OT: Depo Provera
Question:
In article – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I sympathize. I, too, was on Depo and gained and experienced a host of side effects that included aggression and some that were a little more personal, if you get my drift. Doc theorized that my reaction to depo may have been caused by my use of steroids for asthma–that the steroids "enhanced" the effect of the hormones in Depo. He switched me back to the pill, and I’m back to "normal." I also lost the extra fifteen pounds I had gained while on Depo. Good luck to you. Amy
I had trouble with depo provera (pills) but had even more trouble with megace, also a synthetic progesterone. I wasn’t taking either of the two for birth control, but for uterine hyperplasia. Now, I take prometrium, and, while it slows weight loss, and makes me dizzy and sleepy while on it, it doesn’t do the depression thing, the excessive weight gain thing, or the heart pain thing. All in all, it’s a good choice. — Nancy Howells (don’t forget to switch it, and replace the
to send mail).
Response:
I am diabetic and Depo Provera really screwed up my blood sugar. I was losing weight before going on it but that went out the window too. I am now on a generic pill form of progesterone along with a progesterone IUD and its still causing problems. Oh and I feel like c–p. I had bouts of queasiness for the first few months and I am tired all the time, even when I get up in the morning. The problem is I too have endometrial hyperplasia and its so advanced it was originally misdiagnosed as cancer. I have to take the stuff no matter how much I hate it. Debra
Response:
If I didn’t mention it… I’m a diabetic too. And no BG problems on Depo. I’ve maintained non-diabetic A1cs for five years, taken every three months. Every body is different. Jennifer – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am diabetic and Depo Provera really screwed up my blood sugar. I was losing weight before going on it but that went out the window too. I am now on a generic pill form of progesterone along with a progesterone IUD and its still causing problems. Oh and I feel like c–p. I had bouts of queasiness for the first few months and I am tired all the time, even when I get up in the morning. The problem is I too have endometrial hyperplasia and its so advanced it was originally misdiagnosed as cancer. I have to take the stuff no matter how much I hate it. Debra
Response:
I understand. Depo Provera made me a hungry moody woman. It makes your body think you are pregnant. Finally got my tubes tied last year. Was afraid at first but the best thing I think I could have done. I am spade. Jennifer S. 206/159/135
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
Response:
The world breathes a sigh of relief. — You take stupid to a new level. – MFW
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am spade.
Response:
I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs.
Ouch. My best friend went on depo and actually lost a little weight for the two years she was on it. Then she went off, and WOW! She gained over 30lbs, at a rate of a little over a pound a DAY. It was insane, that stuff really messes you up. That was years ago, and she never has been able to get it off either. LCing since 12/01/03- Me- 5′7" 265/166/140 & hubby- 6′ 310/188/180 http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/lcer09/my_photos
Response:
Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks.
You might want to look elsewhere for your weight gain. My wife has been on Depo Provera since the mid-eighties and is 105lb and 5′4". Of my five daughters, two are also using it; both are slim and healthy. It is highly unlikely that Depo Provera would increase weight by as much as 40lbs without it becoming a widely known and well publicised fact. I have had many clients use it and only once was weight gain mentioned and it was in the order of a few pounds that was quickly lost, not in the magnitude that you are suggesting. In some cases they had switched from an estrogen/progestin based product to Depo Provera in order to reduce weight. Regards David — To reply, please include the letters DNF anywhere in the subject line. All other mail is automatically deleted.
Response:
Quit making excuses and try eating less. — Most people are dumb as bricks; some people are dumber than that. – MFW
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. You might want to look elsewhere for your weight gain. My wife has been on Depo Provera since the mid-eighties and is 105lb and 5′4". Of my five daughters, two are also using it; both are slim and healthy. It is highly unlikely that Depo Provera would increase weight by as much as 40lbs without it becoming a widely known and well publicised fact.
I thought it was a widley known fact. A question, have your wife or daughters ever tried to go off the depo? Come to think of it, was depo even out in the mid 80s? Was she in a test market or something? LCing since 12/01/03- Me- 5′7" 265/166/140 & hubby- 6′ 310/188/180 http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/lcer09/my_photos
Response:
And yet it is a wonder drug for me. No weight gain… no mood swings…
yep, me too.
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
I’m sorry you had such a bad reaction to it. Myself, I’ve lost 50 pounds on low-carb, while on Depo the whole time. Everyone’s body is different, and mine _loves_ Depo-Provera. No cramps, no PMS, no feeling like I have the flu every month, it’s been great for me. — Michelle Levin http://www.mindspring.com/~lunachick I have only 3 flaws. My first flaw is thinking that I only have 3 flaws.
Response:
You might want to look elsewhere for your weight gain. My wife has been on Depo Provera since the mid-eighties and is 105lb and 5′4". Of my five daughters, two are also using it; both are slim and healthy. It is highly unlikely that Depo Provera would increase weight by as much as 40lbs without it becoming a widely known and well publicised fact. I thought it was a widley known fact.
No, it isn’t. It known that *some* women experience a small, non-permanent weight gain, nothing like the gain attributed to Depo Provera by the OP. According to Australian Pharmaceutical testing both prior to approval and subsequent to approval, the average gain in test subjects who were already more than 10% overweight resulted in an average gain of 5.3lbs over twelve months and 8.2 lbs over twenty-four months. With women in a normal healthy weight range at the start of testing, weight gain was slight in the early stages and not extant at the twelve month marker. In women of normal weight who exercised regularly the weight gain was not apparent. The real risk with Depo Provera is far more serious, but relatively easy to circumvent. It accelerates osteoporosis rather dramatically. The included documentation notes this but many women who use it do not take a daily calcium supplement and are now experiencing bone density losses. A question, have your wife or daughters ever tried to go off the depo?
Yes, after a kidney infection and hospital stay my wife stopped for nearly a year. One daughter stopped for two years to have a baby. Neither had weight problems, *but* as I often emphasise, they all are very active people with daily exercise as a part of their lifestyle. We have always had a swimming pool and lived in waterfront homes, so they are used to swimming, kayaking, tennis and walking (dogs) as a part of their everyday routine when growing up. Even when moving to city apartments they continue to exercise. All are gym members and all walk or jog daily. We have also had very healthy eating habits, fresh foods, much of it home grown (permaculture is a hobby of mine) nothing with preservatives or chemicals, low saturated fats etc. My children grew up without an excess of snack foods or candy, they were reserved for special treats, and they were not allowed soft drinks (sodas) at all. They were given natural fruit flavoured mineral water. I worked in fitness and weight-loss areas with a number of women who used Depo Provera and was quite interested in the result of changes to their metabolism & fitness levels etc., and monitored them quite carefully. I have very detailed records on more than four hundred clients, mostly women, and always monitored any changes in medication, diet, birth control and have noted no negative changes when beginning or ending Depo Provera. I am not keen on any chemical/pharmaceutical intervention in a person’s body, but this is a choice made for convenience by women and is not based on a man’s opinion on optimum health potential. If I were a woman I suspect that I would override my doubts and do the same. Depo Provera seems to be one birth control option that (in an otherwise healthy woman) seems to have little negative effect. Come to think of it, was depo even out in the mid 80s? Was she in a test market or something?
Depo Provera was released in Australia in the late seventies. My wife went onto it in the eighties after several of her friends from high school had been using it without ill effect for several years. LCing since 12/01/03- Me- 5′7" 265/166/140 & hubby- 6′ 310/188/180 http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/lcer09/my_photos
Just had a peek at your photo’s. Looking good, doing well. <g Regards David — To reply, please include the letters DNF anywhere in the subject line. All other mail is automatically deleted.
Response:
No, it isn’t. It known that *some* women experience a small, non-permanent weight gain, nothing like the gain attributed to Depo Provera by the OP.
<shrug Without exception, every single person I know IRL has had adverse affects from depo-prevera. Normal weight or not, active and healthy or not. I have to widen my scope and get on the internet to find people who don’t have problems. Myself, I’d never touch the stuff. Not for any amount of money. LCing since 12/01/03- Me- 5′7" 265/166/140 & hubby- 6′ 310/188/180 http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/lcer09/my_photos
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself.
My sister had very similar results with Depo Provera! She’d always been fit and never overweight before, either. After starting that, she quickly gained 20 pounds, then more slowly added another 5 or 10 pounds. Even after getting off it… she’s had to struggle with her weight ever since. Good luck getting it out of your system. — Spring LC since 1/1/04 260/208/170 http://f2.pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/sprgsnow/album?.tok=phX4sVBBuvxvs4Hs… Size: 24W / 14 / 10
Response:
Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs.
I sympathize. I, too, was on Depo and gained and experienced a host of side effects that included aggression and some that were a little more personal, if you get my drift. Doc theorized that my reaction to depo may have been caused by my use of steroids for asthma–that the steroids "enhanced" the effect of the hormones in Depo. He switched me back to the pill, and I’m back to "normal." I also lost the extra fifteen pounds I had gained while on Depo. Good luck to you. Amy
Response:
I don’t know exactly how much I put on with the Depo – but over 6 years it was over two stones. I came off in September last year and had a 3 year implant instead. I lost half a stone in the first three months which is the first weight loss in the 5 years I have been diagnosed t2. I don’t know if the previous weight gain was to do with the diabetes, 3 years of insulin or the depo but the only thing I do know is I had never been able to lose weight with anything before I came off the depo. Only regret is now I am back to TOM’s. I have also lost another 8 lbs since low carbing.- since August. LOL Linda
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
Response:
Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
Response:
And yet it is a wonder drug for me. No weight gain… no mood swings… And I’m not bleeding to the point of needing a blood transfusion again. Which I was, due to fibroids. Jennifer – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello all, 2 years ago I went on Atkins and lost 50 lbs in 6 months. I stayed on it and was on maintenance when I made a dreaded mistake. I started taking Depo Provera shots (birth control) and in the year since that fateful decision I have (while still on Atkins) gained back 40 lbs. I had my last shot in July and am due for the next in 2 weeks. Needless to say I will not be getting it. I am so absolutely miserable, but more than that I am really pissed at the medical community for misleading me about "possible weight gain". They said I could gain up to 5 lbs, but that was PER shot. Not only that but I am moody, irritable, tired constantly, have no energy or ambition to leave the house for anything (not even shoe shop which is my favorite thing). I attributed all of these things to weight gain, but didn’t clue in that the weight gain was a symptom of the bigger problem. This drug is BAD news. I have gone to a Nutritionist to find out how to "detox" my body and hopefully I will be back on the road to losing weight and feeling good about myself. Just wanted to share. Lori "To the world you might be one person but to one person you just might be the world" -unknown
Categories:
