave the insurance a deep discount of $850, so they just had to pay $800! Too bad they don’t charge that price for those without insurance!

It’s called "negotiated rates." If you want to see some real price-slashing, look at what clinical labs get. I’ve seen in excess of 80% discounts.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -John Flanagan wrote:

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route. My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. I’ve waded through a lot of messages but haven’t really found anything to address my needs yet. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

John – Pay attention to what Deirdre said.  Although I am one who supports a full sleep test in a lab, "any island in a storm".  I don’t say that there are any right or wrong ways, just better or worse.   As I view it, the best way allows some of the mysteries of sleep apnea to be dealt with.  However, if you don’t have any of these mysteries, any way is the best way.

Response:

On Sat, 8 Feb 2003 12:42:39 -0800, ross…@mindspring.com (Ross Bernheim) wrote:

I get the feeling that you are a bit on the methodical side, so starting at a lower pressure and working your way up might, note I said might, be possible before you quit. However, I want to point out that the CPAP machines are a prescription only item for valid reasons. There are some real possibilities of doing yourself harm with an improperly set machine.

In what way can you harm yourself with improper settings? Overpressure (ie overfilling your lungs) would seem to be an obvious (and uncomfortable) one.  Are there other dangers?  I had planned to talk to the hospital an see what the doctor’s reaction and suggestions might be.  But the bottom line is I don’t have enough extra cash for both a sleep study and a CPAP.  Perhaps after talking to a doctor he might convince me that it’s the only safe route to go but right now I don’t see what specifically is the danger. I think you may be right about the correlation between her and her relatives.  My father has had a sleep study done because he has apnea (as his sister does too).  Perhaps I can go over the results of his study and see what the suggested remedy was. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

In article <1fq1zwa.1ohq20s1ykpucsN%ross…@mindspring.com

,

ross…@mindspring.com (Ross Bernheim) wrote:

Deirdre Saoirse Moen <deir…@deirdre.net wrote: The catch is, you can’t buy a CPAP machine under normal circumstances without a prescription. Legally, you’d also need a prescription to change the setting. I get the feeling that you are a bit on the methodical side, so starting at a lower pressure and working your way up might, note I said might, be possible before you quit. However, I want to point out that the CPAP machines are a prescription only item for valid reasons. There are some real possibilities of doing yourself harm with an improperly set machine.

Right, that’s why I thought it might be possible to go a quasi-legit route and get a prescription to rent an AutoPAP short-term.

But then again, I borrowed a CPAP from a family member while waiting for the healthcare system to catch up with me. It happens that it was set to the correct pressure, but I lucked out. Dierdra, given that you probably inherited your physical ’structure’ from your parents, it is not unlikely that a similar pressure would work for your apnea as well.

Allow me to make a macro for my name for you. ;) But yes, you’re right — I had an educated guess to start from.

This is something that only a full sleep study would really tell you. For most people, CPAPs are fine. A lot of people, like myself, need a heated humidifier. Then there’s the issue of masks, which are also not inexpensive (I use nasal pillows which tend to be less costly). I would go for a plain CPAP with heated humidifer over a BiPAP. Deirdra and I both have the Remstar Plus with their heated humidifier. A nice compact easy to use package. And one of the least expensive, which both our insurance companies liked.

Yep. I’ve logged 65.8 hours on it in the 10 days I’ve had it. And I’m about to log a whole bunch more. — _Deirdre                                             http://deirdre.net A: No. Q: Should I include quotations after my reply?

Response:

In article <3E4605A1.479A0…@socal.rr.com

, NormC <no…@socal.rr.com wrote: John – Pay attention to what Deirdre said.  Although I am one who supports a full sleep test in a lab, "any island in a storm".  I don’t say that there are any right or wrong ways, just better or worse.  

Well, I kinda expected to get thwapped, so I’m glad that others have chimed in. I know that, had I really thought about how the process might work when I couldn’t afford a sleep study, I may have had years of better sleep.

As I view it, the best way allows some of the mysteries of sleep apnea to be dealt with.  However, if you don’t have any of these mysteries, any way is the best way.

Well, there are still better and worse ways. — _Deirdre                                             http://deirdre.net A: No. Q: Should I include quotations after my reply?

Response:

John Flanagan wrote:

On Sat, 8 Feb 2003 12:42:39 -0800, ross…@mindspring.com (Ross Bernheim) wrote: I get the feeling that you are a bit on the methodical side, so starting at a lower pressure and working your way up might, note I said might, be possible before you quit. However, I want to point out that the CPAP machines are a prescription only item for valid reasons. There are some real possibilities of doing yourself harm with an improperly set machine. In what way can you harm yourself with improper settings?

Most of us here are willing to accept that there are one or more reasons that a prescription is required to buy one.

Overpressure (ie overfilling your lungs) would seem to be an obvious (and uncomfortable) one.  Are there other dangers?  

Overfilling your lungs is a matter of volume.  Overpressure is, as it says, a matter of pressure. More than one person posting here has indicated that when they were titrated, at some upper pressure they began to experience central apneas.  So the pressure was lowered. So, if you have the pressure too high, you could experience central apneas, which would mean you aren’t really receiving treatment, at all.  It doesn’t mean you’ll forever have CA, but it doesn’t make sense to me to mess around. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

I had planned to talk to the hospital an see what the doctor’s reaction and suggestions might be.  But the bottom line is I don’t have enough extra cash for both a sleep study and a CPAP.  Perhaps after talking to a doctor he might convince me that it’s the only safe route to go but right now I don’t see what specifically is the danger. I think you may be right about the correlation between her and her relatives.  My father has had a sleep study done because he has apnea (as his sister does too).  Perhaps I can go over the results of his study and see what the suggested remedy was. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong?

Unfortuantely, yes, you are.  The people that supervise you when you undergo a sleep study are trained to revive you if you’re about to die!  It’s not a matter of just bunging the thing on and playing around until you feel better, although published studies are few (that we’ve been able to find) there IS evidence to suggest that the wrong pressure can cause serious problems.

If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route.

If you can find the cash to buy a CPAP machine, you can find the cash to go about this the proper way – it may mean making a few sacrifices along the way, but it’s worth  your life isn’t it?

My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc.

that can only be determined through a sleep study…it entirely depends on what type of apnea you have (if any) and what pressure requirements you have – no two people are the same. — Beth in Australia =================== FAQ for alt.support.sleep-disorder can be found here http://www.anchorweb.com.au/sleepdisorders this site is a work in progress – feel free to submit info/articles

Response:

In article <3e449da9.169229…@news.blacksburg.net

,

john.flana…@onemain.com wrote:

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong?

You might ask what a home sleep study runs (the cheap-ass ones like Ross and I got). You might be have (or be able to get) the budget for that. The in-lab ones are expensive, but start at around $1000. I don’t know what the take-home studies run; my HMO paid for the whole thing. The catch is, you can’t buy a CPAP machine under normal circumstances without a prescription. Legally, you’d also need a prescription to change the setting. There may, however, be a way of sleazing the system, since sleep studies are done, in part, to satisfy requirements of insurance carriers. If you have a doctor who knows a DME (durable medical equipment supplier), what you may be able to do is to have him refer you directly to a DME and rent an AutoPAP for titration (in my case, that cost about $90 for a month, of which I had to pay 20%). Yes, this would require a doctor’s visit; the DME can’t do anything unless it’s prescribed. After titration, you can get a prescription and buy a CPAP. Not sure a doctor would go for it, but without an insurance company’s requirements or coverage, they might, especially a doctor who really was into preventative health care. If you post what area you’re in, someone might be able to refer you to a DME who might in turn be able to find you an appropriate doctor if you don’t already have one. BTW, my DME said that they do have units that were returned that they can’t rent out for new patients on insurance that they sell for a break to people who don’t have coverage for equipment, so that’s always worth asking about. The prices they were charging was easily in the same range as the stuff on eBay. So, if my intuition is right, you may be able to go a quasi-legit route, complete with long-term support, for about what you’re thinking about in the numbers below. Lots of people here will tell you to get a "real" sleep study in a certified lab. Yes, that is the ideal. However, if it takes you two years to get to the point where that’s a possibility, two years of lost sleep does a lot of damage to a body. I’m a pragmatist — I’d rather find a way to help you now. But then again, I borrowed a CPAP from a family member while waiting for the healthcare system to catch up with me. It happens that it was set to the correct pressure, but I lucked out.

My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc.

This is something that only a full sleep study would really tell you. For most people, CPAPs are fine. A lot of people, like myself, need a heated humidifier. Then there’s the issue of masks, which are also not inexpensive (I use nasal pillows which tend to be less costly). — _Deirdre                                             http://deirdre.net A: No. Q: Should I include quotations after my reply?

Response:

My first suggestion would be to call a sleep lab, tell them you are private pay, ask for their lowest price for a "split-night" study.  They will probably be willing to do a split night for as much as a 50% discount if you are paying by cash or credit card, saving them the filing time and discounts applied by so many insurance carriers.  However, that being said, if you persist in your decision to purchase a used pap without a prescription, I would strongly recommend you only consider an AUTOPAP self-titrating machine, all the better if it comes with download software and cables.  Some brands of autopap  include autosetT, Goodknight 418A  or 418P,and Spirit autoset….read up on these before buying a cpap or bipap.You will most likely also want a heated humidifier that is compatible with your system. Keep in mind if you also have asthma, copd, and some other conditions, PAP may be contraindicated…or require close supervision by a pulmonary physician.

Response:

Deirdre Saoirse Moen <deir…@deirdre.net

wrote: In article <3e449da9.169229…@news.blacksburg.net, john.flana…@onemain.com wrote: I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? You might ask what a home sleep study runs (the cheap-ass ones like Ross and I got). You might be have (or be able to get) the budget for that. The in-lab ones are expensive, but start at around $1000. I don’t know what the take-home studies run; my HMO paid for the whole thing.

My HMO paid for it all as well. The at home cheapo study is less expensive than the full up lab test, but they still aren’t cheap.

The catch is, you can’t buy a CPAP machine under normal circumstances without a prescription. Legally, you’d also need a prescription to change the setting.

I get the feeling that you are a bit on the methodical side, so starting at a lower pressure and working your way up might, note I said might, be possible before you quit. However, I want to point out that the CPAP machines are a prescription only item for valid reasons. There are some real possibilities of doing yourself harm with an improperly set machine. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

There may, however, be a way of sleazing the system, since sleep studies are done, in part, to satisfy requirements of insurance carriers. If you have a doctor who knows a DME (durable medical equipment supplier), what you may be able to do is to have him refer you directly to a DME and rent an AutoPAP for titration (in my case, that cost about $90 for a month, of which I had to pay 20%). Yes, this would require a doctor’s visit; the DME can’t do anything unless it’s prescribed. After titration, you can get a prescription and buy a CPAP. Not sure a doctor would go for it, but without an insurance company’s requirements or coverage, they might, especially a doctor who really was into preventative health care. If you post what area you’re in, someone might be able to refer you to a DME who might in turn be able to find you an appropriate doctor if you don’t already have one. BTW, my DME said that they do have units that were returned that they can’t rent out for new patients on insurance that they sell for a break to people who don’t have coverage for equipment, so that’s always worth asking about. The prices they were charging was easily in the same range as the stuff on eBay. So, if my intuition is right, you may be able to go a quasi-legit route, complete with long-term support, for about what you’re thinking about in the numbers below. Lots of people here will tell you to get a "real" sleep study in a certified lab. Yes, that is the ideal. However, if it takes you two years to get to the point where that’s a possibility, two years of lost sleep does a lot of damage to a body. I’m a pragmatist — I’d rather find a way to help you now.

There is a local DME here in Sunnyvale, California, CPAP Company and they have very good prices and service, they are on the web  at www.cpap-company.com  I can reccomend them highly. After a week on CPAP without a heated humidifier, which I had requested from the HMO when I knew I was going to get CPAP, but the insurance wouldn’t pay for, I needed to buy one NOW! The DME that the HMO and insurance company sent me to was very expensive. I found the CPAP Company on-line. Phoned Monday morning and picked up my heated humidifer, at a price as good as any on-line, that afternoon.

But then again, I borrowed a CPAP from a family member while waiting for the healthcare system to catch up with me. It happens that it was set to the correct pressure, but I lucked out.

Dierdra, given that you probably inherited your physical ’structure’ from your parents, it is not unlikely that a similar pressure would work for your apnea as well.

My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. This is something that only a full sleep study would really tell you. For most people, CPAPs are fine. A lot of people, like myself, need a heated humidifier. Then there’s the issue of masks, which are also not inexpensive (I use nasal pillows which tend to be less costly).

I would go for a plain CPAP with heated humidifer over a BiPAP. Deirdra and I both have the Remstar Plus with their heated humidifier. A nice compact easy to use package. And one of the least expensive, which both our insurance companies liked. Ross Bernheim

Response:

My question is the following:  If a person snores he may or may not have sleep apnea.  To have a sleep lab is expensive.  The costs run from $1000-$3000.  If you find that you have sleep apnea, the doctors normally require a second sleep study to determine the cpap  pressure requirements So That  will cost you another $1,000 – $3000.  They use to do split sleep labs tests, thus eliminating the need for two separate sleep lab tests. Now  they don’t want to do the split lab tests.  There are auto cpap

machine

(Computerized)  which use the flow  concept  to analyze a persons

breathing

to determine how to adjust the machines pressure A overnight test using

one

of these machines  could be used to determine if a person has apneas.  I

am

soliciting comments on this approach.

I woudln’t advise this approach For a start, i’m not sure how many peopl ehave had to fork out the $6000+ you indicate – out of pocket…. most of the time insurance plays a part, i mean…isn’t that what insurances is for? Secondly, last i heard, split night studies were still quite common… perhaps YOUR sleep lab doesn’t do split studies anymore, but that doesn’t mean that that pracitce is world wide, or even country wide for that matter Having no trained professionals involved in your health care is never a good way to go. More importantly, autopaps dont’ always pick up all apnea.  ESPECIALLY if you’re apnea events aren’t associated with significant snoring.  You are also missing any other underlying problems, like narcolepsy, restless leg syndrome, periodic limb movment disorder, lack of REM sleep or lack of Deep sleep…all these things are VERY important!! — Beth in Australia =================== FAQ for alt.support.sleep-disorder can be found here http://www.anchorweb.com.au/sleepdisorders this site is a work in progress – feel free to submit info/articles

Response:

My question is the following:  If a person snores he may or may not have sleep apnea.  To have a sleep lab is expensive.  The costs run from $1000-$3000.  If you find that you have sleep apnea, the doctors normally require a second sleep study to determine the cpap  pressure requirements So That  will cost you another $1,000 – $3000.  They use to do split sleep labs tests, thus eliminating the need for two separate sleep lab tests. Now  they don’t want to do the split lab tests.  There are auto cpap machine (Computerized)  which use the flow  concept  to analyze a persons breathing to determine how to adjust the machines pressure A overnight test using one of these machines  could be used to determine if a person has apneas.  I am soliciting comments on this approach. "John Flanagan" <john.flana…@onemain.com

wrote in message

news:3e449da9.169229328@news.blacksburg.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route. My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. I’ve waded through a lot of messages but haven’t really found anything to address my needs yet. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk

email I get.

So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

I’ve long known I have at least OSA.  I need to get some good sleep so I have some energy when I wake up, bad.  I’ve never seen a doctor about it because I don’t have insurance nor the cash to pay for it. But it doesn’t seem like rocket science.  Experiment until you get some real sleep on a consistant basis.  Am I wrong? If this doesn’t work for my I could always resell the CPAP machine on Ebay.  I certainly don’t have the cash to go the "official" route. My question is what kind of CPAP may be best, or better how do I go about determining what kind and what brand may be best for me?  I would like to spend less than $500 if possible.  Should I go for Bi-pap if I can?  Etc. I’ve waded through a lot of messages but haven’t really found anything to address my needs yet. John Please note that my return address is wrong due to the amount of junk email I get. So please respond to this message through the newsgroup.

Response:

Breathing, Anxiety, and Asthma

Question:

But there is not hiding the fact that Buteyko on record failed to produce any improvement in lung functions. To keep plugging any quack therapy for a potentially life-threatening disease is irresponsible. Interestingly, the placebo group in another asthma breath therapy trial (Chest, 1357-61 (1992)) also showed a reduction in medication comparable to the verum group in the Brisbane trial of Buteyko. The basis of Buteyko would seem to be the hypnotic effect of breathing exercises and the anagelsic action of carbon dioxide. If Buteyko advocates are really so interested in the welfare of asthmatics and a physical training approach to asthma, they should try out SIMT, which has bona fide credentials, though the number of participants in a trial was low. Breathing through an SIMT device of the adjustable orifice type stimulates and probably trains the diaphragm and also correctively steps up carbon dioxide. This would be theoretically twice as effective as the original B. Yoga has also done well in studies. Just why should B be better than, say, alternate nostril breathing (nadi sodhanna) which reduces the respiration rate and stimulates the diaphragm? Regards, Richard Friedel – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Conversely, quoting from the trial report: "the reduction in medication use in the BBT group did not lead to a decline in lung function" Which does not indicate that Buteyko had any effect.  Since there was no comparison with a placebo group for medication reduction – the most likely explanation is that the patients were overmedicated. There was a placebo group the receiving ‘conventional’ breathing therapy. I quote: "In the control group, subjects were given general asthma education and relaxation techniques, and were taught abdominal breathing exercises which did not involve hypoventilation." Both groups were given the same instruction to "use beta2-agonists only when symptomatic". The medication reduction was statistically significant when compared to this group. Norman <snip

Response:

Conversely, quoting from the trial report: "the reduction in medication use in the BBT group did not lead to a decline in lung function" Which does not indicate that Buteyko had any effect.  Since there was no comparison with a placebo group for medication reduction – the most likely explanation is that the patients were overmedicated.

There was a placebo group the receiving ‘conventional’ breathing therapy. I quote: "In the control group, subjects were given general asthma education and relaxation techniques, and were taught abdominal breathing exercises which did not involve hypoventilation." Both groups were given the same instruction to "use beta2-agonists only when symptomatic". The medication reduction was statistically significant when compared to this group. Norman <snip

Response:

But it sounds like you’re still on active duty.  So you continue to have my support as you continue to go about serving your country.

I leave active duty on 8 Sept 2003 – "unless otherwise extended." — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Where is there any proof of this in a medical periodical or the like for docs to go by? Forcing the lungs to function with a higher carbon dioxide level simply by breathing less does not put a handle on asthma in terms of better peakflows etc. Carbon dioxide is an anagelsic (this does NOT happen to mean a cure for all ailments!). Soothes the patient but probably makes him dangerously unaware of his clinical condition. The possibility of self-appointed Buteyko asthma experts in action must lead to more Milgram scenarios. Such "experts" think they have "authority" to administer a treatment without, like a proper doctor, being aware of doing a lot of harm through insensitivity and of scientific method. What about differential diagnosis?  Regards, Richard Friedel – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – relaxation and gentle reduction of respiration volume has been the preferred therapeutic method for over a year. Breath holds are only used for measurement of progress and the breath is held only until the first small (slight) discomfort is felt.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Nice to see you back here, Colin. Thanks.  Nice to be back online. I have discovered that I am not in as good physical shape as I thought I was.  Prior to being activated I would jog a couple of miles and I considered myself to be in excellent shape. Yesterday for "Leader’s Physical Training" we did an "easy" 3 mile run – carrying a 30 pound rucksack.  Next week the ‘Leaders PT" will be an ‘easy’ 2 mile run – up a mountains (10% slope). And yes, I am in pain today.

Welcome back, Colin. But it sounds like you’re still on active duty.  So you continue to have my support as you continue to go about serving your country. — Steven D. Litvintchouk                  

Response:

Nice to see you back here, Colin.

Thanks.  Nice to be back online. I have discovered that I am not in as good physical shape as I thought I was.  Prior to being activated I would jog a couple of miles and I considered myself to be in excellent shape. Yesterday for "Leader’s Physical Training" we did an "easy" 3 mile run – carrying a 30 pound rucksack.  Next week the ‘Leaders PT" will be an ‘easy’ 2 mile run – up a mountains (10% slope). And yes, I am in pain today. — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Colin nice to see you posting.  You stay safe ok!  UM MOM Susan

Response:

One of the odd things about Buteyko is as follows: If an asthmatic slows down his breathing, this may curb an emerging attack. This might be due to accumulation of carbon dioxide. Studies show that breathing air enriched with carbon dioxide may in certain circumstances relax the airways in asthmatics. All well and good, but why in all the world use such murderous techniques as breath holding for 1 minute plus to stock up carbon dioxide, if a gentle reduction in respiration rate does the trick just as well? In any case, breath hold time may be short in a perfectly normal subject.

I’m afraid you’re out of touch with the latest Buteyko teaching, relaxation and gentle reduction of respiration volume has been the preferred therapeutic method for over a year. Breath holds are only used for measurement of progress and the breath is held only until the first small (slight) discomfort is felt. As I started Buteyko over 4 years ago I was taught the more extended breath holds. However I was also told that if I found the breath holds more than a little uncomfortable I was overdoing it. In my view ‘murderous’ is clearly overdoing it. Buteyko is obviously a cult with its own "sacred knowledge" (unquestionable irrational belief). Regards, Richard Friedel

I’m sorry Richard. I cannot equate the above with my experience of Buteyko. Norman <snip

Response:

One of the odd things about Buteyko is as follows: If an asthmatic slows down his breathing, this may curb an emerging attack. This might be due to accumulation of carbon dioxide. Studies show that breathing air enriched with carbon dioxide may in certain circumstances relax the airways in asthmatics. All well and good, but why in all the world use such murderous techniques as breath holding for 1 minute plus to stock up carbon dioxide, if a gentle reduction in respiration rate does the trick just as well? In any case, breath hold time may be short in a perfectly normal subject. Buteyko is obviously a cult with its own "sacred knowledge" (unquestionable irrational belief). Regards, Richard Friedel – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Almost right. In fact Buteyko recommends using the minimum preventer required to keep asthma under control, which BTW is now the main stream recommendation. My experience is that using Buteyko has reduced my preventer dosage requirement dramatically. Many people report, after some months of Buteykoing, a successful reduction to zero. In this case, a set of PFTs would be in order.  The Brisbane trial demonstrated that Buteyko can affect the patients perception of asthma symptoms while producing no objective improvement in airways function. (Something I bet they did not tell you.) — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Nice to see you back here, Colin. Joan

Response:

Conversely, quoting from the trial report: "the reduction in medication use in the BBT group did not lead to a decline in lung function"

Which does not indicate that Buteyko had any effect.  Since there was no comparison with a placebo group for medication reduction – the most likely explanation is that the patients were overmedicated. Also, we all know that the claim in the report that the patients were screened for hyperventilation syndrome was a lie.  This means that we cannot be sure that all the participants in the trial even had asthma. so the trial confirms that after just 3 months a significant reduction in medication can be achieved without loss of lung function.

Wrong.  It does not confirm this.  If the Buteyko supporters are making this claim then they are lying again. BTW, why are the Buteyko supporters using this trial to support their position when they know that it is tainted with academic fraud? — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Almost right. In fact Buteyko recommends using the minimum preventer required to keep asthma under control, which BTW is now the main stream recommendation. My experience is that using Buteyko has reduced my preventer dosage requirement dramatically. Many people report, after some months of Buteykoing, a successful reduction to zero. In this case, a set of PFTs would be in order.  The Brisbane trial demonstrated that Buteyko can affect the patients perception of asthma symptoms while producing no objective improvement in airways function. (Something I bet they did not tell you.)

Conversely, quoting from the trial report: "the reduction in medication use in the BBT group did not lead to a decline in lung function" so the trial confirms that after just 3 months a significant reduction in medication can be achieved without loss of lung function. My experience is that improvements over the following months continue and are retained long term. Norman <snip

Response:

Almost right. In fact Buteyko recommends using the minimum preventer required to keep asthma under control, which BTW is now the main stream recommendation. My experience is that using Buteyko has reduced my preventer dosage requirement dramatically. Many people report, after some months of Buteykoing, a successful reduction to zero.

In this case, a set of PFTs would be in order.  The Brisbane trial demonstrated that Buteyko can affect the patients perception of asthma symptoms while producing no objective improvement in airways function. (Something I bet they did not tell you.) — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Buteyko doesn’t recommend reducing preventers. In fact he says carry on with them.

Almost right. In fact Buteyko recommends using the minimum preventer required to keep asthma under control, which BTW is now the main stream recommendation. My experience is that using Buteyko has reduced my preventer dosage requirement dramatically. Many people report, after some months of Buteykoing, a successful reduction to zero. you are taught to breath less deeply at the first signs of any tightness in the chest/airways…hence you don’t really notice mild attacks as long as you aren’t being active at the time…so you reduce your use of medication…you then start acting as a publicist for B*teyko…next is the first serious attack and B*teyko is sod all use to deal with it, but it’s almost inevitable, because you’ve reduced the use of preventer medication…the B*teyko cult then tells you that you have been doing it wrong and need to shell out more money to learn how to do it better

I am unable to equate the text above with my experience of Buteyko. Wrong on every count. We are taught to breath less _all_ of the time and to _increase_ our physical activity. We are taught to retain our reliver but only use it if we can’t control an attack with Buteyko. Usually I can. When I started Buteyko I spent about