from a new asthmatic
Question:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – cut When I was first diagnosed, I saw a chiropractor for the back pain. He referred me to a "nutritionalist" who also tried to sell me "miracle" cures for asthma. She said once I got the poisons out of my body I would be able to give up the inhalers. What set off the bells and whistles was the bee pollen she recommended as well as my cautious nature. I left and have not returned to even the chiropractor. I now control the back pain with a back massager, yoga and if it is really bad, pain reliever. cut tassle
best thing I ever did for back pain (slipped discs 3 times, various trapped nerves mostly relating to a road accident) was see a physiotherapist…she taught me a set of exercises to strengthen the muscles in my back…now I only have trouble if I really push things way too hard…best of all the treatment is entirely under my control, has NO side effects, and is completely free
eric
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – To all who would listen, I woke up in the middle of the night 9 weeks ago and I couldn’t breathe. I thought I was having a heart attack. It was the most terrifieing moment of my life. I could hardly cry out to my daughter to call 911. After a quick trip to the emergency room, a ER doctor took all of 5 minutes examining me a told me I had possible asthma, so he stuck a cannister of Albuterol in my hand and sent me home. I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do?
It sounds like your ‘asthma’ is still not controlled, with 5 attacks a day. This may indicate the need to increase the dose of inhaled steroid, Vanceril in your case. If you are using regular Vanceril (42 ug beclomethasone/puff), it’s a weak dose. Better steroid inhalers include Vanceril Double Strength; and better yet Pulmicort and Flovent inhalers. It is now recommended most asthmatics monitor their lung function at home using a peak flow meter. When peak flow drops into Yellow Zone (50-80% of personal best) asthma meds are increased, usually double inhaled steroids and use albuterol as needed. Albuterol is a safe drug in high doses, but the need for high doses tends to indicate insufficient long-acting preventor drugs like inhaled steroids. Asthma is diagnosed with lung function tests. Lung function measured before and after administering bronchodilator like albuterol. A 12% improvement tends to support an asthma diagnosis, since asthma is a reversible disease. Note that there are some asthma look alike conditions to be ruled out. If a heart problem is suspected, an EKG monitored treadmill test might be indicated. –cut–
Ellis
Response:
While the most cases per year of age are diagnosed during childhood, asthma cases continue to be diagnosed throughout adulthood. Because adulthood lasts so much longer than childhood the majority of cases are diagnosed in adults, with a median age in the thirties (most of my pediatrician colleagues don’t believe this and all of my internist colleagues do). The persistence of your symptoms will depend on what the triggers are and if they can be removed. If this is all from an infection that can be eradicated you may only have rare symptoms when experiencing similar infections. If you have other triggers your success may depend on how well you avoid them. It is possible that despite great effort your problems will continue for the rest of your life. Most likely they will wax and wane over time. As for the issue of specialist referral, this should be done on an individual basis. Different people are easier to control and have different issues. Not all primary care doctors are equally equipped to handle all diseases (not all specialists are equal either for that matter). Most asthmatics are well managed without the help of a specialist. It sounds like your doctor has taken the correct initial steps. If a convincing diagnosis is obtained and your disease is well controlled then there probably is no need for a referral. If things are not going well, then obviously something should change and referral is one possibility. Whether this should be to a pulmonologist, allergist, ENT, gastroenterologist, or others should be dictated by the suspicions of the reasons for treatment failure. — Good Luck, CBI, M.D. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – To all who would listen, I woke up in the middle of the night 9 weeks ago and I couldn’t breathe. I thought I was having a heart attack. It was the most terrifieing moment of my life. I could hardly cry out to my daughter to call 911. After a quick trip to the emergency room, a ER doctor took all of 5 minutes examining me a told me I had possible asthma, so he stuck a cannister of Albuterol in my hand and sent me home. I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do? I am a web page designer so I am very familiar with searching the Web for information. But I wasn’t prepared for the amount of info you get when you investigate the causes and remedies for Asthma. There is so much info out in the world on the subject that I don’t know what is true and what is bunk. And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way. (None of them have asthma) I had a guy at my local health foo store tell me he had asthma and he completely cured himself through diet along. Then he tried to sell me $200.00 worth of stuff to clean out all the poisons in my body. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such? Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)? Once you aquire this, do you suffer from it for the rest of your lives? All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it. Or that I must be having a reaction to something so find out what it is and stay away from it. My sister even went so far to say she thinks it is all in my head. My doctor seems to be gearing up to take care of this in the long term sense and that scares the hell out of me. I feel like I am the only person in my town that has this problem. No one I know has asthma and no one seems to know anything about it. I thank God I found this NG, because it allowed me to releive some of my fears. I hope I haven’t rambled on too much but this has been very therapudic for me. On one hand I fear asthma, but on the other hand I thank God it was not anything fatal or completely debilitating. I am a single Dad with a teenage daughter and I have to be there for her. This is such a crutial time in in child rearing stage that what I am afraid of is that I won’t be able to be there for her. It is my mission in life to get her off on a good life. I appologize for the long post, I won’t do it again. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am. If anyone can give me some insight on this new chapter in my life please feel free to post or e-mail me. (Jim Howard)
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -To all who would listen, I woke up in the middle of the night 9 weeks ago and I couldn’t breathe. I thought I was having a heart attack. It was the most terrifieing moment of my life. I could hardly cry out to my daughter to call 911. After a quick trip to the emergency room, a ER doctor took all of 5 minutes examining me a told me I had possible asthma, so he stuck a cannister of Albuterol in my hand and sent me home. I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do? I am a web page designer so I am very familiar with searching the Web for information. But I wasn’t prepared for the amount of info you get when you investigate the causes and remedies for Asthma. There is so much info out in the world on the subject that I don’t know what is true and what is bunk. And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way. (None of them have asthma) I had a guy at my local health foo store tell me he had asthma and he completely cured himself through diet along. Then he tried to sell me $200.00 worth of stuff to clean out all the poisons in my body. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such? Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)? Once you aquire this, do you suffer from it for the rest of your lives? All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it. Or that I must be having a reaction to something so find out what it is and stay away from it. My sister even went so far to say she thinks it is all in my head. My doctor seems to be gearing up to take care of this in the long term sense and that scares the hell out of me. I feel like I am the only person in my town that has this problem. No one I know has asthma and no one seems to know anything about it. I thank God I found this NG, because it allowed me to releive some of my fears. I hope I haven’t rambled on too much but this has been very therapudic for me. On one hand I fear asthma, but on the other hand I thank God it was not anything fatal or completely debilitating. I am a single Dad with a teenage daughter and I have to be there for her. This is such a crutial time in in child rearing stage that what I am afraid of is that I won’t be able to be there for her. It is my mission in life to get her off on a good life. I appologize for the long post, I won’t do it again. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am. If anyone can give me some insight on this new chapter in my life please feel free to post or e-mail me.
1. Many people develop asthma later in life. 2. About 1 in 20 people have asthma, so you probably DO know some asthmatics, you just don’t know that they are asthmatics. 3. Herbs and homeopathy don’t work. 4. Give it some time; with a good treatment plan, you can live a long, happy, healthy life. Chris Owens
Response:
I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do?
Current medical doctrine is to use the stronger asthma medications in order to get immediate control then use the lower strength medications for maintenance. It can take several weeks for an inhaled steroid like Vanceril to show effects. I am a web page designer so I am very familiar with searching the Web for information. But I wasn’t prepared for the amount of info you get when you investigate the causes and remedies for Asthma. There is so much info out in the world on the subject that I don’t know what is true and what is bunk.
Stick with ‘mainstream’ sites such as the JAMA asthma site. Stay away from any site that is selling anything. And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way. (None of them have asthma) I had a guy at my local health foo store tell me he had asthma and he completely cured himself through diet along.
Homeopathy has been tested in controlled clinical trials and found useless for the treatment of asthma. If there were a ‘natural’ treatment for asthma that was both safe and effective then asthma would have been cured hundreds of years ago. Likewise, dietary treatment of asthma has been tested – and found useless except in cases where there is a specific food allergy. And if you suspect a food allergy you need to be treated by a specialist as food allergies are very dangerous. Then he tried to sell me $200.00 worth of stuff to clean out all the poisons in my body. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such? Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)?
Alternative medicine has been shown to be very effective at transferring money from your wallet tho theirs. Other than that it does not do much. Adult onset asthma is not uncommon. I was diagnosed at age 35. Once you aquire this, do you suffer from it for the rest of your lives? All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it. Or that I must be having a reaction to something so find out what it is and stay away from it. My sister even went so far to say she thinks it is all in my head. My doctor seems to be gearing up to take care of this in the long term sense and that scares the hell out of me.
Your doctor seems to be the only person with a brain. Listen to him. Asthma is a serious chronic (you have it for life) disease. There is no cure (and anybody who even implies that they can cure asthma is a fraud). You should expect that you are going to be on anti inflammatory medications for the foreseeable future. I feel like I am the only person in my town that has this problem. No one I know has asthma and no one seems to know anything about it.
You would be surprised at how many people around you have asthma. We tend to not make a fuss about it. For every 20 people you meet, one of them will have asthma. I appologize for the long post, I won’t do it again. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am. If anyone can give me some insight on this new chapter in my life please feel free to post or e-mail me.
No problem. My first post to this newsgroup was similar to yours. "Usenet is like a herd of performing elephants with diarrhea — massive, diffucult to redirect, awe-inspiring, entertaining, and a source of mind boggling amounts of excrement when you least expect it." Gene Spafford 1992
Response:
To all who would listen, I woke up in the middle of the night 9 weeks ago and I couldn’t breathe. I thought I was having a heart attack. It was the most terrifieing moment of my life. I could hardly cry out to my daughter to call 911. After a quick trip to the emergency room, a ER doctor took all of 5 minutes examining me a told me I had possible asthma, so he stuck a cannister of Albuterol in my hand and sent me home. I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do? I am a web page designer so I am very familiar with searching the Web for information. But I wasn’t prepared for the amount of info you get when you investigate the causes and remedies for Asthma. There is so much info out in the world on the subject that I don’t know what is true and what is bunk. And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way. (None of them have asthma) I had a guy at my local health foo store tell me he had asthma and he completely cured himself through diet along. Then he tried to sell me $200.00 worth of stuff to clean out all the poisons in my body. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such? Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)? Once you aquire this, do you suffer from it for the rest of your lives? All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it. Or that I must be having a reaction to something so find out what it is and stay away from it. My sister even went so far to say she thinks it is all in my head. My doctor seems to be gearing up to take care of this in the long term sense and that scares the hell out of me. I feel like I am the only person in my town that has this problem. No one I know has asthma and no one seems to know anything about it. I thank God I found this NG, because it allowed me to releive some of my fears. I hope I haven’t rambled on too much but this has been very therapudic for me. On one hand I fear asthma, but on the other hand I thank God it was not anything fatal or completely debilitating. I am a single Dad with a teenage daughter and I have to be there for her. This is such a crutial time in in child rearing stage that what I am afraid of is that I won’t be able to be there for her. It is my mission in life to get her off on a good life. I appologize for the long post, I won’t do it again. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am. If anyone can give me some insight on this new chapter in my life please feel free to post or e-mail me. (Jim Howard)
Response:
And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way
A homeopathic doctor nearly killed me. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such?
No Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)?
I was 33 All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it.
If this is asthma you will need to learn to live with it. Don’t trust a GP. You need to see a pulmonologist. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am.
I freaked out too. And then I learned to live with the asthma. There are amazing drugs now. Good luck. Carol
Response:
Your frustration and fear is totally justified. Although I began my asthmatic chapter at 12, I have heard of others getting it later on in life. My best advice is to RUN from anyone that wants to only treat you with herbs and such…straight into the arms of a good pulmonologist. I’m not saying that a general practioner doesn’t know anything about asthma, but you want to trust your lungs to whoever knows the most. I wish you the best of luck. Don’t worry, I’m sure that once your asthma is under contol, you will be able to be there again for your daughter. You sound like a great dad. Keep up the good work! *hugs* Ash http://www.angelfire.com/tn/Ashleigh1976/index.html Try smiling, it won’t kill you and might even brighten your day.
Response:
Ahhh, I’m 41 and have had asthma most of my life. Once it’s controlled and you have your inhaler with you at all times it is no big deal. We are sooo lucky to have rescue inhalers, they work like a miracle. I suffered the 1st 18 years of my life with my asthma not being treated, luckily I didn’t die, I’m so grateful they have great medicines today. Make sure your doctor gives you preventative inhalers or meds also and don’t just rely on you rescue breather. You may e-mail me any time. I also am a single parent raising 2 teenagers. Just the thought of it sometimes makes me want to hyperventilate! :-) (Just kidding, I have it pretty together!) Good luck and don’t be afraid to e-mail me any time! Marilyn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – To all who would listen, I woke up in the middle of the night 9 weeks ago and I couldn’t breathe. I thought I was having a heart attack. It was the most terrifieing moment of my life. I could hardly cry out to my daughter to call 911. After a quick trip to the emergency room, a ER doctor took all of 5 minutes examining me a told me I had possible asthma, so he stuck a cannister of Albuterol in my hand and sent me home. I went to my doctor and she immediately prescribed more Albuterol and Vanceril. I have had many tests done and I am still waiting for the results of my pulumonary functions test. No one seems to be able to answer any of my questions. The doctors are basicaly saying that they don’t know if this is permanenet or just temporary. They don’t know what has caused this or why. I have never had any resporatory illness or problems in my life. I have been lifting weights and exercising for many years and can (or used to be able to) run full speed for one hour on a treadmill. I have an attack 4 or 5 times a day. I use the Albuterol and it seems to work but a couple of times it didn’t work and I had to use more than 2 puffs to be able to breathe. I know your not supposed to do this but if you can’t breath, what are you supposed to do? I am a web page designer so I am very familiar with searching the Web for information. But I wasn’t prepared for the amount of info you get when you investigate the causes and remedies for Asthma. There is so much info out in the world on the subject that I don’t know what is true and what is bunk. And I have friends who are into homeopathic remedies who are telling me to throw away my medicines because I don’t need them. They are saying asthma can be cured the natural way. (None of them have asthma) I had a guy at my local health foo store tell me he had asthma and he completely cured himself through diet along. Then he tried to sell me $200.00 worth of stuff to clean out all the poisons in my body. Can asthma be controlled by herbs and vitamins and such? Has anybody ever heard of getting asthma at my age (40 yrs)? Once you aquire this, do you suffer from it for the rest of your lives? All my friends do not take this serious. They tell me I’ll get over it. Or that I must be having a reaction to something so find out what it is and stay away from it. My sister even went so far to say she thinks it is all in my head. My doctor seems to be gearing up to take care of this in the long term sense and that scares the hell out of me. I feel like I am the only person in my town that has this problem. No one I know has asthma and no one seems to know anything about it. I thank God I found this NG, because it allowed me to releive some of my fears. I hope I haven’t rambled on too much but this has been very therapudic for me. On one hand I fear asthma, but on the other hand I thank God it was not anything fatal or completely debilitating. I am a single Dad with a teenage daughter and I have to be there for her. This is such a crutial time in in child rearing stage that what I am afraid of is that I won’t be able to be there for her. It is my mission in life to get her off on a good life. I appologize for the long post, I won’t do it again. If it sounds like I freaking out it is because I am. If anyone can give me some insight on this new chapter in my life please feel free to post or e-mail me. (Jim Howard)
Categories:
