Posts belonging to Category 'Stop Asthma'

Healpful hint

Question:

I am not a salesman, nor will I ever make a cent from this hint.

Interesting statement that you are "not a salesman." http://x76.deja.com/getdoc.xp?AN=713183160 http://x76.deja.com/getdoc.xp?AN=713189233 Which read like this: http://x76.deja.com/getdoc.xp?AN=713183281 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Newsgroups: alt.inventors … I also sell a do-it-yourself Patent Pending Kit for $29.95 or I can get it Patent Pending for you for $150 or plus $75 Patent Office fees. If your tired of Asthma and you are willing to try something new that has no side effects and want something that will stop asthma attacks immediately then try Stabilized Oxygen, one brand is WaterOz.  There are others, and some that don’t work, but health food stores usually have Stabilized Oxygen.  Use 25 drops in a glass of water each day, or twice a day in very bad cases, or more if needed. I have given this stuff to a number of friends who had asthma and some children.  In all cases it took less than 10 minutes to stop an asthma attach.  I also used this Stabilized Oxygen in the jungle to treat various difficulties.  It’s totally safe.  Hundreds of thousands of people have used it for 55 years.  Unlike all medical drugs which cause many deaths each year.  Not one death has ever been associated with Stabilized Oxygen.  Good luck.

I’ve had previous encounters with this "Stabilized Oxygen." There was a past Fergus post: http://x74.deja.com/getdoc.xp?AN=606886705 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Author: Fergus … When USA Today carried a full-page ad last year for a mysterious tincture called "Vitamin O," described as "stabilized oxygen molecules in a solution of distilled water and sodium chloride," few noticed that the ad was describing common salt water. Clearly, the manufacturer, Rose Creek Health Products, was betting on the public’s unfamiliarity with scientific lingo to make a killing in the lucrative homeopathic market. It seemed a pretty safe bet: The company was selling 60,000 of the 2-ounce vials each month, retailing at $20 apiece, after ads promised Vitamin O would increase energy and even cure cancer. The premise was that our bodies need oxygen to function well but air quality is so poor that most of us don’t get the oxygen we need. Then Robert Park, a physics professor at the University of Maryland, exposed the scam in his provocative weekly electronic newsletter, "What’s New," which reports on science issues. A subsequent interview with Park on National Public Radio raised enough public pressure to cause the Federal Trade Commission to investigate. Three months later, the FTC charged the supplier with fraud and ultimately closed down the company.

Then there’s this: http://x53.deja.com/[ST_rn=ps]/getdoc.xp?AN=608157561 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Author: Bob Park … DIETARY SUPPLEMENT: THE RETURN OF "VITAMIN O."  In November of 1998, USA Today carried a full page ad for "Vitamin O."  What was it? "Vitamin O contains stabilized oxygen molecules in a solution of sodium chloride and distilled water" (WN 27 Nov 98). After we called attention to the ad, the Federal Trade Commission charged the supplier, Rose Creek Health Products, with fraud (WN 19 Mar 99), and the company was shut down.  This week, we became aware of a new oxygen supplement, BiOxygen, offered by Beverly Sassoon & Co., … And what is BiOxygen?  "The components of BiOxygen are water, sodium chloride, and activated oxygen molecules." One difference: a two ounce bottle of BiOxygen costs $34.95, compared to only $20 for "Vitamin O."  The recommended dose is again 15-20 drops, twice a day, or roughly 0.0000002% of your minimum daily requirement for oxygen.

// Here’s a free recipe for anyone wanting to try saline solution stabilized oxygen: 1) Fill cup with water 2) Add NaCl to taste 3) Insert straw into the water 4) Blow gently through straw into the water 5) Drink quickly OR 5) Store solution in bottle and later apply it to other drinks using an eyedropper If you’re very picky, replace "breath of life" with medical oxygen. // Incidentally, if a reader finds themself without electricity for a fish tank oxygenator, insert straw into tank and exhale slowly through the straw into the water. // "Fraud and murder create hard enough mysteries when the people and objects involved are unique.  When they aren’t…." G. David Nordley

Response:

I am not a salesman, nor will I ever make a cent from this hint.  If your tired of Asthma and you are willing to try something new that has no side effects and want something that will stop asthma attacks immediately then try Stabilized Oxygen, one brand is WaterOz.  There are others, and some that don’t work, but health food stores usually have Stabilized Oxygen.  Use 25 drops in a glass of water each day, or twice a day in very bad cases, or more if needed.

How is this stuff supposed to work?  The oxygen content of the stuff would be so low as to be irrelevant to the human body. "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

I am not a salesman, nor will I ever make a cent from this hint.  If your tired of Asthma and you are willing to try something new that has no side effects and want something that will stop asthma attacks immediately then try Stabilized Oxygen, one brand is WaterOz.  There are others, and some that don’t work, but health food stores usually have Stabilized Oxygen.  Use 25 drops in a glass of water each day, or twice a day in very bad cases, or more if needed. I have given this stuff to a number of friends who had asthma and some children.  In all cases it took less than 10 minutes to stop an asthma attach.  I also used this Stabilized Oxygen in the jungle to treat various difficulties.  It’s totally safe.  Hundreds of thousands of people have used it for 55 years.  Unlike all medical drugs which cause many deaths each year.  Not one death has ever been associated with Stabilized Oxygen.  Good luck.

Response:

Medical Science knows 'nuts' about treating virus diseases!!!

Question:

The concept of "it takes a poison to kill a poison" is actually better applied to homeopathy than orthodox medicine….as I understand it anyway.

I’d say this is basically the basis of cancer chemotherapy as well… Spencer Cox

Response:

The concept of "it takes a poison to kill a poison" is actually better applied to homeopathy than orthodox medicine….as I understand it anyway. I’d say this is basically the basis of cancer chemotherapy as well…

Ahh, nicely put, and of course absolutely true :o ) It works though <shrugs but then cancer is a weird mix of entities.  What works for one type doesn’t work for another, and of course may not work for everyone. The bane of multicellular organisms…. Bennett

Response:

Hi Bennett,

Hello again. If, you are talking about medical science advance in the know-how on surgery, to treat ‘orthodox sickness (germ derived sickness ie. cancer)

Hmmm…some cancers are "germ-derived", in that a virus can cause them (I understand "germs" to mean infectious diseases in general) but fundamentally they are a defect in the genetic stability and growth characteristics of a cell.  Anyhow. or anesthestic, I would agree with you that, medical science really advanc tremedulously in these fields, but, to say that, medical science knows how to treat mankind sickness, especially on those ‘mysterious/unorthodox (virus derived sickness ie. aids), medical science is still in primary stage of understanding on how thes mysterious sickness came about.

I disagree.  While there undoubtedly is a lot still needed to learn, I’d say we are beyond the "primary stage" of understanding.  In most cases the virus can be identified, transmission routes are known, virulence factors (not quite the right term, but good enough) are understood, and in a few cases there are even means to help clear or control the infection.  In most cases though there isn’t anything to beat the good old fashioned immune response :o ) As I mentiones earlier, come to think of it, without the invention on antibiotics, what is there for medical science to offer, as medicine to treat mankind sickness?

The cardiovascular drugs are a good example.  We can control abnormal heart rhythms, correct high blood pressure, prevent blood clots or even dissolve them once they’ve formed. We can modulate the immune response to prevent or stop asthma attacks, psoriasis, colitis, rheumatoid arthritis, even transplant rejection (and transplants themselves are one of the triumphs of surgery). In our medical field, sometimes, we apply this sort of understanding as a kind of tactic in treating sickness successfully, they are as follows, ‘it takes a poison, to kills a poison’.

To some extent that’s right for antibiotics – they are usually derived from actual products of other bacteria that are used in real life to kill off competitors. So far, medical science applied this sort of understanding, such as, the application in using antibiotics (antibiotics derived from bacterial, as a kind of ‘raw material’) to treat most mankind sickness.

Most?  Not really.  In the developed world infectious diseases have been removed from their primary role as causing mortality and morbidity, and as a result other diseases (such as cancer and heart diseases) are more common instead.  These require different approaches.  Others phrases, such as, to treat an ‘unorthodox sickness’, one got to treat it with ‘unorthodox herbs’, has yet to be understood by medical science. Don’t you agree?

Depends on what you exactly mean by "unorthodox sickness".  Most drugs start life as "unorthodox herbs", since an awful lot as I recall are derived in some way from plant products (although usually modified in the lab for greater stability/stronger action/better absorption etc). The concept of "it takes a poison to kill a poison" is actually better applied to homeopathy than orthodox medicine….as I understand it anyway. If you could clarify what you understand by orthodox medicine, maybe with examples, I’d have a better idea of where you’re coming from. Cheers Bennett

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Ohhh! I see, you are a guy, studying medicine!! Indeed, but mainly lab work ATM.  Also a qualified masseur. Tell me, how to prevent cancer??? Depends which one.  They’re all different. Pls, make sure that, at the end of the day, you, yourself, don’t die from cancer!!!!  LOL   LOL Yeah, I’m doubled up with laughter.  With a 1in3 chance of suffering sometime during my life (something like 1in4 chance of dying from cancer) it’s not really a laughing matter. You mean, by coming overhere, are you trying to promote those ‘powerful antibiotics’ for PWAs? Well, seems I’ve been "here" a whole lot longer than you.  I’m not really promoting anything, if you follow the main discussions on the group. I’d recommend antiviral therapy for those with sufficient evidence of a severely compromised immune system, because all the evidence shows that the dysfunction can be reversed with positive clinical benefits (in other words people don’t die so much).  I occasionally speculate or comment on new data as it arrives. I didn’t address the rest of your original post, since it’s largely a rant against orthodox medicine, and an uninformed one at that, but from having seen both sides of the fence I’d say that orthodox medicine has a whole lot better grasp on treating human disease than any other approach.  Does it have failings?  Yup – and some of those are better addressed by another approach, but on the whole it does okay.  I’d like to see a stronger amalgam between various complementary medical fields and the orthodox medical practise, but until people like yourself stop shouting from the rooftops that isn’t going to happen (and both sides are at fault here).  A little sensibility is called for. Cheers Bennett

Hi Bennett, If, you are talking about medical science advance in the know-how on surgery, to treat ‘orthodox sickness (germ derived sickness ie. cancer) or anesthestic, I would agree with you that, medical science really advanc tremedulously in these fields, but, to say that, medical science knows how to treat mankind sickness, especially on those ‘mysterious/unorthodox (virus derived sickness ie. aids), medical science is still in primary stage of understanding on how thes mysterious sickness came about. As I mentiones earlier, come to think of it, without the invention on antibiotics, what is there for medical science to offer, as medicine to treat mankind sickness? In our medical field, sometimes, we apply this sort of understanding as a kind of tactic in treating sickness successfully, they are as follows, ‘it takes a poison, to kills a poison’. So far, medical science applied this sort of understanding, such as, the application in using antibiotics (antibiotics derived from bacterial, as a kind of ‘raw material’) to treat most mankind sickness. Others phrases, such as, to treat an ‘unorthodox sickness’, one got to treat it with ‘unorthodox herbs’, has yet to be understood by medical science. Don’t you agree? Danny — University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Opinions expressed are mine – I’ll take the rap for my own mistakes. (swap cam for spam to reply via email) A half-truth is like half a brick: You can throw it further

Before you buy.

Response:

University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Ohhh! I see, you are a guy, studying medicine!!

Indeed, but mainly lab work ATM.  Also a qualified masseur. Tell me, how to prevent cancer???

Depends which one.  They’re all different. Pls, make sure that, at the end of the day, you, yourself, don’t die from cancer!!!!  LOL   LOL

Yeah, I’m doubled up with laughter.  With a 1in3 chance of suffering sometime during my life (something like 1in4 chance of dying from cancer) it’s not really a laughing matter. You mean, by coming overhere, are you trying to promote those ‘powerful antibiotics’ for PWAs?

Well, seems I’ve been "here" a whole lot longer than you.  I’m not really promoting anything, if you follow the main discussions on the group.  I’d recommend antiviral therapy for those with sufficient evidence of a severely compromised immune system, because all the evidence shows that the dysfunction can be reversed with positive clinical benefits (in other words people don’t die so much).  I occasionally speculate or comment on new data as it arrives. I didn’t address the rest of your original post, since it’s largely a rant against orthodox medicine, and an uninformed one at that, but from having seen both sides of the fence I’d say that orthodox medicine has a whole lot better grasp on treating human disease than any other approach.  Does it have failings?  Yup – and some of those are better addressed by another approach, but on the whole it does okay.  I’d like to see a stronger amalgam between various complementary medical fields and the orthodox medical practise, but until people like yourself stop shouting from the rooftops that isn’t going to happen (and both sides are at fault here).  A little sensibility is called for. Cheers Bennett — University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Opinions expressed are mine – I’ll take the rap for my own mistakes. (swap cam for spam to reply via email) A half-truth is like half a brick: You can throw it further

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If, medical science don’t even understand, how and why our ‘heart’ is situated on the ‘left-side’ Something to do with homeobox genes, as I recall. And it’s central, not "to the left".  It’s just that the heatbeat is best felt on the left side of the chest :o ) <trivia Quiet a few people have survived shootings, as their assailant has shot to the left and missed the heart, thereby giving them the slightly less nasty wound of a punctured lung. Also, the heart actually begins life as a simple tube, and folds up into the 4-chambered organ we know and love.  During the 2-3 months this takes, it continues to beat….  Astonishing. </trivia Bennett — University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine

Ohhh! I see, you are a guy, studying medicine!! Tell me, how to prevent cancer??? Pls, make sure that, at the end of the day, you, yourself, don’t die from cancer!!!!  LOL   LOL You mean, by coming overhere, are you trying to promote those ‘powerful antibiotics’ for PWAs? Opinions expressed are mine – I’ll take the rap for my own mistakes. (swap cam for spam to reply via email) A half-truth is like half a brick: You can throw it further

Before you buy.

Response:

If, medical science don’t even understand, how and why our ‘heart’ is situated on the ‘left-side’ Something to do with homeobox genes, as I recall.

Danny would say homoboxoffice and be as close to reality as his ‘cum Herbals’ are :~) — Gary Stein http://www.mischealthaids.org "Usenet is like a herd of performing elephants with diarrhea massive, difficult to redirect, awe-inspiring, entertaining, and a source of mind- boggling amounts of excrement when you least expect it."          (Gene Spafford) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And it’s central, not "to the left".  It’s just that the heatbeat is best felt on the left side of the chest :o ) <trivia Quiet a few people have survived shootings, as their assailant has shot to the left and missed the heart, thereby giving them the slightly less nasty wound of a punctured lung. Also, the heart actually begins life as a simple tube, and folds up into the 4-chambered organ we know and love.  During the 2-3 months this takes, it continues to beat….  Astonishing. </trivia Bennett — University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Opinions expressed are mine – I’ll take the rap for my own mistakes. (swap cam for spam to reply via email) A half-truth is like half a brick: You can throw it further

Response:

Path: reader4.news.rcn.net!feed1.news.rcn.net!rcn!cpk-news-hub1.bbnplanet.co m!news.gtei.net!nntp2.deja.com!nnrp1.deja.com!not-for-mail Newsgroups: misc.health.aids Organization: Deja.com – Before you buy. Lines: 32 NNTP-Posting-Host: 203.117.33.25 X-Http-User-Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 5.0; Windows 95) X-Http-Proxy: 1.1 sbproxy3 (NetCache 4.0R4DEBUG4), 1.0 x53.deja.com:80 (Squid/1.1.22) for client 203.117.39.191, 203.117.33.25 X-MyDeja-Info: XMYDJUIDyangdanny4321 Xref: reader4.news.rcn.net misc.health.aids:78027

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If, medical science don’t even understand, how and why our ‘heart’ is situated on the ‘left-side’ (in wholistic term, the left-side of our human body is called the ‘moonside’) or why our ‘purity blood’ is more active (in its circulation) during nightfall, how’d the hell, medical science is able to find a cure for any sort of virus sicknesses, let alone, the deadly aids virus!!! In fact, medical science knows ‘nuts’ in understanding a human sickness, in-making or come about!! One consolation to medical science is, fortunately, they (medical science) discovered ‘antibiotic’ for treating most of human sickness, otherwise, there is not much medicines, medical science could offer, lucky for for medical science!! Anyway, what happen now? Without understanding the inherency of those antibiotic’s active principle, medical science is to be blamed for all those ‘antibiotic resistent’ cases, suffered by hardcore patients , that  ’misused’ antibiotics, previously. You tell me, is medical science really understood the application of medicine to treat human sickness?? Danny Yang An Asian Wholistic Physician cum Herbalist Before you buy.

This message was posted 5 times in one day to the misc.health.aids newsgroup and appears be a commercial solicitation. And also appears to be qwackery of the most foul kind ie attempting to entice terminally ill patients to unsubstantiated, untested, fake/false medical treatment. — Gary Stein

Response:

If, medical science don’t even understand, how and why our ‘heart’ is situated on the ‘left-side’

Something to do with homeobox genes, as I recall. And it’s central, not "to the left".  It’s just that the heatbeat is best felt on the left side of the chest :o ) <trivia Quiet a few people have survived shootings, as their assailant has shot to the left and missed the heart, thereby giving them the slightly less nasty wound of a punctured lung. Also, the heart actually begins life as a simple tube, and folds up into the 4-chambered organ we know and love.  During the 2-3 months this takes, it continues to beat….  Astonishing. </trivia Bennett — University of Cambridge Dept of Medicine Opinions expressed are mine – I’ll take the rap for my own mistakes. (swap cam for spam to reply via email) A half-truth is like half a brick: You can throw it further

Response:

If, medical science don’t even understand, how and why our ‘heart’ is situated on the ‘left-side’ (in wholistic term, the left-side of our human body is called the ‘moonside’) or why our ‘purity blood’ is more active (in its circulation) during nightfall, how’d the hell, medical science is able to find a cure for any sort of virus sicknesses, let alone, the deadly aids virus!!! In fact, medical science knows ‘nuts’ in understanding a human sickness, in-making or come about!! One consolation to medical science is, fortunately, they (medical science) discovered ‘antibiotic’ for treating most of human sickness, otherwise, there is not much medicines, medical science could offer, lucky for for medical science!! Anyway, what happen now? Without understanding the inherency of those antibiotic’s active principle, medical science is to be blamed for all those ‘antibiotic resistent’ cases, suffered by hardcore patients , that  ’misused’ antibiotics, previously. You tell me, is medical science really understood the application of medicine to treat human sickness?? Danny Yang An Asian Wholistic Physician cum Herbalist Before you buy.

Response:

Magnetic Therapy

Question:

My first visit to this group as I figured you all here probably know more about the diffrerent ways to relieve pain than anyone else. I finished chemotherapy for breast cancer at the beginning of January. I’m doing well and starting to feel normal again finally. However about a month after finishing chemo I started getting aches and pains all over my body. From what I have read this is quite common for chemo patients. They say it eventually goes away. For some quite quickly, for others, not for years. Have there been any discussions on this group about magnetic therapy that someone can point me to? I would imagine that this subject has been discussed here. I’m asking about the products that you would buy directly from the manufacturer with a money-back guarantee. Not the stuff that they have for sale in most stores that you walk into. Any info would be appreciated. Thanx, jane

Response:

Hi Jane, If you’re interested, we have an online magnetic therapy guide and lots of info posted at our web site: http://www.magnapak.com/index.html Good luck! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – My first visit to this group as I figured you all here probably know more about the diffrerent ways to relieve pain than anyone else. I finished chemotherapy for breast cancer at the beginning of January. I’m doing well and starting to feel normal again finally. However about a month after finishing chemo I started getting aches and pains all over my body. From what I have read this is quite common for chemo patients. They say it eventually goes away. For some quite quickly, for others, not for years. Have there been any discussions on this group about magnetic therapy that someone can point me to? I would imagine that this subject has been discussed here. I’m asking about the products that you would buy directly from the manufacturer with a money-back guarantee. Not the stuff that they have for sale in most stores that you walk into. Any info would be appreciated. Thanx, jane

Before you buy.

Response:

OK. You have finally made a statement of fact.  How does a therapeutic magnet differ from a refrigerator magnet?

Hi William,     You know, I think you’ve firmly established your skepticism of magnets.  If you feel the need to repeatedly challenge someone over the subject of magnets, why not take on the people selling them and leave people who are only posting about their experiences alone? Denise

Response:

I just rec’d a magnet strip from a rep of Nikken. Does anyone know anything about this company?

Multi-loser marketing scam, apparently based in Japan.  Recently, several ‘reps’ have been spamming the support groups.  They’ve got a website, but it doesn’t have much info on the products, only on the organization and commission structure. My curiousity is almost, but not quite, to the point of going to look to see if there really are any published double-blind studies on the use of magnets for pain treatment… — DO NOT SEND UNSOLICITED BULK MAIL TO THIS ADDRESS

Response:

My curiousity is almost, but not quite, to the point of going to look to see if there really are any published double-blind studies on the use of magnets for pain treatment…

    Hi Howard,        I’ve taken the liberty of reprinting a report on a double-blind study on magnets for pain relief that Marlynn was kind enough to post awhile ago.              Coincidently, there was a brief segment on Dateline (NBC) tonight regarding magnets. A doctor at Vanderbilt (I think) has been doing research on them for years.  He was the 27th doctor this teenager in Tennesee had been to seeking pain relief.  The kid even had his appendix taken out ‘coz some doc thought that was the source of the pain.  The magnets worked for the kid and NBC did refer to this Baylor study.  (see, Marlynn, I *do* pay attention to this stuff!;) Denise Subj:    Re: Re Baylor Study on Post Polio Patients Here is a news release about the magnet therapy research at Baylor College of Medicine. Magnet therapy reduces pain in post-polio patients         HOUSTON–(Nov. 3, 1997)–A small magnet strapped to post-polio patients’ most sensitive sore spots reduced pain acutely in a study of 50 people at Baylor College of Medicine and The Institute for Rehabilitation and Research (TIRR) in Houston.         Results of the double-blind study were published in the November issue of the Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation.         "The majority of patients in the study who received treatment with a magnet reported a significant decrease in pain, and most of the patients who were given a placebo, or inactive magnet, reported very little or no improvement," said principal investigator Dr. Carlos Vallbona.  He is a professor of family and community medicine and physical medicine and rehabilitation at Baylor and director of the Post-Polio Clinic at TIRR.         Vallbona evaluated the magnet therapy in adults diagnosed with post-polio syndrome who were experiencing arthritic pain in the joints or had identifiable points of pain in their muscles.  Thirty-nine women and 11 men participated in the study.  Most were in their 50s and had developed post-polio syndrome during their 40s.         All patients were asked to press on the "trigger point" where they felt the severest pain and rank that pain on a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the worst.  The patients were then randomly given an active or inactive magnet to strap against their trigger point for 45 minutes. After the magnets were removed, patients rated the intensity of their pain again.         Twenty-nine participants received an active magnet.  Their average score of pain was 9.6 before the treatment, and 4.4 after wearing the magnet. The placebo group had an average pain score of 9.5 before treatment, and 8.4 afterward.         The low-intensity magnets, less than a half-inch thick and slightly stronger than refrigerator magnets, were available in four formats to accommodate different areas of the body: a credit-card- size rectangle, a six-inch strip almost two inches wide, a disc the size of a silver dollar and a disc the size of a CD.         "Seventy-six percent of the patients who had the active magnet reported a decrease in pain, but only 19 percent of the patients treated with a placebo felt an improvement," Vallbona said.  None of the patients reported any side effects from the treatment.         "We do not have a clear explanation for the significant and quick pain relief observed by the patients in our study," Vallbona said.  "It’s possible that the magnetic energy affects the pain receptors in the joints or muscles or lowers the sensation of pain in the brain."         The Baylor-TIRR study consisted of one treatment per patient and did not evaluate how long the reported pain relief lasted.  Vallbona said more research is needed to determine whether magnet therapy should be recommended as an alternative to the standard treatments for pain in post-polio patients, such as physical therapy, support braces, muscle relaxants, anti-inflammatory drugs and other medication.         Vallbona’s co-principal investigator for the study was Dr. Carlton F. Hazlewood, Baylor professor of molecular physiology and biophysics.         BIOflex, Inc., a company in Corpus Christi, Texas, provided magnets for the study.                                

Response:

What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into. — Ron Joiner

Response:

What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into. — Ron Joiner

Sorry "OA" in the neck.

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? WB

Response:

: Magnetic Therapy What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into.

Hi Ron, I personally use magnets and do find them very helpful.  I have used them for many years for arthritis in my fingers, hips and chronic lower back pain. The ones that I use and hightly recommend are called "rare earth neodymium" magnets.  They are a very small (size of a dime) and have the strength of one 20 times their size. A new book just came out called Magnet Therapy – The Pain Cure Alternative by Drs. Ron Lawrence and Paul J. Rosch.  I purchased mine at Barnes & Nobel.  It’s filled withe interesting information, lots of case studies, many of which deal with arthritic sufferers.  They talk about this specific type of magnet and the ways in which it can be used to help alleviate pain;  much of which I have discovered on my own just by using and experimenting over the past years.  I’ve also learned a lot of new things. These are permanent magnets not electro magnets.  These are not the ones that they were talking about being cancer producing.  AND, as a matter of fact,a study came out recently with proof of the fact that the electro magnetic fields that surround some areas (high tension wires, etc.) are not cancer producing. I don’t know this personally, I am just relating what I have heard.  The only thing that I can vouch for personally is that these permanent magnets do work for hundreds of thousands of people world wide and have for many years. If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to ask.  I think I’m the only one on the board that uses this particular type of magnet.  They are the newest technology today in magnet field therapy.  All magnets are not the same and there are lots of companies out there selling garbage for very high prices.  These magnets are also not expensive, non-invasive to the body except for their energy, and will not harm anyone the way so many of the meds do. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. —

Hi Norman, Read the book that I mentioned in my previous post.  I think that you will find it very enlightening.   Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects?

Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big Alternative by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects.

I am sorry that my sarcasm did not get throught in my original post.  I was trying to emphasize the ridiculous attribution of therapeutic capability to magnetism.  This practice dates back at least as far as Mesmer.  Benjamin Franklin showed that the principle at work was gullability. You mention case studies, but you do not mention CONTROLLED studies. This message is not aimed at you personally.  It is aimed at all who pomulgate unsubstantiated health claims. William Buchman

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big Alternative by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects. I am sorry that my sarcasm did not get throught in my original post.  I was trying to emphasize the ridiculous attribution of therapeutic capability to magnetism.  This practice dates back at least as far as Mesmer.  Benjamin Franklin showed that the principle at work was gullability. You mention case studies, but you do not mention CONTROLLED studies. This message is not aimed at you personally.  It is aimed at all who pomulgate unsubstantiated health claims. William Buchman </PRE</HTML

Billy, I didn’t realize that you posted this to the board.  I though it was to me personally.  If you would like to post my answer to you I have no objection.  I don’t feel like typing the whole thing again. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? WB

Where in the world did you get that magnets cause cancer?

Response:

This is kind of a long story and I’m not going into a lot of details. I have been talking to a researcher at a company that develops agricultural products and what he had to say was most interesting.  He said that they know that bovine colostrum impacts arthritis in a big, positive way and they would like to get into the human side of using it for medicinal purposes – but with FDA regulations being what they are, he doubted the company ever would.   He said it also seems to help in some but not all cases of autoimmunity conditions – he said he’s seen some remarkable reversals of conditions with its use. I was thinking of trying bovine colostrum, but I’m still a bit hesitant to commit the money.  Anyway, I just thought I would throw this out there because the researcher was objective, not trying to sell me his product – which is meant for calves and sheep.

Response:

I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Response:

Hi Marilyn, I think ‘twould be better to try homo sapiens colostrum.

Response:

Hi Marilyn I’m curious as to the by-product of your study on Bovine Colostrum.  I remember in the 5th grade in 1954 our enlightnened teacher instgructed us in the benefits of copper in the cure for arthritis. As for me, I prefer the green wrist look to having refridgerator magnets scotch taped to my knees. Larry Ward

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Norman,     I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                   Corky

Response:

As for me, I prefer the green wrist look to having refridgerator magnets scotch taped to my knees. Larry Ward

Larry,  If you think that Therapeutic Magnets have anything to do with refridgerator magnets you are greatly mistaken.  I wouild be happy to educate you if you are interested.   Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. Norman,    I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                  Corky

And I know of people who have had positive results from magnets the size of a quarter.  Good luck with finding out. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines.

I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.    

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. Norman,    I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                  Corky And I know of people who have had positive results from magnets the size of a quarter.  Good luck with finding out.

I just rec’d a magnet strip from a rep of Nikken. Does anyone know anything about this company? Ron

Response:

It seems to me I heard somewhere that Ms LVP wrote in article I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness

Does this perhaps explain why I can’t get my compass to point to north when I’m indoors?  Anybody else had that experience?  ;-) is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.    

– Don

Response:

If you think that Therapeutic Magnets have anything to do with refridgerator magnets you are greatly mistaken.  I wouild be happy to educate you if you are interested.  

OK. You have finally made a statement of fact.  How does a therapeutic magnet differ from a refrigerator magnet? William Buchman Why seek truth when error is more fun?

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.

In many countries, including Japan, the magnetic products are classified as medical devices and their use it taught in Med schools!

Response:

As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

Response:

WOW! You’ve blown me away with your even posting this information Billy.  Thank you for having an open mind and reporting what you heard. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

Response:

It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment …SNIP

I believe I have an open mind regarding magnetic possibilities.  What really turns me against magnet manufacturers is that they refuse to support tests like these. It seems they are willing to wait until someone else spends money to prove magnets work. The sad part to me is that these studies can cost very little compared to the profits made. In the meantime people may risk further injury thinking the placebo effect is the real treatment and cure.

Response:

Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit WOW! You’ve blown me away with your even posting this information Billy. Thank you for having an open mind and reporting what you heard. Marlynn

My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics. Bill

Response:

My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics.

I’m pretty open to the possibility that magnets may work for some pain. After all, nerve impulses are electrical in nature, and it seems to me that a magnetic field *could* influence that. However, when people start talking about magnets actually *curing* conditions, it’s going to take a lot of proof to get me to accept that. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

Steve, I don’t think that anyone posting any information on this or any other NG has ever said that magnets cure anything.  It is the way the people on this NG  interpret what people who use or sell magnets say.  MAGNETS DO NOT CURE, but they do help to alleviate pain in many situations and are non-invasive. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics. I’m pretty open to the possibility that magnets may work for some pain. After all, nerve impulses are electrical in nature, and it seems to me that a magnetic field *could* influence that. However, when people start talking about magnets actually *curing* conditions, it’s going to take a lot of proof to get me to accept that. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

Steve, I don’t think that anyone posting any information on this or any other NG has ever said that magnets cure anything.  It is the way the people on this NG  interpret what people who use or sell magnets say.  MAGNETS DO NOT CURE, but they do help to alleviate pain in many situations and are non-invasive. Marlynn

Marlynn, usenet is awfully big to think that *no one* has ever said that magnets cure! <BEG Do a search on Deja News, I’m sure that someone has made the claim. (along with any number of others!) ;-)  I wasn’t talking about this NG specifically, but I have seen plenty of claims that magnets cure illnesses, in various places, especially on the web. Here’s an excerpt from a website: "Magnetic Health Quarterly" Newsletter Four times a year, Dr. Philpott discusses a Timely Topic in "The Magnetic Health Quarterly" newsletter. This is the most practical "How To" information on the market today. It takes the Guesswork out of Magnetic therapy. You will discover new insights, and a new approach, to many of your health problems. What you’ll learn will not only amaze you, but give you a renewed sense of hope. He discusses topics such as:- 1. Magnetic Pain Relief. 2. Magnetic Reversal Of Diabetes Mellitus. 3. Magnetic Reversal of Atherosclerosis and Arteriosclerosis. The Magnetic Health Quarterly is Dr. Philpott’s most advanced, and most documented information. You will gain a thorough understanding of what to do, How to do it, and why!

When people talk about reversing serious illness with magnets, I just find it difficult to accept anything they say. These extreme claims are one of the reasons that people are so sceptical of magnets in general. Last winter I shoveled out a couple, who’s car was snowed in at the hotel where I work. They told me that they were doing a magnet demonstration at the retirement home down the street. We got to talking, and the man told me that he slept with a magnetic mask that kept him from having asthma attacks. I just can’t buy into the possibility that magnets can stop asthma. All I’m saying, is that those types of claims are one of the reasons that people don’t take magnets seriously. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

All I’m saying, is that those types of claims are one of the reasons that people don’t take magnets seriously.

Oh, I take magnets very seriously.  Life as we know it today would be totally impossible without magnets.  Motors and generators would not work. As help for arthritis, however, hee hee haw, until they are PROVEN to be useful. Bill

Response:

I believe I have an open mind regarding magnetic possibilities.  What really turns me against magnet manufacturers is that they refuse to support tests like these.

The manufacturers supplied the magnets for the Baylor post polio pain study and the Weintraub diabetic neuropathy pain study and the fibromyalgia pain study.   I have read a criticism of the Baylor study which said the results were suspect because the researchers had used magnets on themselves before using them on their patients and were therefore biased.   Can you blame the manufacturers from standing back from such studies in case that their funding or involvement was used as an excuse to negate the study. In the meantime people may risk further injury thinking the placebo

effect is the real treatment and cure. First, magnotherapy does not cure any condition, it merely makes the symptoms more bearable.   It is a complementary therapy to be used alongside conventional treatment. Surely these studies have shown that for post polio pain relief and diabetic neuropathy pain relief, magnotherapy works better than the placebo effect.   What more do you need.   Or do you want a study on every medical condition which can produce pain before you will accept that magnotherapy is a useful aid to pain relief. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some. Dawn0 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

– "If you have a garden and a library you have everything you need" Cicero

Response:

I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some.

Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time? Bill

Response:

Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time?

I would say more likely that every time they cut, you may have a different outcome.  Depends how much blood supply to that particular area, natural healing of that person’s body at that period of time, any drugs that were being taken at the same time that might have inhibitted healing, how much flexing the site was getting which could affect the healing, general health condition of the person… a sample of two incisions that are not controlled is just too small to draw any conclusions. Best regards,

Response:

This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some. Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time? Bill

Response:

This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn

What is the evidence that these assertions are true??? Bill

Response:

Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn What is the evidence that these assertions are true??? Bill

Response:

Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though.

I do not believe that for a moment! Bill

Response:

I would have been shocked had you answered any differently.  Your loss.  Why don’t you read some of the books.  Won’t even cost you a penny.  Sit at one of the lovely book stores and read away. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though. I do not believe that for a moment! Bill

Response:

I don’t need to read a book.  I know from experience.  I have heard that they help some people but not all.  I was given magnetic insoles to wear for plantar fasciitis.  They did not work at all for me.  But that is just me. Not all "treatments" work equally for all people.  You must keep that in mind in your blanket statements.

Response:

I don’t need to read a book.  I know from experience.  I have heard that they help some people but not all.  I was given magnetic insoles to wear for plantar fasciitis.  They did not work at all for me.  But that is just me. Not all "treatments" work equally for all people.  You must keep that in mind in your blanket statements.

Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it? Bill

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it?

That’s what the studies are for.   I’ve posted the URL’s here before, and they are on my website.   Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is shown to have an effect in reducing pain.   90% success rate in the diabetic neuropathy pain study. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it? That’s what the studies are for.   I’ve posted the URL’s here before, and they are on my website.   Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is shown to have an effect in reducing pain.   90% success rate in the diabetic neuropathy pain study.

No! I will not accept that!  I looked at your web page. I will not believe that anyone with personal scientific experience would write that.  Magnetic fuel conditioning.  What next.  You will hear people saying that it will condition hard water.  Oops.  People are already being scammed that way. Bill the skeptic

Response:

    Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is     shown to have an effect in reducing pain. 90% success rate in the     diabetic neuropathy pain study. No! I will not accept that!  I looked at your web page. I will not believe that anyone with personal scientific experience would write that.

Forget my page for now, look at the two studies and tell me what is wrong with them.   Those two studies were done in the US and showed that magnets could relieve pain.  If you cannot accept them, tell us why not.   The only possible reason I can think of is that the studies are relatively small, but they showed that magnets could reduce the level of pain felt by the users.   If you are in pain, magnets may be a viable option for you.   They are certainly not a scam. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL  Now that is funny.  Come back to MHA and post that site so we can do something about your server. Harv Houston,Tx   They are certainly not a scam. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBai.html Surround Sound for Television

Response:

Here are the sites again.   Read them and take up any arguments with the people who wrote them. The magnotherapy and pain relief studies The Washington Post printed the article about the Baylor post polio pain study http://www.astro.queensu.ca/~bworth/Health/Alternative/Magnetic/baylor_s tudy.html NBC New York aired the item about the Weintraub diabetic neuropathy pain study http://www.health-magnets.com/nbcarticle.htm The US Dept of Energy produced the report on Water conditioning by magnetic fields http://www.pnl.gov/fta/11_non.htm If you still think magnotherapy is a scam after that, then you are a fool.   Some magnetic salesmen might be con-men, but magnotherapy for pain reduction is no scam. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

I am trying to find information on the effectiveness of magnetic therapy and whether the products the various companies sell (particularly Nikken) work. So far everything I’ve been able to find on the net is stuff written by companies selling product and I’d like to find if there is any independant research. Thanks. John

Response:

John, You might check out Gary Null’s book called "Healing with Magnets"

Response:

If you are interested in using magnets, I’ve used them for many years and swear by them.  I mainly use magnets called rare earth neodymium, and in some products magnets that are hi-energy ceramic.  These magnets have worked for me more often than not.  I have used them for things such as headaches, OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc.  In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur.  They definitely work to take the pain away, which in some cases never comes back. Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have (w/6 of the neodymium magnets) and the pain diminishes greatly.  . Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am trying to find information on the effectiveness of magnetic therapy and whether the products the various companies sell (particularly Nikken) work. So far everything I’ve been able to find on the net is stuff written by companies selling product and I’d like to find if there is any independant research. Thanks. John

Response:

Here a few medical journal abstracts on magnetic therapy found by the National Library of Medicine medline search.  You can search for free via http://igm.nlm.nih.gov National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Use of magnet therapy to heal an abdominal wound: a case study. AUTHORS:    Szor JK; Topp R AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  Toledo Hospital, Ohio, USA. SOURCE:  Ostomy Wound Manage 1998 May;44(5):24-9 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 9697544 UI: 98362883 ABSTRACT:   Complementary therapies, in particular magnet therapy, may have benefits to offer in healing chronic wounds. This case study involves a 51 year old paraplegic woman with an abdominal wound that had been present for one year. Traditional approaches to wound care had not achieved complete healing. Prior to surgical intervention, the patient consented to the application of magnet therapy over her usual wound dressing. In one month, the wound completely healed. On the basis of this case, further investigation of magnet therapy for wound healing appears to be warranted. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  Abdominal Abscess/*therapy Cellulitis/*therapy Magnetics/*therapeutic use *Wound Healing ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Alternative Medicine Case Report Chronic Disease Female Human Middle Age Paraplegia/complications PUBLICATION TYPES:   JOURNAL ARTICLE LANGUAGES:  Eng National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Successful treatment of an acute exacerbation of multiple sclerosis by external magnetic fields. AUTHORS:    Sandyk R; Derpapas AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  NeuroCommunication Research Laboratories, Danbury, CT 06811. SOURCE:  Int J Neurosci 1993 May;70(1-2):97-105 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 8083029 UI: 94364783 ABSTRACT:   A 55 year old woman with multiple sclerosis presented with a 5 week history of an exacerbation of symptoms. Prominent among these symptoms was trigeminal neuralgia, migraine headaches, blurring of vision, and ataxia of gait. While treatment with carbamazepine (TegretolR) (800 mg/d) and oral prednisolone (15 mg/d) over a 4 week period produced no improvement in symptoms, externally applied magnetic fields (MF) (7.5 picoTesla; 5 Hz) placed over the scalp for a 7 minute period on three different days resulted in a complete resolution of symptoms within two weeks of initiation of treatment. Partial relief of the neuralgic pain and headaches was obtained immediately after completion of the first treatment indicating that resolution of symptoms was related to the eff ects of MF and not to a spontaneous remission. This is the first report demonstrating the clinical efficacy of pico Tesla range MF in rapidly resolving an acute relapse of MS. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  *Electromagnetic Fields Multiple Sclerosis/*therapy ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Case Report Facial Expression Female Human Middle Age Migraine/complications Multiple Sclerosis/complications Serotonin Treatment Outcome Trigeminal Neuralgia/complications PUBLICATION TYPES:   JOURNAL ARTICLE CAS REGISTRY NUMBERS:   50-67-9 (Serotonin) LANGUAGES:  Eng National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Initial exploration of pulsing electromagnetic fields for treatment of migraine. AUTHORS:    Sherman RA; Robson L; Marden LA AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  Service of Orthopedic Surgery, Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma,  Wash. 98431, USA. SOURCE:  Headache 1998 Mar;38(3):208-13 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 9563212 UI: 98224316 ABSTRACT:   Two studies were conducted during which 23 patients with chronic migraine were exposed to pulsing electromagnetic fields over the inner thigh. In an open study, 11 subjects kept a 2-week headache log before and after 2 to 3 weeks of exposure to pulsing electromagnetic fields for 1 hour per day, 5 days per week. The number of headaches per week decreased from 4.03 during the baseline period to 0.43 during the initial 2-week follow-up period and to 0.14 during the extended follow- up which averaged 8.1 months. In a double-blind study, 9 subjects kept a 3-week log of headache activity and were randomly assigned to receive 2 weeks of real or placebo pulsing electromagnetic field exposures as described above. They were subsequently switched to 2 weeks of the other mode, after which they kept a final 3-week log. Three additional subjects in the blind study inadvertently received half-power pulsing electromagnetic field exposures. The 6 subjects exposed to the actual device first showed a change in headache activity from 3.32 per week to 0.58 per week. The 3 subjects exposed to only half the dose showed no change in headache activity. Large controlled studies should be performed to determine whether this intervention is actually effective. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  *Electromagnetic Fields Migraine/*therapy ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Adult Aged Chronic Disease Double-Blind Method Female Follow-Up Studies Human Male Middle Age Migraine/physiopathology Support, U.S. Gov’t, Non-P.H.S. Thigh/blood supply PUBLICATION TYPES:   CLINICAL TRIAL JOURNAL ARTICLE RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL LANGUAGES:  Eng

Response:

OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc.

THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of. In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur.

This can be construed to be making a medical claim…….quite illegal. They definitely work to take the pain away,

pain is considered a medical term, hence: medical claim Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have

hmmmmm…..OA?  is that short for a medical disease?

Response:

OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc. THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of.

One of the things to remember is that this is an international board.  While those of us in the USA might want to be playing by the FDA rules they do not pertain to our international friends. I have no idea who posted the original message about osteoarthritis but thought a simple reminder that we are not all playing by the same rules would be prudent. Susan

Response:

The claims made below were strictly mine about my own personal experience using neodymium magnets.  My claims are true….these are my conditions so what is the problem here? Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc. THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of. In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur. This can be construed to be making a medical claim…….quite illegal. They definitely work to take the pain away, pain is considered a medical term, hence: medical claim Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have hmmmmm…..OA?  is that short for a medical disease?

Response:

My daughter has just been diagnosed with TMJ.  Has anyone heard of using magnetic therapy for this?

Response:

My daughter has just been diagnosed with TMJ.  Has anyone heard of using magnetic therapy for this?

Yes, we have a couple of dentist who use the products in their practice and it has helped with TMJ. If you would like, I can get you in touch with them. – Jim

Response:

re TMJ and magnetic therapy, I’ve used one for my neck and back at times and do feel relief.  I can see no reason why it wouldn’t work as well for TMJ.   Here’s something else to try if that doesn’t work:  I have fibromyalgia and have spent much time with a physical therapist (with a  prescription from my rheumatologist so it’s covered by insurance.)  The therapist also showed me how to do therapy on my own TMJ – a procedure using pressure on the inside and back of the lower molars from inside the mouth.  It sounds strange but it does work.    Make sure the therapist knows what  (s)he is doing as it could also make you worse if it’s  not done right.   Good luck!

Response:

| Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – | Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

Why are you skeptial? If this therapy works, then why question it results. There appears to no side effects from this treatment.

Response:

writes: Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

I believe Jane Heimlich writes about magnet therapy in her book "What Your Doctor Won’t Tell You."  You can probably find it in most of the larger chain bookstores.  She also writes about other alternative therapies like chelation, etc.  She’s married to the "Heimlich Maneuver" guy, and is a champion of a lot of alternative approaches. Hope it helps.    

Response:

I have recently been introduced to the field of Magnetic Therapy, particularly in the use of pain control and increased circulation. As you may have guessed, I am skeptical, as are many of the people I have talked to about it. I have become a distributor of Magnetic therapy products, but I would like to find out if there are people doing studies on these devices, and if so where can I get the results. Any comments, what ever you have would be welcome. Jerry Wiebe

Response:

Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

Response:

Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

Hi Doug, I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems in most conditions. Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. –Gary

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – | Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

For anyone out there interested in doing a little reading on this subject the following list is for you.  I have been sleeping on a magnetic mattress now for almost four years. My, own experience, I believe I sleep better on it than off. jim Received: from locator (occs2.nlm.nih.gov) by nlm.nih.gov (4.1/SMI-4.0) Received: by locator (AIX 3.2/UCB 5.64/4.10) Status: RO 31 of 55 AUTHOR        Biomagnetic Effects Workshop, 1978, Lawrence Berkeley                   Laboratory TITLE         Magnetic field effect on biological systems : based on the                   proceedings of the Biomagnetic Effects Workshop held at                   Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, University of California, on                   April 6-7, 1978 PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum, c1979. DESCRIPTION   108 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   BB5260 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Limited cataloging. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        8106160 ISBN          0-306-40312-9. LC CARD NO    79-20739 32 of 55 AUTHOR        Dubrov, A. P. (Aleksandr Petrovich) TITLE         The geomagnetic field and life : geomagnetobiology               Geomagnitnoe pole i zhizn’ : geomagnetobiology PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum Press, c1978. DESCRIPTION   xvii, 318 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 162.M3 D819g 1978a ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Magnetics               Physiology NOTES         Translation of Geomagnitnoe pole i zhizn’.               Bilbiography: p. 255-311. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        7901234 ISBN          0-306-31072-4. LC CARD NO    78-1705 52 of 55 AUTHOR        Barnothy, Madeleine F., 1904- TITLE         Biological effects of magnetic fields. PUBLISHER     New York, Plenum Press, 1964. DESCRIPTION   ix, 324 p. illus. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 B262b 1964 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Magnetics LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        0001325 1 of 55 AUTHOR        Bachmann, Kurt, 1929-               Stefan, Hermann               Vieth, Jurgen TITLE         Biomagnetism : principles, models, and clinical research :                   proceedings of the opening symposium of the Biomagnetic                   Center Erlangen (5.-6. October 1990) PUBLISHER     Erlangen : Verlag Palm & Enke, 1992. DESCRIPTION   118 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 B61125 1990 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biomedical Engineering – methods – congresses               Electroencephalography – congresses               Magnetics – diagnostic use – congresses               Magnetoencephalography – congresses NOTES         Includes bibliographical references and indexes. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9308754 ISBN          3-7896-0507-7. 2 of 55 AUTHOR        Hoke, M. (Manfried)               International Conference on Biomagnetism, 8th, 1991, Munster in                   Westfalen, Germany TITLE         Biomagnetism : clinical aspects : proceedings of the 8th                   International Conference on Biomagnetism, Munster, 19-24                   August, 1991 PUBLISHER     Amsterdam ; New York : Excerpta Medica, 1992. DESCRIPTION   xxii, 904 p. : ill. SERIES        International congress series ; no. 988 CALL NUMBER   W3 EX89 no.988 1992 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Brain Diseases – therapy – congresses               Evoked Potentials – congresses               Heart Diseases – therapy – congresses               Magnetics – therapeutic use – congresses NOTES         Includes bibliographical references and index. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9216444 ISBN          0-444-89268-0 (alk. paper). 3 of 55 AUTHOR        Lissens, Mark A. TITLE         Clinical applications of magnetic transcranial stimulation PUBLISHER     Leuven : Uitgeverij Peeters, 1992. DESCRIPTION   xi, 300 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   WL 300 C641 1992 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Central Nervous System Diseases – therapy               Evoked Potentials               Magnetics               Physical Stimulation NOTES         Includes bibliographical references. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9314351 ISBN          90-6831-434-3. 6 of 55 AUTHOR        Philpott, William H., 1919-               Taplin, Sharon Lindsay TITLE         Biomagnetic handbook : today’s introduction to the energy                   medicine of tomorrow               Today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow :                   today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow               Guide to medical magnetics, the energy medicine of tomorrow :                   today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow PUBLISHER     Choctaw, OK : Enviro-Tech Products, c1990. DESCRIPTION   97 leaves : ill. CALL NUMBER   WB 890 P549b 1990 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Magnetics               Alternative Medicine NOTES         A Guide to medical magnetics, the energy medicine of                   tomorrow–Cover.               Includes bibliographical references (leaves 92-93). LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9204875 8 of 55 AUTHOR        Williamson, Samuel J.               International Conference on Biomagnetism, 7th, 1989, New York,                   N.Y. TITLE         Advances in biomagnetism PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum Press, c1989. DESCRIPTION   xx, 771 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 I61425a 1989 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Electromagnetics – congresses               Evoked Potentials – congresses               Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on                   Biomagnetism, held August 13-18, 1989, in New York, New                   York–T.p. verso.               Includes bibliographical references and indexes. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9310981 ISBN          0-306-43483-0. LC CARD NO    89-49359 17 of 55 AUTHOR        Evans, Bruce A.               American Association of Electromyography and Electrodiagnosis TITLE         Use of magnetic stimulation in the peripheral nervous system :                   an AAEE workshop PUBLISHER     [Rochester, Minn.] : American Association of Electromyography                   and Electrodiagnosis, [c1988] DESCRIPTION   4 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   WB 141 E917u 1988 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Electric Stimulation – methods               Electrodiagnosis – methods               Magnetics               Peripheral Nerves NOTES         Includes bibliographical references (p. 4). LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9209125 29 of 55 AUTHOR        Erne, S. N. (Sergio Nicola), 1944-               Hahlbohm, H. D., 1930-               Lubbig, H., 1932-               International Workshop on Biomagnetism, 3rd, 1980, Berlin,                   Germany TITLE         Biomagnetism : proceedings, Third International Workshop on                   Biomagnetism, Berlin (West), May 1980 PUBLISHER     Berlin ; New York : Walter de Gruyter, 1981. DESCRIPTION   xviii, 558 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   W3 IN9324NI 3rd 1980b ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biomedical Engineering – congresses               Biophysics – congresses               Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Proceedings of earlier workshops not published. LANGUAGE    

… read more »

Response:

 JL Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy?  JL I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to  JL relieve  discomfort in the body.  Any comments? It appears that this message is coming from Germany.  Your name isn’t German, so I’m guessing your in the military.   yes, I can give you some information on magnetic therapy.  The Japanese have been using it for over 20 years.  I heard that one out of 8 homes in Japan are using this new technology.  The magnets are using in a rubberized material which is polarized so that it stimulates the body.  Magnetic waves pass through the tissue and secondary currents are induced.  This induction reduces pain and inflamation in the muscles and joints.  Magnetic waves penetrate the skin, fatty tissues and bones, invigorating general metabolism.  Magnetism seems to really stimulate circulation also.  We have found the magnetic insoles to be the most effective product for most problems involving circulation or pain in the legs or back.  My wife has been wearing them and they have done wonders for the pain she has due to adhesions.  Magnetic therapy helps arthritic pain, headaches, muscle aches, etc.  We have a friend who is going to have to have his spinal cord cut due to extreme pain in his body.  We are going to have him to try the magnetic seat and insoles to see is this will help with the pain.  If you have more questions feel free to respond. Ken ___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12

Response:

Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy? I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to relieve discomfort in the body.  Any comments? —               – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – -              Take the calculated risks; to dream and to build,              to fail and to succeed.  Enjoy the challenges of                   life and the thrill of fulfillment.  * Origin: Medical System Munich

Response:

Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy? I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to relieve discomfort in the body.  Any comments? —               – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – -              Take the calculated risks; to dream and to build,              to fail and to succeed.  Enjoy the challenges of                   life and the thrill of fulfillment.

Response:

OK. You have finally made a statement of fact.  How does a therapeutic magnet differ from a refrigerator magnet?

Hi William,     You know, I think you’ve firmly established your skepticism of magnets.  If you feel the need to repeatedly challenge someone over the subject of magnets, why not take on the people selling them and leave people who are only posting about their experiences alone? Denise

Response:

I just rec’d a magnet strip from a rep of Nikken. Does anyone know anything about this company?

Multi-loser marketing scam, apparently based in Japan.  Recently, several ‘reps’ have been spamming the support groups.  They’ve got a website, but it doesn’t have much info on the products, only on the organization and commission structure. My curiousity is almost, but not quite, to the point of going to look to see if there really are any published double-blind studies on the use of magnets for pain treatment… — DO NOT SEND UNSOLICITED BULK MAIL TO THIS ADDRESS

Response:

My curiousity is almost, but not quite, to the point of going to look to see if there really are any published double-blind studies on the use of magnets for pain treatment…

    Hi Howard,        I’ve taken the liberty of reprinting a report on a double-blind study on magnets for pain relief that Marlynn was kind enough to post awhile ago.              Coincidently, there was a brief segment on Dateline (NBC) tonight regarding magnets. A doctor at Vanderbilt (I think) has been doing research on them for years.  He was the 27th doctor this teenager in Tennesee had been to seeking pain relief.  The kid even had his appendix taken out ‘coz some doc thought that was the source of the pain.  The magnets worked for the kid and NBC did refer to this Baylor study.  (see, Marlynn, I *do* pay attention to this stuff!;) Denise Subj:    Re: Re Baylor Study on Post Polio Patients Here is a news release about the magnet therapy research at Baylor College of Medicine. Magnet therapy reduces pain in post-polio patients         HOUSTON–(Nov. 3, 1997)–A small magnet strapped to post-polio patients’ most sensitive sore spots reduced pain acutely in a study of 50 people at Baylor College of Medicine and The Institute for Rehabilitation and Research (TIRR) in Houston.         Results of the double-blind study were published in the November issue of the Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation.         "The majority of patients in the study who received treatment with a magnet reported a significant decrease in pain, and most of the patients who were given a placebo, or inactive magnet, reported very little or no improvement," said principal investigator Dr. Carlos Vallbona.  He is a professor of family and community medicine and physical medicine and rehabilitation at Baylor and director of the Post-Polio Clinic at TIRR.         Vallbona evaluated the magnet therapy in adults diagnosed with post-polio syndrome who were experiencing arthritic pain in the joints or had identifiable points of pain in their muscles.  Thirty-nine women and 11 men participated in the study.  Most were in their 50s and had developed post-polio syndrome during their 40s.         All patients were asked to press on the "trigger point" where they felt the severest pain and rank that pain on a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the worst.  The patients were then randomly given an active or inactive magnet to strap against their trigger point for 45 minutes. After the magnets were removed, patients rated the intensity of their pain again.         Twenty-nine participants received an active magnet.  Their average score of pain was 9.6 before the treatment, and 4.4 after wearing the magnet. The placebo group had an average pain score of 9.5 before treatment, and 8.4 afterward.         The low-intensity magnets, less than a half-inch thick and slightly stronger than refrigerator magnets, were available in four formats to accommodate different areas of the body: a credit-card- size rectangle, a six-inch strip almost two inches wide, a disc the size of a silver dollar and a disc the size of a CD.         "Seventy-six percent of the patients who had the active magnet reported a decrease in pain, but only 19 percent of the patients treated with a placebo felt an improvement," Vallbona said.  None of the patients reported any side effects from the treatment.         "We do not have a clear explanation for the significant and quick pain relief observed by the patients in our study," Vallbona said.  "It’s possible that the magnetic energy affects the pain receptors in the joints or muscles or lowers the sensation of pain in the brain."         The Baylor-TIRR study consisted of one treatment per patient and did not evaluate how long the reported pain relief lasted.  Vallbona said more research is needed to determine whether magnet therapy should be recommended as an alternative to the standard treatments for pain in post-polio patients, such as physical therapy, support braces, muscle relaxants, anti-inflammatory drugs and other medication.         Vallbona’s co-principal investigator for the study was Dr. Carlton F. Hazlewood, Baylor professor of molecular physiology and biophysics.         BIOflex, Inc., a company in Corpus Christi, Texas, provided magnets for the study.                                

Response:

What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into. — Ron Joiner

Response:

What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into. — Ron Joiner

Sorry "OA" in the neck.

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? WB

Response:

: Magnetic Therapy What’s the latest on this for arthritis sufferers. I have OS in the neck region and I wonder if this is something I should look into.

Hi Ron, I personally use magnets and do find them very helpful.  I have used them for many years for arthritis in my fingers, hips and chronic lower back pain. The ones that I use and hightly recommend are called "rare earth neodymium" magnets.  They are a very small (size of a dime) and have the strength of one 20 times their size. A new book just came out called Magnet Therapy – The Pain Cure Alternative by Drs. Ron Lawrence and Paul J. Rosch.  I purchased mine at Barnes & Nobel.  It’s filled withe interesting information, lots of case studies, many of which deal with arthritic sufferers.  They talk about this specific type of magnet and the ways in which it can be used to help alleviate pain;  much of which I have discovered on my own just by using and experimenting over the past years.  I’ve also learned a lot of new things. These are permanent magnets not electro magnets.  These are not the ones that they were talking about being cancer producing.  AND, as a matter of fact,a study came out recently with proof of the fact that the electro magnetic fields that surround some areas (high tension wires, etc.) are not cancer producing. I don’t know this personally, I am just relating what I have heard.  The only thing that I can vouch for personally is that these permanent magnets do work for hundreds of thousands of people world wide and have for many years. If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to ask.  I think I’m the only one on the board that uses this particular type of magnet.  They are the newest technology today in magnet field therapy.  All magnets are not the same and there are lots of companies out there selling garbage for very high prices.  These magnets are also not expensive, non-invasive to the body except for their energy, and will not harm anyone the way so many of the meds do. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. —

Hi Norman, Read the book that I mentioned in my previous post.  I think that you will find it very enlightening.   Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects?

Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big Alternative by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects.

I am sorry that my sarcasm did not get throught in my original post.  I was trying to emphasize the ridiculous attribution of therapeutic capability to magnetism.  This practice dates back at least as far as Mesmer.  Benjamin Franklin showed that the principle at work was gullability. You mention case studies, but you do not mention CONTROLLED studies. This message is not aimed at you personally.  It is aimed at all who pomulgate unsubstantiated health claims. William Buchman

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? Billy, We live and have lived surrounded by magnets.  The earth is one big Alternative by Dr Ron Lawrence,  you will learn about how magnets give pain relief to many who suffer from chronic pains and learn a lot more that you never knew or realized.  I recommend this book because I have read several and I found this one to be the most helpful to the lay person.  Actually gives lots of case studies and shows how to use magnets in several ways for maximum results and explains why. The book is not expensive and in paperback so that it’s not heavy to hold. Magnets will not cure arthritis. If you remember my previous posts, in answer to your many questions about magnets, you will know that I never said they cure anything.  They will just help with the pain in a far less harmful way than the invasive meds that people now take that tend to destroy their bodies and cause lots of other side effects. I am sorry that my sarcasm did not get throught in my original post.  I was trying to emphasize the ridiculous attribution of therapeutic capability to magnetism.  This practice dates back at least as far as Mesmer.  Benjamin Franklin showed that the principle at work was gullability. You mention case studies, but you do not mention CONTROLLED studies. This message is not aimed at you personally.  It is aimed at all who pomulgate unsubstantiated health claims. William Buchman </PRE</HTML

Billy, I didn’t realize that you posted this to the board.  I though it was to me personally.  If you would like to post my answer to you I have no objection.  I don’t feel like typing the whole thing again. Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

What is the difference between a magnetic field that cures arthritis and one that produces cancer?  Why and how do they produce the different effects? WB

Where in the world did you get that magnets cause cancer?

Response:

This is kind of a long story and I’m not going into a lot of details. I have been talking to a researcher at a company that develops agricultural products and what he had to say was most interesting.  He said that they know that bovine colostrum impacts arthritis in a big, positive way and they would like to get into the human side of using it for medicinal purposes – but with FDA regulations being what they are, he doubted the company ever would.   He said it also seems to help in some but not all cases of autoimmunity conditions – he said he’s seen some remarkable reversals of conditions with its use. I was thinking of trying bovine colostrum, but I’m still a bit hesitant to commit the money.  Anyway, I just thought I would throw this out there because the researcher was objective, not trying to sell me his product – which is meant for calves and sheep.

Response:

I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Response:

Hi Marilyn, I think ‘twould be better to try homo sapiens colostrum.

Response:

Hi Marilyn I’m curious as to the by-product of your study on Bovine Colostrum.  I remember in the 5th grade in 1954 our enlightnened teacher instgructed us in the benefits of copper in the cure for arthritis. As for me, I prefer the green wrist look to having refridgerator magnets scotch taped to my knees. Larry Ward

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. — "Give a small boy a hammer and the world becomes a nail." Norman Lampert

Norman,     I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                   Corky

Response:

As for me, I prefer the green wrist look to having refridgerator magnets scotch taped to my knees. Larry Ward

Larry,  If you think that Therapeutic Magnets have anything to do with refridgerator magnets you are greatly mistaken.  I wouild be happy to educate you if you are interested.   Marlynn A day in which I haven’t learned something new is a day lost……

Response:

Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. Norman,    I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                  Corky

And I know of people who have had positive results from magnets the size of a quarter.  Good luck with finding out. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines.

I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.    

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Personally, I don’t think that any magnet small enough for you to carry would have a large enough magnetic field to have any effect on the human body. Norman,    I have seen some pretty amazing things with a magnet the size of a silver dollar!                                                                  Corky And I know of people who have had positive results from magnets the size of a quarter.  Good luck with finding out.

I just rec’d a magnet strip from a rep of Nikken. Does anyone know anything about this company? Ron

Response:

It seems to me I heard somewhere that Ms LVP wrote in article I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness

Does this perhaps explain why I can’t get my compass to point to north when I’m indoors?  Anybody else had that experience?  ;-) is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.    

– Don

Response:

If you think that Therapeutic Magnets have anything to do with refridgerator magnets you are greatly mistaken.  I wouild be happy to educate you if you are interested.  

OK. You have finally made a statement of fact.  How does a therapeutic magnet differ from a refrigerator magnet? William Buchman Why seek truth when error is more fun?

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I read about some such study several years ago. One of the things they were looking into was magnetic fields caused by electric power distribution lines. I think this is considered an "electro magnetic field" generated by electrical power  not the "natural" magnetic field. Remember the earth is a giant magnet & as we live/work in concrete buildings, etc we lose contact with this "natural" magnetism.  Using magnets for wellness is a way of "reconnecting" to a "natural" magnetic field & helps us stay healthy.  Other countries, especially Japan have been using magnets regularly for health benefits.  They are just now becoming known in the US.

In many countries, including Japan, the magnetic products are classified as medical devices and their use it taught in Med schools!

Response:

As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

Response:

WOW! You’ve blown me away with your even posting this information Billy.  Thank you for having an open mind and reporting what you heard. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

Response:

It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment …SNIP

I believe I have an open mind regarding magnetic possibilities.  What really turns me against magnet manufacturers is that they refuse to support tests like these. It seems they are willing to wait until someone else spends money to prove magnets work. The sad part to me is that these studies can cost very little compared to the profits made. In the meantime people may risk further injury thinking the placebo effect is the real treatment and cure.

Response:

Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit WOW! You’ve blown me away with your even posting this information Billy. Thank you for having an open mind and reporting what you heard. Marlynn

My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics. Bill

Response:

My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics.

I’m pretty open to the possibility that magnets may work for some pain. After all, nerve impulses are electrical in nature, and it seems to me that a magnetic field *could* influence that. However, when people start talking about magnets actually *curing* conditions, it’s going to take a lot of proof to get me to accept that. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

Steve, I don’t think that anyone posting any information on this or any other NG has ever said that magnets cure anything.  It is the way the people on this NG  interpret what people who use or sell magnets say.  MAGNETS DO NOT CURE, but they do help to alleviate pain in many situations and are non-invasive. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – My mind is slightly open.  Do the research in front of skeptics. I’m pretty open to the possibility that magnets may work for some pain. After all, nerve impulses are electrical in nature, and it seems to me that a magnetic field *could* influence that. However, when people start talking about magnets actually *curing* conditions, it’s going to take a lot of proof to get me to accept that. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

Steve, I don’t think that anyone posting any information on this or any other NG has ever said that magnets cure anything.  It is the way the people on this NG  interpret what people who use or sell magnets say.  MAGNETS DO NOT CURE, but they do help to alleviate pain in many situations and are non-invasive. Marlynn

Marlynn, usenet is awfully big to think that *no one* has ever said that magnets cure! <BEG Do a search on Deja News, I’m sure that someone has made the claim. (along with any number of others!) ;-)  I wasn’t talking about this NG specifically, but I have seen plenty of claims that magnets cure illnesses, in various places, especially on the web. Here’s an excerpt from a website: "Magnetic Health Quarterly" Newsletter Four times a year, Dr. Philpott discusses a Timely Topic in "The Magnetic Health Quarterly" newsletter. This is the most practical "How To" information on the market today. It takes the Guesswork out of Magnetic therapy. You will discover new insights, and a new approach, to many of your health problems. What you’ll learn will not only amaze you, but give you a renewed sense of hope. He discusses topics such as:- 1. Magnetic Pain Relief. 2. Magnetic Reversal Of Diabetes Mellitus. 3. Magnetic Reversal of Atherosclerosis and Arteriosclerosis. The Magnetic Health Quarterly is Dr. Philpott’s most advanced, and most documented information. You will gain a thorough understanding of what to do, How to do it, and why!

When people talk about reversing serious illness with magnets, I just find it difficult to accept anything they say. These extreme claims are one of the reasons that people are so sceptical of magnets in general. Last winter I shoveled out a couple, who’s car was snowed in at the hotel where I work. They told me that they were doing a magnet demonstration at the retirement home down the street. We got to talking, and the man told me that he slept with a magnetic mask that kept him from having asthma attacks. I just can’t buy into the possibility that magnets can stop asthma. All I’m saying, is that those types of claims are one of the reasons that people don’t take magnets seriously. Steve http://www.zoomnet.net/~steve

Response:

All I’m saying, is that those types of claims are one of the reasons that people don’t take magnets seriously.

Oh, I take magnets very seriously.  Life as we know it today would be totally impossible without magnets.  Motors and generators would not work. As help for arthritis, however, hee hee haw, until they are PROVEN to be useful. Bill

Response:

I believe I have an open mind regarding magnetic possibilities.  What really turns me against magnet manufacturers is that they refuse to support tests like these.

The manufacturers supplied the magnets for the Baylor post polio pain study and the Weintraub diabetic neuropathy pain study and the fibromyalgia pain study.   I have read a criticism of the Baylor study which said the results were suspect because the researchers had used magnets on themselves before using them on their patients and were therefore biased.   Can you blame the manufacturers from standing back from such studies in case that their funding or involvement was used as an excuse to negate the study. In the meantime people may risk further injury thinking the placebo

effect is the real treatment and cure. First, magnotherapy does not cure any condition, it merely makes the symptoms more bearable.   It is a complementary therapy to be used alongside conventional treatment. Surely these studies have shown that for post polio pain relief and diabetic neuropathy pain relief, magnotherapy works better than the placebo effect.   What more do you need.   Or do you want a study on every medical condition which can produce pain before you will accept that magnotherapy is a useful aid to pain relief. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some. Dawn0 – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – As followers of my post may know, I am highly skeptical of such magnet therapy.  Today, a researcher from Baylor was interviewed on PBS’s Morning Edition.  He believes that magnetic therapy works in spite of his own skepticism.  From his description of the experiments, however, he is clearly concerned about the randomness of the trials.  He indicated that a paper clip provides the information to distinguish a placebo magnet from a real magnet.  He also indicated that magnetic mattresses apparently provide some relief. It is possible to do a randomized controlled experiment using mattresses.  Use a computer to drive electromagnets in a mattress.  On the same patient, energize the magnets randomly on various nights from the computer.  The subjects are asked if they can tell which nights alleviated their pains.  The only record should be in the computer so that no human knows which nights are magnetized.  Precautions must be taken to prevent the subjects from knowing whether the magnets are turned on or not.  This may require mattresses made from nonmgagnetic material.  Further precautions need to be taken so that no sounds or heat can be detected by the subjects.  Any paper clips or other such items must be kept away from the subjects so that they cannot use them as detectors. I am sure that some would argue that "natural" magnets are different from electromagnets.  If it can be proven that that is indeed true, the prover is sure to get a Nobel prize in physics.  Such a discovery would be truly amazing. OK researchers.  Start your engines. Bill

– "If you have a garden and a library you have everything you need" Cicero

Response:

I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some.

Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time? Bill

Response:

Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time?

I would say more likely that every time they cut, you may have a different outcome.  Depends how much blood supply to that particular area, natural healing of that person’s body at that period of time, any drugs that were being taken at the same time that might have inhibitted healing, how much flexing the site was getting which could affect the healing, general health condition of the person… a sample of two incisions that are not controlled is just too small to draw any conclusions. Best regards,

Response:

This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I sleep on a magnetic mattress. My experience with my surgery six weeks ago is that I think I have healed faster.  The scar has already faded which took two years to get to this point 5 years ago.  I believe magnets have their place, for me they do not help with pain.   I have tried all kinds and I have a source from a reputable company who provides me with some. Do you think that surgical technique may have improved during that time? Bill

Response:

This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn

What is the evidence that these assertions are true??? Bill

Response:

Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – This is not an uncommom occurrence for someone who uses magnets.  People do heal faster.  Magnets help the body to help itself because of the increased blood circulation.  Probably a result of what you are sleeping on. Marlynn What is the evidence that these assertions are true??? Bill

Response:

Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though.

I do not believe that for a moment! Bill

Response:

I would have been shocked had you answered any differently.  Your loss.  Why don’t you read some of the books.  Won’t even cost you a penny.  Sit at one of the lovely book stores and read away. Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Read books on magnetic therapy written by doctors who have experienced this with their patients.  It’s strictly anecdotal…….not the scientific evidence that you seek.  Everyone that uses magnets seriously is well aware of this though. I do not believe that for a moment! Bill

Response:

I don’t need to read a book.  I know from experience.  I have heard that they help some people but not all.  I was given magnetic insoles to wear for plantar fasciitis.  They did not work at all for me.  But that is just me. Not all "treatments" work equally for all people.  You must keep that in mind in your blanket statements.

Response:

I don’t need to read a book.  I know from experience.  I have heard that they help some people but not all.  I was given magnetic insoles to wear for plantar fasciitis.  They did not work at all for me.  But that is just me. Not all "treatments" work equally for all people.  You must keep that in mind in your blanket statements.

Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it? Bill

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it?

That’s what the studies are for.   I’ve posted the URL’s here before, and they are on my website.   Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is shown to have an effect in reducing pain.   90% success rate in the diabetic neuropathy pain study. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Suppose a malady can get worse by itself, or better by itself.  For arguments’s sake, say it is 50/50.  Further suppose that you heard that drinking water while pinching your nose shut, will alleviate the problem.  You think it is worth a shot so you drink water that way. There is a human tendency for those nose pinchers who improve to say that nose pinching is a wonderful therapy.  The ones who did not improve say that it did just did not work for them but it was worth trying something so simple.  Why cannot  most of the improved nose pinchers to consider that that nose pinching has nothing to do with it? That’s what the studies are for.   I’ve posted the URL’s here before, and they are on my website.   Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is shown to have an effect in reducing pain.   90% success rate in the diabetic neuropathy pain study.

No! I will not accept that!  I looked at your web page. I will not believe that anyone with personal scientific experience would write that.  Magnetic fuel conditioning.  What next.  You will hear people saying that it will condition hard water.  Oops.  People are already being scammed that way. Bill the skeptic

Response:

    Why won’t you accept that magnotherapy is     shown to have an effect in reducing pain. 90% success rate in the     diabetic neuropathy pain study. No! I will not accept that!  I looked at your web page. I will not believe that anyone with personal scientific experience would write that.

Forget my page for now, look at the two studies and tell me what is wrong with them.   Those two studies were done in the US and showed that magnets could relieve pain.  If you cannot accept them, tell us why not.   The only possible reason I can think of is that the studies are relatively small, but they showed that magnets could reduce the level of pain felt by the users.   If you are in pain, magnets may be a viable option for you.   They are certainly not a scam. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL  Now that is funny.  Come back to MHA and post that site so we can do something about your server. Harv Houston,Tx   They are certainly not a scam. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBai.html Surround Sound for Television

Response:

Here are the sites again.   Read them and take up any arguments with the people who wrote them. The magnotherapy and pain relief studies The Washington Post printed the article about the Baylor post polio pain study http://www.astro.queensu.ca/~bworth/Health/Alternative/Magnetic/baylor_s tudy.html NBC New York aired the item about the Weintraub diabetic neuropathy pain study http://www.health-magnets.com/nbcarticle.htm The US Dept of Energy produced the report on Water conditioning by magnetic fields http://www.pnl.gov/fta/11_non.htm If you still think magnotherapy is a scam after that, then you are a fool.   Some magnetic salesmen might be con-men, but magnotherapy for pain reduction is no scam. Best wishes John Bain UK TV Sound Director, magnotherapy user & distributor http://members.aol.com/JBainSI/Magnotherapy.html Surround Sound for Television Share what you know. Learn what you don’t.

Response:

I am trying to find information on the effectiveness of magnetic therapy and whether the products the various companies sell (particularly Nikken) work. So far everything I’ve been able to find on the net is stuff written by companies selling product and I’d like to find if there is any independant research. Thanks. John

Response:

John, You might check out Gary Null’s book called "Healing with Magnets"

Response:

If you are interested in using magnets, I’ve used them for many years and swear by them.  I mainly use magnets called rare earth neodymium, and in some products magnets that are hi-energy ceramic.  These magnets have worked for me more often than not.  I have used them for things such as headaches, OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc.  In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur.  They definitely work to take the pain away, which in some cases never comes back. Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have (w/6 of the neodymium magnets) and the pain diminishes greatly.  . Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am trying to find information on the effectiveness of magnetic therapy and whether the products the various companies sell (particularly Nikken) work. So far everything I’ve been able to find on the net is stuff written by companies selling product and I’d like to find if there is any independant research. Thanks. John

Response:

Here a few medical journal abstracts on magnetic therapy found by the National Library of Medicine medline search.  You can search for free via http://igm.nlm.nih.gov National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Use of magnet therapy to heal an abdominal wound: a case study. AUTHORS:    Szor JK; Topp R AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  Toledo Hospital, Ohio, USA. SOURCE:  Ostomy Wound Manage 1998 May;44(5):24-9 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 9697544 UI: 98362883 ABSTRACT:   Complementary therapies, in particular magnet therapy, may have benefits to offer in healing chronic wounds. This case study involves a 51 year old paraplegic woman with an abdominal wound that had been present for one year. Traditional approaches to wound care had not achieved complete healing. Prior to surgical intervention, the patient consented to the application of magnet therapy over her usual wound dressing. In one month, the wound completely healed. On the basis of this case, further investigation of magnet therapy for wound healing appears to be warranted. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  Abdominal Abscess/*therapy Cellulitis/*therapy Magnetics/*therapeutic use *Wound Healing ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Alternative Medicine Case Report Chronic Disease Female Human Middle Age Paraplegia/complications PUBLICATION TYPES:   JOURNAL ARTICLE LANGUAGES:  Eng National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Successful treatment of an acute exacerbation of multiple sclerosis by external magnetic fields. AUTHORS:    Sandyk R; Derpapas AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  NeuroCommunication Research Laboratories, Danbury, CT 06811. SOURCE:  Int J Neurosci 1993 May;70(1-2):97-105 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 8083029 UI: 94364783 ABSTRACT:   A 55 year old woman with multiple sclerosis presented with a 5 week history of an exacerbation of symptoms. Prominent among these symptoms was trigeminal neuralgia, migraine headaches, blurring of vision, and ataxia of gait. While treatment with carbamazepine (TegretolR) (800 mg/d) and oral prednisolone (15 mg/d) over a 4 week period produced no improvement in symptoms, externally applied magnetic fields (MF) (7.5 picoTesla; 5 Hz) placed over the scalp for a 7 minute period on three different days resulted in a complete resolution of symptoms within two weeks of initiation of treatment. Partial relief of the neuralgic pain and headaches was obtained immediately after completion of the first treatment indicating that resolution of symptoms was related to the eff ects of MF and not to a spontaneous remission. This is the first report demonstrating the clinical efficacy of pico Tesla range MF in rapidly resolving an acute relapse of MS. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  *Electromagnetic Fields Multiple Sclerosis/*therapy ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Case Report Facial Expression Female Human Middle Age Migraine/complications Multiple Sclerosis/complications Serotonin Treatment Outcome Trigeminal Neuralgia/complications PUBLICATION TYPES:   JOURNAL ARTICLE CAS REGISTRY NUMBERS:   50-67-9 (Serotonin) LANGUAGES:  Eng National Library of Medicine: IGM Full Record Screen TITLE:   Initial exploration of pulsing electromagnetic fields for treatment of migraine. AUTHORS:    Sherman RA; Robson L; Marden LA AUTHOR AFFILIATION:  Service of Orthopedic Surgery, Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma,  Wash. 98431, USA. SOURCE:  Headache 1998 Mar;38(3):208-13 CITATION IDS:  PMID: 9563212 UI: 98224316 ABSTRACT:   Two studies were conducted during which 23 patients with chronic migraine were exposed to pulsing electromagnetic fields over the inner thigh. In an open study, 11 subjects kept a 2-week headache log before and after 2 to 3 weeks of exposure to pulsing electromagnetic fields for 1 hour per day, 5 days per week. The number of headaches per week decreased from 4.03 during the baseline period to 0.43 during the initial 2-week follow-up period and to 0.14 during the extended follow- up which averaged 8.1 months. In a double-blind study, 9 subjects kept a 3-week log of headache activity and were randomly assigned to receive 2 weeks of real or placebo pulsing electromagnetic field exposures as described above. They were subsequently switched to 2 weeks of the other mode, after which they kept a final 3-week log. Three additional subjects in the blind study inadvertently received half-power pulsing electromagnetic field exposures. The 6 subjects exposed to the actual device first showed a change in headache activity from 3.32 per week to 0.58 per week. The 3 subjects exposed to only half the dose showed no change in headache activity. Large controlled studies should be performed to determine whether this intervention is actually effective. MAIN MESH HEADINGS:  *Electromagnetic Fields Migraine/*therapy ADDITIONAL MESH HEADINGS:  Adult Aged Chronic Disease Double-Blind Method Female Follow-Up Studies Human Male Middle Age Migraine/physiopathology Support, U.S. Gov’t, Non-P.H.S. Thigh/blood supply PUBLICATION TYPES:   CLINICAL TRIAL JOURNAL ARTICLE RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL LANGUAGES:  Eng

Response:

OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc.

THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of. In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur.

This can be construed to be making a medical claim…….quite illegal. They definitely work to take the pain away,

pain is considered a medical term, hence: medical claim Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have

hmmmmm…..OA?  is that short for a medical disease?

Response:

OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc. THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of.

One of the things to remember is that this is an international board.  While those of us in the USA might want to be playing by the FDA rules they do not pertain to our international friends. I have no idea who posted the original message about osteoarthritis but thought a simple reminder that we are not all playing by the same rules would be prudent. Susan

Response:

The claims made below were strictly mine about my own personal experience using neodymium magnets.  My claims are true….these are my conditions so what is the problem here? Marlynn – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – OA in both hips, chronic low back pain, heel spurs, etc. THIS naming diseases is exactly what the FDA disapproves of. In most cases I find that, for me, it’s not necesary to use anything other than the small, unobtrusive magnet, or several of them at once, which I happen to be doing now, for a heel spur. This can be construed to be making a medical claim…….quite illegal. They definitely work to take the pain away, pain is considered a medical term, hence: medical claim Unfortunately my OA flares up occasionally, but I just wear a magnetic back belt that I have hmmmmm…..OA?  is that short for a medical disease?

Response:

My daughter has just been diagnosed with TMJ.  Has anyone heard of using magnetic therapy for this?

Response:

My daughter has just been diagnosed with TMJ.  Has anyone heard of using magnetic therapy for this?

Yes, we have a couple of dentist who use the products in their practice and it has helped with TMJ. If you would like, I can get you in touch with them. – Jim

Response:

re TMJ and magnetic therapy, I’ve used one for my neck and back at times and do feel relief.  I can see no reason why it wouldn’t work as well for TMJ.   Here’s something else to try if that doesn’t work:  I have fibromyalgia and have spent much time with a physical therapist (with a  prescription from my rheumatologist so it’s covered by insurance.)  The therapist also showed me how to do therapy on my own TMJ – a procedure using pressure on the inside and back of the lower molars from inside the mouth.  It sounds strange but it does work.    Make sure the therapist knows what  (s)he is doing as it could also make you worse if it’s  not done right.   Good luck!

Response:

| Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – | Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

Why are you skeptial? If this therapy works, then why question it results. There appears to no side effects from this treatment.

Response:

writes: Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

I believe Jane Heimlich writes about magnet therapy in her book "What Your Doctor Won’t Tell You."  You can probably find it in most of the larger chain bookstores.  She also writes about other alternative therapies like chelation, etc.  She’s married to the "Heimlich Maneuver" guy, and is a champion of a lot of alternative approaches. Hope it helps.    

Response:

I have recently been introduced to the field of Magnetic Therapy, particularly in the use of pain control and increased circulation. As you may have guessed, I am skeptical, as are many of the people I have talked to about it. I have become a distributor of Magnetic therapy products, but I would like to find out if there are people doing studies on these devices, and if so where can I get the results. Any comments, what ever you have would be welcome. Jerry Wiebe

Response:

Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

Response:

Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). doug

Hi Doug, I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems in most conditions. Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. –Gary

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – | Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative | | | | | Anybody out there have any experience with magnetic therapy for arthritus. | This deals with some new testing going on using magentic fields to | stimulate the growth and repair of Cartilage.  Is there anything to this? | | Thanks in advance to your repsonse(s). | | doug | | | Hi Doug, | | I’m a holistic health care practitioner and have used magnetic therapy successfully | in sebveral applications. When I recently fractured the cuboid bone in my foot, I | used a magnet on it every day and the pain and healing effects were quite positive. | | Just one thing to keep in mind: always use the North (negative) side of the magnet. | Please be sure about this since the South (positive) pole can create more problems | in most conditions. | | Also, the physical size of the magnet correlates with penetration depth, and the | Gauss (strength) of the magnet correlates to how long to apply it per session. | | –Gary Is there any research supporting your opinion, Gary??? If not, you experimented with it and it may have worked for you. Would it work for someone else? I don’t know. If there’s no studies to back you up, please say so.

For anyone out there interested in doing a little reading on this subject the following list is for you.  I have been sleeping on a magnetic mattress now for almost four years. My, own experience, I believe I sleep better on it than off. jim Received: from locator (occs2.nlm.nih.gov) by nlm.nih.gov (4.1/SMI-4.0) Received: by locator (AIX 3.2/UCB 5.64/4.10) Status: RO 31 of 55 AUTHOR        Biomagnetic Effects Workshop, 1978, Lawrence Berkeley                   Laboratory TITLE         Magnetic field effect on biological systems : based on the                   proceedings of the Biomagnetic Effects Workshop held at                   Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, University of California, on                   April 6-7, 1978 PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum, c1979. DESCRIPTION   108 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   BB5260 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Limited cataloging. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        8106160 ISBN          0-306-40312-9. LC CARD NO    79-20739 32 of 55 AUTHOR        Dubrov, A. P. (Aleksandr Petrovich) TITLE         The geomagnetic field and life : geomagnetobiology               Geomagnitnoe pole i zhizn’ : geomagnetobiology PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum Press, c1978. DESCRIPTION   xvii, 318 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 162.M3 D819g 1978a ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Magnetics               Physiology NOTES         Translation of Geomagnitnoe pole i zhizn’.               Bilbiography: p. 255-311. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        7901234 ISBN          0-306-31072-4. LC CARD NO    78-1705 52 of 55 AUTHOR        Barnothy, Madeleine F., 1904- TITLE         Biological effects of magnetic fields. PUBLISHER     New York, Plenum Press, 1964. DESCRIPTION   ix, 324 p. illus. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 B262b 1964 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Magnetics LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        0001325 1 of 55 AUTHOR        Bachmann, Kurt, 1929-               Stefan, Hermann               Vieth, Jurgen TITLE         Biomagnetism : principles, models, and clinical research :                   proceedings of the opening symposium of the Biomagnetic                   Center Erlangen (5.-6. October 1990) PUBLISHER     Erlangen : Verlag Palm & Enke, 1992. DESCRIPTION   118 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 B61125 1990 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biomedical Engineering – methods – congresses               Electroencephalography – congresses               Magnetics – diagnostic use – congresses               Magnetoencephalography – congresses NOTES         Includes bibliographical references and indexes. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9308754 ISBN          3-7896-0507-7. 2 of 55 AUTHOR        Hoke, M. (Manfried)               International Conference on Biomagnetism, 8th, 1991, Munster in                   Westfalen, Germany TITLE         Biomagnetism : clinical aspects : proceedings of the 8th                   International Conference on Biomagnetism, Munster, 19-24                   August, 1991 PUBLISHER     Amsterdam ; New York : Excerpta Medica, 1992. DESCRIPTION   xxii, 904 p. : ill. SERIES        International congress series ; no. 988 CALL NUMBER   W3 EX89 no.988 1992 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Brain Diseases – therapy – congresses               Evoked Potentials – congresses               Heart Diseases – therapy – congresses               Magnetics – therapeutic use – congresses NOTES         Includes bibliographical references and index. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9216444 ISBN          0-444-89268-0 (alk. paper). 3 of 55 AUTHOR        Lissens, Mark A. TITLE         Clinical applications of magnetic transcranial stimulation PUBLISHER     Leuven : Uitgeverij Peeters, 1992. DESCRIPTION   xi, 300 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   WL 300 C641 1992 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Central Nervous System Diseases – therapy               Evoked Potentials               Magnetics               Physical Stimulation NOTES         Includes bibliographical references. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9314351 ISBN          90-6831-434-3. 6 of 55 AUTHOR        Philpott, William H., 1919-               Taplin, Sharon Lindsay TITLE         Biomagnetic handbook : today’s introduction to the energy                   medicine of tomorrow               Today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow :                   today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow               Guide to medical magnetics, the energy medicine of tomorrow :                   today’s introduction to the energy medicine of tomorrow PUBLISHER     Choctaw, OK : Enviro-Tech Products, c1990. DESCRIPTION   97 leaves : ill. CALL NUMBER   WB 890 P549b 1990 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Magnetics               Alternative Medicine NOTES         A Guide to medical magnetics, the energy medicine of                   tomorrow–Cover.               Includes bibliographical references (leaves 92-93). LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9204875 8 of 55 AUTHOR        Williamson, Samuel J.               International Conference on Biomagnetism, 7th, 1989, New York,                   N.Y. TITLE         Advances in biomagnetism PUBLISHER     New York : Plenum Press, c1989. DESCRIPTION   xx, 771 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   QT 34 I61425a 1989 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biophysics               Electromagnetics – congresses               Evoked Potentials – congresses               Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on                   Biomagnetism, held August 13-18, 1989, in New York, New                   York–T.p. verso.               Includes bibliographical references and indexes. LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9310981 ISBN          0-306-43483-0. LC CARD NO    89-49359 17 of 55 AUTHOR        Evans, Bruce A.               American Association of Electromyography and Electrodiagnosis TITLE         Use of magnetic stimulation in the peripheral nervous system :                   an AAEE workshop PUBLISHER     [Rochester, Minn.] : American Association of Electromyography                   and Electrodiagnosis, [c1988] DESCRIPTION   4 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   WB 141 E917u 1988 ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Electric Stimulation – methods               Electrodiagnosis – methods               Magnetics               Peripheral Nerves NOTES         Includes bibliographical references (p. 4). LANGUAGE      English NLM UI        9209125 29 of 55 AUTHOR        Erne, S. N. (Sergio Nicola), 1944-               Hahlbohm, H. D., 1930-               Lubbig, H., 1932-               International Workshop on Biomagnetism, 3rd, 1980, Berlin,                   Germany TITLE         Biomagnetism : proceedings, Third International Workshop on                   Biomagnetism, Berlin (West), May 1980 PUBLISHER     Berlin ; New York : Walter de Gruyter, 1981. DESCRIPTION   xviii, 558 p. : ill. CALL NUMBER   W3 IN9324NI 3rd 1980b ACCESS        Circulation Desk SUBJECTS      Biomedical Engineering – congresses               Biophysics – congresses               Magnetics – congresses NOTES         Proceedings of earlier workshops not published. LANGUAGE    

… read more »

Response:

 JL Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy?  JL I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to  JL relieve  discomfort in the body.  Any comments? It appears that this message is coming from Germany.  Your name isn’t German, so I’m guessing your in the military.   yes, I can give you some information on magnetic therapy.  The Japanese have been using it for over 20 years.  I heard that one out of 8 homes in Japan are using this new technology.  The magnets are using in a rubberized material which is polarized so that it stimulates the body.  Magnetic waves pass through the tissue and secondary currents are induced.  This induction reduces pain and inflamation in the muscles and joints.  Magnetic waves penetrate the skin, fatty tissues and bones, invigorating general metabolism.  Magnetism seems to really stimulate circulation also.  We have found the magnetic insoles to be the most effective product for most problems involving circulation or pain in the legs or back.  My wife has been wearing them and they have done wonders for the pain she has due to adhesions.  Magnetic therapy helps arthritic pain, headaches, muscle aches, etc.  We have a friend who is going to have to have his spinal cord cut due to extreme pain in his body.  We are going to have him to try the magnetic seat and insoles to see is this will help with the pain.  If you have more questions feel free to respond. Ken ___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12

Response:

Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy? I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to relieve discomfort in the body.  Any comments? —               – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – -              Take the calculated risks; to dream and to build,              to fail and to succeed.  Enjoy the challenges of                   life and the thrill of fulfillment.  * Origin: Medical System Munich

Response:

Does anyone have any information on the benefits of Magnetic Therapy? I heard that this is a form of accupressure used successfully to relieve discomfort in the body.  Any comments? —               – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – - – -              Take the calculated risks; to dream and to build,              to fail and to succeed.  Enjoy the challenges of                   life and the thrill of fulfillment.

Response:

a question about an herb

Question:

Hello, whoever you are! In Germany there is a treatment of outdoor patiens in a small allergological and lung hospital at L

Sulfur

Question:

It kills more people every year than any other inhaled poison. That might depend on the country. How about carbon monoxide?

Carbon Monoxide is up there but H2S is the leading killer in the US.  It chiefly kills people in refining (gas seepage from oil wells), construction (excavating) and waste disposal (landfill gas).

Response:

However, these are the relatively benign sulphur gases.

There is no such thing. You end up with either a lung full of sulphonic or a lung full of sulphuric acid. There’s nothing benign about either of those compounds in contact with the alveoli !!! Chris — Chris King http://www.csking.demon.co.uk

Response:

However, these are the relatively benign sulphur gases. There is no such thing.

Note the "relatively". Hydrogen sulfide (the "bad-egg" smell) is not _too_ bad, in comparison with sulphur dioxide f’rinstance. At least it doesn’t kill instantly and it acts as a graphic warning that there might be worse gases around. But every time I encounter it, I wish I could break my childhood conditioning and learn how to hawk-and-spit….          Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com), from grimy Tokyo

Response:

Hydrogen sulfide (the "bad-egg" smell) is not _too_ bad, in comparison with sulphur dioxide f’rinstance. At least it doesn’t kill instantly and it acts as a graphic warning that there might be worse gases around.

Hydrogen sulfide is a _very_ dangerous gas.  It kills more people every year than any other inhaled poison.  (Yes, hydrogen sulfide is classified as a poisonous gas.) What makes the stuff particularly deadly is that it quickley numbs the sense of smell – so just at the time you no longer smell it is when you are in the most danger.

Response:

Hydrogen sulfide is a _very_ dangerous gas.  

I am not saying it’s not dangerous–just that it’s less immediately so than, say, sulphur dioxide which is colourless, odourless, almost instantly lethal, and has a nasty habit of hanging around in sticky "bubbles" to trap the unwary. Rightly or wrongly, that’s the one that worries me worst. And isn’t it the most likely gas to be produced by burning sulfur, which is the origin of this thread? But the rotten-eggs smell of hydrogen sulphide does give some warning, especially in the open air. Seeing as how I have problems near volcanos, possibly because of that smell, I can’t imagine why anyone would willingly inhale _any_ such fumes to "cure" breathing problems, but it seems that people do, in various different countries around the world. Why, I wonder? It kills more people every year than any other inhaled poison.  

That might depend on the country. How about carbon monoxide? What makes the stuff particularly deadly is that it quickley numbs the sense of smell – so just at the time you no longer smell it is when you are in the most danger.

Yuk. I didn’t know that–and I’ve never hung around long enough to find it out for myself.          Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com), from grimy Tokyo

Response:

at Pozzuoli, near Neaples, there are solftaras or natural steam vents with sulfur gases.  Nearby people camp in tents in the hope of curing their chest conditions (including I believe asthma).  There is even a small building with very intense sulfur fumes in it through which the poor devils had to run in the past to get a really intensive dose, or at any rate this is what I was able to gather from listening to people. Perhaps somebody who has lived in the district ccould add more details.

There are similar folk beliefs in Japan. I’ve seen hot-spring resorts that advertise the beneficial effects on breathing disorders (not necessarily asthma) of their waters. Near active craters, I’ve seen setups that reminded me of washing facilities at campsites–a long feeder pipe with yellow-stained nozzles at regular intervals, over a trough. At one, there was a row of grandads, many of them still holding cigarettes in their spare hands, breathing deeply of the fumes from the nozzles then breaking into violent spasms of hawking and spitting into the trough. They looked like a bizarre parody of a chorus line. But I know I have problems near volcanos, so I avoid places where fumes are obvious, or at least I pre-med heavily. However, these are the relatively benign sulphur gases. As far as I know, there’s no way to guarantee that simply burning sulphur will produce only those compounds. There was an incident recently in the mountains here, where a group of experienced hikers were following a well-marked "safe" path across an semi-active crater and up the other side, but got turned around in the fog. They knew they’d gone wrong when they couldn’t see any more warning signs, so they tried to turn back. They blundered into a gully where sulfur gases had collected. Several of them keeled over instantly and were dead within minutes. There are also "famous" suicide sites at volcanoes–favoured because they gave a rapid death. The authorities used to leave the bodies in place, because there was no way to collect them. Be very careful about burning sulfur.          Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com), from grimy Tokyo

Response:

I know very little about asthma, but became curious after my friend translated a message from Spanish to English for another friend who’s son has asthma and is seeking a "cure".  The "doctor" she is conversing with suggests that she try his treatment – part of which consists of having her son inhale burning sulfur fumes. Has anyone ever heard of this type of treatment, or know if it’s dangerous?

Karen Since you didn’t provide a valid e-mail address, you’ll have to make do with a posted response !!! Deliberately inhaling sulphur fumes (sulphur dioxide) is *extremely* dangerous, even for non-asthmatics – it could prove fatal for someone with a respiratory disorder. I would suggest that your friend avoids this "doctor" like the plague ! Chris It is just one of those uncomfortable facts about asthma.  For instance at Pozzuoli, near Neaples, there are solftaras or natural steam vents with sulfur gases.  Nearby people camp in tents in the hope of curing their chest conditions (including I believe asthma).  There is even a small building with very intense sulfur fumes in it through which the poor devils had to run in the past to get a really intensive dose, or at any rate this is what I was able to gather from listening to people. Perhaps somebody who has lived in the district ccould add more details. To my mind it simply goes to confimr the impression that any stunning or very impressive distraction, like a surgical operation to cut the vagus nerve as in the past, will tend to stop asthma for a short while.  See CBI

Civility

Question:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : You’re a pathetic asshole, Paul. You whine and bleat hysterically : about besmirching the memory of your poor, deceased father when : someone  sophomorically twists your last name around (Inane, etc). : Yet you just can’t seem to acknowledge any pain you might have : caused, inadvertantly to be sure, with your cavalier use of the word : ‘Nazi’. : : You suffer from such a bloated opinion of yourself. And the result : is that people like me, who are supposed to be on your side, end up : looking forward to the next chance to dump on you. : : Do get some therapy. : — Right, Robert. You have flamed me since day one, but supposedly you’re on my side. Get real. The word ‘Nazi’ is treated like the empress’s thigh. It’s a word. I used it once, maybe four months ago, when provoked. Now you and Rich want to make something huge out of it. How boring.

Actually it was a test to see if you had it within yourself to acknowledge pain you might have caused others, and apologize. Apparently, you’re incapable of doing that. Sad, for a supposed healer. — Robert Greenstein                 When you’re right 95% of the time,

Response:

: It just doesn’t bother me when people call you a quack. : : : : sdb : : Thanks for admitting that the whole business with the dictionary : was just crap.   : : Paul, I’ve already said I don’t approve of the use of the word : quack. [...] : Surely you notice that DS is gone. Guess MIT didn’t agree with you : or him about what is acceptable. : : Yes, well – if that’s why DS is gone, it’s certainly a shame that they : caved into a petty little fascist like you. : : sdb The petty little fascist is gone. Most of us would gladly invite you to follow him out the door. —

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : I only used the first term here in as an adjective referring to the : aforesaid anonymous poster and his insistence that I fulfill his : standards of expectation or suffer his libels. : : I realize that you think that it was appropriate to call DragonSlayer : a "Nazi" for the statements made by him. It is sad that you : could rationalize calling someone who was just expressing his : opinion such a thing. I have had relatives die in concentration : camps as a result of the Nazi holocaust and it is an insult Blah, blah, blah. Yes, I know all about that personal tragedy, and it is essentially a monotonal point-of-view. I did not call DS a Nazi, I called his behavior ‘Nazi,’ but the word fascist (which my Italian relatives suffered plenty under) would do as well, and would not involve me in the self-pities of history. You’re a pathetic asshole, Paul. You whine and bleat hysterically about besmirching the memory of your poor, deceased father when someone sophomorically twists your last name around (Inane, etc). Yet you just can’t seem to acknowledge any pain you might have caused, inadvertantly to be sure, with your cavalier use of the word ‘Nazi’. You suffer from such a bloated opinion of yourself. And the result is that people like me, who are supposed to be on your side, end up looking forward to the next chance to dump on you. Do get some therapy. — Robert Greenstein                 When you’re right 95% of the time,

I agree with you Robert that Paul is in need of therapy but I am not at all optimistic that the therapy would be successful because one important ingredient for success is missing. That ingredient is an awareness that he has a problem. It is likely that if Paul got into therapy he would complain bitterly about how he is only trying to help people but people don’t appreciate or respect him and only attack him for no reason. He is completely unable to see the nature of his own problem and offensiveness. Actually I don’t think that Paul has a bloated opinion of himself at all. I think his self esteem is extremely low and he tries to compensate for it by trying to get other people to acknowledge his accomplishments and to give him respect. He does not realize that one needs to feel good about oneself and have some selfrespect before anyone will respect him. It is sad and ironic that the individual who tries to come across to others as a caring healer actually has essentially no capacity for empathy. This is very clear from most of his postings and is especially true in his response to my expressing a very personal feeling about his using the term "Nazi" to describe DragonSlayer who clearly was using rather strong language to describe Paul but Paul uses even stronger language and then justifies it (adjective instead of a noun is somehow supposed to make the term "Nazi" Ok. And since when is "Nazi" and adjective. The term WAS used as a noun and like so many times Paul is trying to avoid taking responsibility for his statements but he threatens frivilous lawsuits against those who make comments about him). I know very little about Paul and his life but as I have said before it is very likely that he had a very difficult life (which is no excuse for his behavior but does help to understand it). It is because I realize that Paul obviously has very serious problems that I don’t get angry at him for his apparent total insensitivity to my feelings and the feelings of other posters in this group. He got DS kicked off the server for calling him a quack. I think if anything Paul should be prevented from advising (without even being licensed to practice medicine) a parent to stop asthma medication for their very ill infant when this may result in the infants death. Paul’s undying support of ETH prevents him from considering other possibilities and this could be quite deadly for those listening to his advice. Paul will some day find out the hard way when some naive and trusting person listens to his advice and then someone dies as a result. Yes people die from conventional treatments also. The difference is that there is scientific validation for certain therapies and that despite the scientific validation no treatment works 100% of the time. Aloha, Rich ——- Richard Jacobson Better to be uncertain about something than to be sure and be wrong about it

Response:

| <snip | : | : Yes, well – if that’s why DS is gone, it’s certainly a shame that they | : caved into a petty little fascist like you. | : | : sdb | | The petty little fascist is gone. Most of us would gladly invite you to follow | him out the door. | | | | | — No, most of us would not. Most of us ARE sick of the total waste of bandwidth used up by this endless, endless, endless, endless, endless, endless, endless, endless, endless, never ending, endless bickering.  Did I mention how tired WE are of the endless, endless, endless, endless, endless bickering?  Believe me, I personally know everyone who reads this newsgroup, and I can therefore speak for everyone.  Everyone, Gorddummit! — Troy M. Hash                        I like to write ‘endless’ !! My Opinions Do Not Reflect Those Of My Employer <<<<!! "You’ll be absolutely free, Only if you want to be…"F.Zappa

Response:

: : Surely you notice that DS is gone. Guess MIT didn’t agree with you : or him about : what is acceptable. : Apparently you are right. Wonder if MIT would agree with *you* about : the acceptability of your postings. :  You probably won’t have to worry about that though :-0) DS is gone because he violated MIT policy on personal attacks on the Internet. I do not violate any MIT policies, or Usenet policies for that matter. Whether MIT like the color of my underwear is hardly the point. —

Yes Paul I realize that you think that DS is gone because he violated MIT policies on personal attacks on the internet. It is not clear if that is the reason that he is gone. It could be because he was using MIT account with anonymous name which is not allowed by this school. And it is a matter of personal opinion whether or not you are as guilty as DS as making personal attacks against others.  It is not surprising that you do not think so. I suspect that it is with great pain that you could ever admit that you did anything wrong. Aloha, Rich ——- Richard Jacobson Better to be uncertain about something than to be sure and be wrong about it

Response:

: You’re a pathetic asshole, Paul. You whine and bleat hysterically : about besmirching the memory of your poor, deceased father when : someone  sophomorically twists your last name around (Inane, etc). : Yet you just can’t seem to acknowledge any pain you might have : caused, inadvertantly to be sure, with your cavalier use of the word : ‘Nazi’. : : You suffer from such a bloated opinion of yourself. And the result : is that people like me, who are supposed to be on your side, end up : looking forward to the next chance to dump on you. : : Do get some therapy. : — Right, Robert. You have flamed me since day one, but supposedly you’re on my side. Get real. The word ‘Nazi’ is treated like the empress’s thigh. It’s a word. I used it once, maybe four months ago, when provoked. Now you and Rich want to make something huge out of it. How boring. —

Response:

writes: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : : Surely you notice that DS is gone. Guess MIT didn’t agree with you : or him about : what is acceptable. : Apparently you are right. Wonder if MIT would agree with *you* about : the acceptability of your postings. :  You probably won’t have to worry about that though :-0) DS is gone because he violated MIT policy on personal attacks on the Internet. I do not violate any MIT policies, or Usenet policies for that matter. Whether MIT like the color of my underwear is hardly the point. — Yes Paul I realize that you think that DS is gone because he violated MIT policies on personal attacks on the internet. It is not clear if that is the reason that he is gone. It could be because he was using MIT account with anonymous name which is not allowed by this school. And it is a matter of personal opinion whether or not you are as guilty as DS as making personal attacks against others.  It is not surprising that you do not think so. I suspect that it is with great pain that you could ever admit that you did anything wrong. Aloha, Rich ——- Richard Jacobson Better to be uncertain about something than to be sure and be wrong about it

And the ghost of DS lives on.

Response:

: : Surely you notice that DS is gone. Guess MIT didn’t agree with you : or him about : what is acceptable. : Apparently you are right. Wonder if MIT would agree with *you* about : the acceptability of your postings. :  You probably won’t have to worry about that though :-0) DS is gone because he violated MIT policy on personal attacks on the Internet. I do not violate any MIT policies, or Usenet policies for that matter. Whether MIT like the color of my underwear is hardly the point. —

Response:

: I only used the first term here in as an adjective referring to the : aforesaid anonymous poster and his insistence that I fulfill his : standards of expectation or suffer his libels. : : I realize that you think that it was appropriate to call DragonSlayer : a "Nazi" for the statements made by him. It is sad that you : could rationalize calling someone who was just expressing his : opinion such a thing. I have had relatives die in concentration : camps as a result of the Nazi holocaust and it is an insult Blah, blah, blah. Yes, I know all about that personal tragedy, and it is essentially a monotonal point-of-view. I did not call DS a Nazi, I called his behavior ‘Nazi,’ but the word fascist (which my Italian relatives suffered plenty under) would do as well, and would not involve me in the self-pities of history. : As for ‘idiotic’ and ‘ridiculous’–many things are, but when I : react in this manner I am usually apologetic. Nonetheless, they are : context driven. I would  be happy to defend the point-of-view, if : not its actual terminology. : : I rarely see your posts apologizing for these statements which you : make very freely. Which is because I have only used such words twice or three times, and don’t consider it meaningful to apologize weekly for those who may have missed my mea culpas. : Rich, you gyrate wildly between Good Guy strategy and hostile : inquisitor. This is Good Guy. I have less of a range. You will have : to excuse me. : : Yes I realize that you think I gyrate wildly. I really don’t think so. : I think I have basically been consistent with my statements with : occasional use of sarcasm and humor to illustrate my points. I am not the only person here who thinks this. You were certainly not respectful to me when you first came around. Things have changed. Which I do appreciate. : I try to treat people with respect. I realize that you feel very : strongly about ETH and feel you are providing an excellent : health service to your clients. I have no doubt that your : intentions are good. I do however question the validity of : your methods. Perhaps you could give me some sources : of literature which demonstrates the "scientific" documentation : for your methods as you alleged before. : : Richard Jacobson I have said that this isn’t my fight. But what kind of docs are you after? There are tons of Chinese hospital studies. There are tons of herbal studies on animal models. I could offer a pile of those from my library, but I don’t collect or particularly scrutinize such ‘evidences.’ —

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : I only used the first term here in as an adjective referring to the : aforesaid anonymous poster and his insistence that I fulfill his : standards of expectation or suffer his libels. : : I realize that you think that it was appropriate to call DragonSlayer : a "Nazi" for the statements made by him. It is sad that you : could rationalize calling someone who was just expressing his : opinion such a thing. I have had relatives die in concentration : camps as a result of the Nazi holocaust and it is an insult Blah, blah, blah. Yes, I know all about that personal tragedy, and it is essentially a monotonal point-of-view. I did not call DS a Nazi, I called his behavior ‘Nazi,’ but the word fascist (which my Italian relatives suffered plenty under) would do as well, and would not involve me in the self-pities of history.

It is often difficult to understand the feelings of others. I also realize that you don’t think that you called DragonSlayer a Nazi. With all due respect Paul I think that sometimes you type things into the computer without realizing what you type and then when called on it deny you said it. The same thing applied to when you said homeopathy was "mildly" invasive and then vehemently said that you never said "mildly" but instead said "minimally" as if there is a signifigant difference between the words. Again with all due respect Paul you seem to want people to respect you and what you do. But you rarely seem to acknowledge the feelings of others. Empathy, IMHO, is one of the most important qualities of a healer. With all due respect again, I see so little empathy for those who happen to post here when they happen to express something different from what you believe. You use EXTREMELY strong language with people and then are offended when they do the same to you. : As for ‘idiotic’ and ‘ridiculous’–many things are, but when I : react in this manner I am usually apologetic. Nonetheless, they are : context driven. I would  be happy to defend the point-of-view, if : not its actual terminology. : : I rarely see your posts apologizing for these statements which you : make very freely. Which is because I have only used such words twice or three times, and don’t consider it meaningful to apologize weekly for those who may have missed my mea culpas.

Again Paul, with all due respect, I don’t think you are aware of how frequently you use such words. I would estimate two or three times a week that you say such things or similar. Those who read these posts regularly likely will confirm this. Why not go over some of you posts to see how you talk to others. Perhaps if you review them you will see what I mean. I suspect that you will say that you were justified in using these kinds of words or make some condescending remark to me (like I am trying to run for Pope). : Rich, you gyrate wildly between Good Guy strategy and hostile : inquisitor. This is Good Guy. I have less of a range. You will have : to excuse me. : : Yes I realize that you think I gyrate wildly. I really don’t think so. : I think I have basically been consistent with my statements with : occasional use of sarcasm and humor to illustrate my points. I am not the only person here who thinks this. You were certainly not respectful to me when you first came around. Things have changed. Which I do appreciate.

If I have offended you I apologize. My sense was that I WAS respectful when I first came around. Then perhaps out of some frustration that my comments were not being acknowledged I became a bit more aggressive in my remarks. I always try to respect others even if they don’t show me respect. I realize that those who have difficulty respecting others or who are very angry have often led very difficult lives and while this may not be an excuse for the behavior it certainly does help to explain it. I have received many comments by private mail from individuals who have commended me on my restraint and attempts to show respect despite not being reciprocated. I know that I am not perfect and that I will occasionally make an inappropriate or offensive remark. And when I do I try to acknowledge it. : I try to treat people with respect. I realize that you feel very : strongly about ETH and feel you are providing an excellent : health service to your clients. I have no doubt that your : intentions are good. I do however question the validity of : your methods. Perhaps you could give me some sources : of literature which demonstrates the "scientific" documentation : for your methods as you alleged before. : : Richard Jacobson I have said that this isn’t my fight. But what kind of docs are you after? There are tons of Chinese hospital studies. There are tons of herbal studies on animal models. I could offer a pile of those from my library, but I don’t collect or particularly scrutinize such ‘evidences.’

I realize that you think I am "after" some kind of doc. In fact, again with all due respect Paul, you seem to think that anyone who does not agree with what you say or is critical of your statements somehow is out to get you. There is a quality of paranoia that is quite strong. I imagine that the anger that you feel inside is often very uncomfortable to deal with and I would suggest that you get some professional help to deal with it. Aloha, Rich —

——- Richard Jacobson Better to be uncertain about something than to be sure and be wrong about it

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : I only used the first term here in as an adjective referring to the : aforesaid anonymous poster and his insistence that I fulfill his : standards of expectation or suffer his libels. : : I realize that you think that it was appropriate to call DragonSlayer : a "Nazi" for the statements made by him. It is sad that you : could rationalize calling someone who was just expressing his : opinion such a thing. I have had relatives die in concentration : camps as a result of the Nazi holocaust and it is an insult Blah, blah, blah. Yes, I know all about that personal tragedy, and it is essentially a monotonal point-of-view. I did not call DS a Nazi, I called his behavior ‘Nazi,’ but the word fascist (which my Italian relatives suffered plenty under) would do as well, and would not involve me in the self-pities of history.

You’re a pathetic asshole, Paul. You whine and bleat hysterically about besmirching the memory of your poor, deceased father when someone sophomorically twists your last name around (Inane, etc). Yet you just can’t seem to acknowledge any pain you might have caused, inadvertantly to be sure, with your cavalier use of the word ‘Nazi’. You suffer from such a bloated opinion of yourself. And the result is that people like me, who are supposed to be on your side, end up looking forward to the next chance to dump on you. Do get some therapy. — Robert Greenstein                 When you’re right 95% of the time,

Response:

: Right, Robert. You have flamed me since day one, but supposedly : you’re on my side. Get real. The word ‘Nazi’ is treated like the : empress’s thigh. It’s a word. I used it once, maybe four months : ago, when provoked. Now you and Rich want to make something huge : out of it. How boring. : : Actually it was a test to see if you had it within yourself to : acknowledge pain you might have caused others, and apologize. : Apparently, you’re  incapable of doing that. Sad, for a supposed : healer.  – How ridiculous, Robert. Jump through your own hoops. —

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : : DS is gone because he violated MIT policy on personal attacks on : the Internet. I do not violate any MIT policies, or Usenet policies : for that matter. Whether MIT like the color of my underwear is : hardly the point. : : Yes Paul I realize that you think that DS is gone because he violated : MIT policies on personal attacks on the internet. It is not clear if : that is the reason that he is gone. It could be because he was : using MIT account with anonymous name which is not allowed : by this school. As usual, Rich, you’re busy with nothing but guesswork. The anonymous posting at those accounts was not the problem. They don’t provide access for people to harrass others, and his behavior was considered BY THEM (when I supplied them the posts) to be harrassment. At that point they would have simply warned him, but he hung himself out to dry by taunting them publicly that they would never find him. I don’t think administrations like being mocked in that way.

Thanx for making my point. MIT likely was upset at the anonymous nature of his posts as you pointed out when you said that they got angry at him for saying that they would never catch him. MIT does not like people to post anonymously. I also realize that you feel that it is ME who use guesswork.  Did you contact MIT to find out why DS was kicked off. If so who did you talk to as I would like to verify this. You accuse me of guesswork. Why not provide the group members with specific evidence that what you think is right. Why is your opinion not ALSO guesswork? : And it is a matter of personal opinion whether or : not you are as guilty as DS as making personal attacks against : others.   Look on the bottom of my posts, Rich. My name and the name of my provider is there. If you think I have violated a Net policy, file a complaint. Please. I am out in the open, above board.

Yes and that is the difference between you and DragonSlayer. You give your name and he did not. While I think that many of your posts are more offensive than DragonSlayer I think that you have a right to express your opinion just as I thought DragonSlayer had that right. I did not think it appropriate for DS to be kicked off because of what he had to say but if MIT has policy preventing anonymous postings from their site without their permission I could understand why they kicked him off. Actually I have considered expressing concern to admin about some of your posts where you tell people to stop potentially life threatening therapy and change to "kinder and gentler" methods. You give this advice without even examining the patient or taking a complete history. Not that your examination or history taking would have changed your mind about the treatment. Your decision about treatments seems independent of anything except your ideology.  But I decided not to because I think that you still have a right to express these opinions. Fortunately there are others who can provide an alternative view to yours. And the alternative view to your may be conventional. Aloha, Rich – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -:It is not surprising that you do not think so. I suspect : that it is with great pain that you could ever admit that you : did anything wrong. : : Aloha, : : Rich I have occasionally, in thousands of posts, called people names, which I regret. But I have NEVER engaged a systematic attempt to slander or defame anybody. Just yesterday I called you dimwitted. I regretted that, wished I’d said ‘obtuse.’ But your continued program of trying to shame me with my apparently horrendous conduct ignores the fact that a healer HAS to be somewhat aggressive. A person has to have the nerve to do more than say, ‘let’s all get along, mix all therapies, do our best, and be friends.’ How wimpy! I have to tell people to stop doing things that are hurting them, I have to fight off lies, slanders, and characterizations that are inaccurate (and then some), and to fight off mongrelization of the tradition. You want to be friends? Have a little respect for my continued work on those fronts. —

——- Richard Jacobson Better to be uncertain about something than to be sure and be wrong about it

Response:

: : DS is gone because he violated MIT policy on personal attacks on : the Internet. I do not violate any MIT policies, or Usenet policies : for that matter. Whether MIT like the color of my underwear is : hardly the point. : : Yes Paul I realize that you think that DS is gone because he violated : MIT policies on personal attacks on the internet. It is not clear if : that is the reason that he is gone. It could be because he was : using MIT account with anonymous name which is not allowed : by this school. As usual, Rich, you’re busy with nothing but guesswork. The anonymous posting at those accounts was not the problem. They don’t provide access for people to harrass others, and his behavior was considered BY THEM (when I supplied them the posts) to be harrassment. At that point they would have simply warned him, but he hung himself out to dry by taunting them publicly that they would never find him. I don’t think administrations like being mocked in that way. : And it is a matter of personal opinion whether or : not you are as guilty as DS as making personal attacks against : others.   Look on the bottom of my posts, Rich. My name and the name of my provider is there. If you think I have violated a Net policy, file a complaint. Please. I am out in the open, above board. :It is not surprising that you do not think so. I suspect : that it is with great pain that you could ever admit that you : did anything wrong. : : Aloha, : : Rich I have occasionally, in thousands of posts, called people names, which I regret. But I have NEVER engaged a systematic attempt to slander or defame anybody. Just yesterday I called you dimwitted. I regretted that, wished I’d said ‘obtuse.’ But your continued program of trying to shame me with my apparently horrendous conduct ignores the fact that a healer HAS to be somewhat aggressive. A person has to have the nerve to do more than say, ‘let’s all get along, mix all therapies, do our best, and be friends.’ How wimpy! I have to tell people to stop doing things that are hurting them, I have to fight off lies, slanders, and characterizations that are inaccurate (and then some), and to fight off mongrelization of the tradition. You want to be friends? Have a little respect for my continued work on those fronts. —

Response:

: I agree with you Robert that Paul is in need of therapy but I am not : at all optimistic that the therapy would be successful because one : important ingredient for success is missing. That ingredient is : an awareness that he has a problem. I know you guys think this is an appropriate use of bandwidth, but I hasten to disagree. The presumptuousness of the whole affair is stunning, though. What a bunch of cards! :It is likely that if Paul got : into therapy he would complain bitterly about how he is only trying : to help people but people don’t appreciate or respect him and only : attack him for no reason. He is completely unable to see the nature : of his own problem and offensiveness. Actually I don’t think that : Paul has a bloated opinion of himself at all. I think his self : esteem is extremely low and he tries to compensate for it by trying : to get other people to acknowledge his accomplishments and to give : him respect. Yeah, that’s right…I only heal to replace my lost teddy bear when I was four. : He does not realize that one needs to feel good about : oneself and have some selfrespect before anyone will respect him. Tell you what. I’ll restart my twenty year meditation practice, and get started on these issues RIGHT AWAY! No more time for the True Abstract…I’ve got SELF-PITY to study! : It is sad and ironic that the individual who tries to come across : to others as a caring healer actually has essentially no : capacity for empathy. This is very clear from most of his : postings and is especially true in his response to my expressing : a very personal feeling about his using the term "Nazi" to : describe DragonSlayer who clearly was using rather strong : language to describe Paul but Paul uses even stronger : language and then justifies it (adjective instead of a noun : is somehow supposed to make the term "Nazi" Ok. And : since when is "Nazi" and adjective. The term WAS used : as a noun and like so many times Paul is trying to avoid : taking responsibility for his statements but he threatens : frivilous lawsuits against those who make comments about : him). Yawn. Boring evening at home, huh, Rich? : I know very little about Paul and his life but as I have said : before it is very likely that he had a very difficult life (which : is no excuse for his behavior but does help to understand : it). It is because I realize that Paul obviously has very : serious problems that I don’t get angry at him for his : apparent total insensitivity to my feelings and the feelings : of other posters in this group. You are so kind. : He got DS kicked off the : server for calling him a quack. MIT didn’t need anything more than notice that this problem existed. Actually, in my opinion, it was DS’s own post (one of his last) when he essentially thumbed his nose at the school administration, that got him found out and booted. Sic Semper Tyrannis! : I think if anything Paul : should be prevented from advising (without even being : licensed to practice medicine) a parent to stop asthma : medication for their very ill infant when this may result : in the infants death. AS I HAVE NOTED SEVERAL TIMES–THAT CHILD WAS UNDER THE CARE OF AN M.D. The pathos, is, sniff, really to the point as usual, Rich. : Paul’s undying support of ETH : prevents him from considering other possibilities and : this could be quite deadly for those listening to his : advice. You have no idea what you’re talking about, but then again you have failed to actually read my posts. You repeatedly attack me for saying things I have never said, and you also deride me for other people’s comments. I cannot be all things to all people…certainly not all people to all people. : Paul will some day find out the hard way : when some naive and trusting person listens to his : advice and then someone dies as a result. I don’t treat such severe illnesses that this is an issue. As for ‘advise’ (a la DragonSlayer, RIP), I do my best to balance all the issues, and regularly kick people in the rear to go to M.D.’s and get the conventional diagnosis in risky cases. : Yes : people die from conventional treatments also. The : difference is that there is scientific validation for : certain therapies and that despite the scientific : validation no treatment works 100% of the time. Wow. Science. I’m sure we all feel a whole lot better. : Aloha, : : Rich —

Response:

: : This newsgroup is not ‘designated’ for alternative opinion. This is : just more of your uneducated blather. Every newsgroup on usenet has : what’s known as a ‘charter’ that defines the purpose of the : newsgroup. Why don’t you do something positive for a change and : discover how to read this charter, so that you can inform yourself : about the true nature of this newsgroup? I’ve read the charter. It specifically suggests that these subjects be moved to this group to get them out of sci.med. One has to ask, then, what do we have to do to get the sci.med people to stop condemning everything they find here. Duh. :

You read but you do not comprehend. Recall the portion of the charter that said discussion ‘pro and con’?  It seems you just can’t handle criticism. : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : libel. I doubt you would win. : : sdb The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot more than it will cost me, win or lose.

Yes, but he doesn’t have to go to California. He can stay right where he is. I don’t approve of nuisance suits used to suppress opinion. I think you’re a fascist. Of course, there’s the interesting possibility that DragonSlayer might just win, in which case you would have the label ‘quack’ permanently affixed to you forever. I’m not sure that wouldn’t cost you something. sdb —  * Origin: Medical System Munich – m

Response:

Is anyone aware of any adverse effects of prolonged psyllium use? Thanx, G.

Response:

:   : : I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to : : actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate : : people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to : : a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion. I agree with you Paul. It is very important to discuss ideas and not simply make character assassinations against those who happen to disagree with what you are saying. I could certainly understand your frustration in trying to discuss an issue and instead have someone attack you personally. I would respectfully suggest that with these ideas in mind you reflect on the manner in which *you* post statements. While I could certainly understand your frustration and anger I think it important if only to protect your own credibility (if that is imprtant to you) to not do unto others those things that you are quite critical of others doing unto you. In other words calling somone a "Nazi" after they called you a "Quack" is hardly what I would deem an appropriate response. While it is true that we have fredom of speech in this country I think that each of us needs to take some responsibility in exercising that freedom. If we do not then these freedoms will gradually be eroded. : : : : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : : libel. I doubt you would win. : : : : sdb : The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to : _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, : and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot : more than it will cost me, win or lose. Maybe that is an idiotic idea…maybe : I can’t control the situation at all, and maybe I choose to do something else : with my time. Although I see that you are very angry and want to get back at Dragonslayer for his maligning you my recommendation is not to proceed with a lawsuit especially given what you just wrote above, that being that it would be for nuissance purposes only being that you have nothing to lose. The filing of frivolous lawsuits is a very serious crime with harsh penalities against those that file them. Doubt if you could find any attorney who is reputable (oxymoron?:-) who would represent you. Aloha, Rich

Response:

:   : : I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to : : actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate : : people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to : : a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion. I agree with you Paul. It is very important to discuss ideas and not simply make character assassinations against those who happen to disagree with what you are saying. I could certainly understand your frustration in trying to discuss an issue and instead have someone attack you personally. I would respectfully suggest that with these ideas in mind you reflect on the manner in which *you* post statements. While I could certainly understand your frustration and anger I think it important if only to protect your own credibility (if that is imprtant to you) to not do unto others those things that you are quite critical of others doing unto you. In other words calling somone a "Nazi" after they called you a "Quack" is hardly what I would deem an appropriate response. While it is true that we have fredom of speech in this country I think that each of us needs to take some responsibility in exercising that freedom. If we do not then these freedoms will gradually be eroded. : : : : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : : libel. I doubt you would win. : : : : sdb : The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to : _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, : and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot : more than it will cost me, win or lose. Maybe that is an idiotic idea…maybe : I can’t control the situation at all, and maybe I choose to do something else : with my time. Although I see that you are very angry and want to get back at Dragonslayer for his maligning you my recommendation is not to proceed with a lawsuit especially given what you just wrote above, that being that it would be for nuissance purposes only being that you have nothing to lose. The filing of frivolous lawsuits is a very serious crime with harsh penalities against those that file them. Doubt if you could find any attorney who is reputable (oxymoron?:-) who would represent you. Aloha, Rich

Response:

: : This newsgroup is not ‘designated’ for alternative opinion. This is : just more of your uneducated blather. Every newsgroup on usenet has : what’s known as a ‘charter’ that defines the purpose of the : newsgroup. Why don’t you do something positive for a change and : discover how to read this charter, so that you can inform yourself : about the true nature of this newsgroup? I’ve read the charter. It specifically suggests that these subjects be moved to this group to get them out of sci.med. One has to ask, then, what do we have to do to get the sci.med people to stop condemning everything they find here. Duh. :

You read but you do not comprehend. Recall the portion of the charter that said discussion ‘pro and con’?  It seems you just can’t handle criticism. : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : libel. I doubt you would win. : : sdb The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot more than it will cost me, win or lose.

Yes, but he doesn’t have to go to California. He can stay right where he is. I don’t approve of nuisance suits used to suppress opinion. I think you’re a fascist. Of course, there’s the interesting possibility that DragonSlayer might just win, in which case you would have the label ‘quack’ permanently affixed to you forever. I’m not sure that wouldn’t cost you something. sdb —

Response:

:   : : I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to : : actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate : : people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to : : a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion. I agree with you Paul. It is very important to discuss ideas and not simply make character assassinations against those who happen to disagree with what you are saying. I could certainly understand your frustration in trying to discuss an issue and instead have someone attack you personally. I would respectfully suggest that with these ideas in mind you reflect on the manner in which *you* post statements. While I could certainly understand your frustration and anger I think it important if only to protect your own credibility (if that is imprtant to you) to not do unto others those things that you are quite critical of others doing unto you. In other words calling somone a "Nazi" after they called you a "Quack" is hardly what I would deem an appropriate response. While it is true that we have fredom of speech in this country I think that each of us needs to take some responsibility in exercising that freedom. If we do not then these freedoms will gradually be eroded. : : : : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : : libel. I doubt you would win. : : : : sdb : The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to : _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, : and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot : more than it will cost me, win or lose. Maybe that is an idiotic idea…maybe : I can’t control the situation at all, and maybe I choose to do something else : with my time. Although I see that you are very angry and want to get back at Dragonslayer for his maligning you my recommendation is not to proceed with a lawsuit especially given what you just wrote above, that being that it would be for nuissance purposes only being that you have nothing to lose. The filing of frivolous lawsuits is a very serious crime with harsh penalities against those that file them. Doubt if you could find any attorney who is reputable (oxymoron?:-) who would represent you. Aloha, Rich  * Origin: Medical System Munich – medsys.muc.de (80:8

Response:

: Oh, nonsense. I would hope that good old MIT has not gone that far off : track that they would let a little bully like you turn them into : censors. You’re so totally clueless about the net that you don’t even : realize that even *if* you manage to talk MIT into taking action : against DragonSlayer, all they are likely to do is boot him off the : public machines. He can still post just as anonymously as he likes : using any number of methods, including easily available anonymous : posting services from any machine in the world. That is true. : I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to : actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate : people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to : a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion. : : : This newsgroup is not ‘designated’ for alternative opinion. This is : just more of your uneducated blather. Every newsgroup on usenet has : what’s known as a ‘charter’ that defines the purpose of the : newsgroup. Why don’t you do something positive for a change and : discover how to read this charter, so that you can inform yourself : about the true nature of this newsgroup? I’ve read the charter. It specifically suggests that these subjects be moved to this group to get them out of sci.med. One has to ask, then, what do we have to do to get the sci.med people to stop condemning everything they find here. Duh. : : I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for : libel. I doubt you would win. : : sdb The point is not winning. The point is nuisance suit. MIT is attempting to _identify_ DragonSlayer. Once he is identified, I can sue him in California, and he will have to defend himself in California, which will cost him a lot more than it will cost me, win or lose. Maybe that is an idiotic idea…maybe I can’t control the situation at all, and maybe I choose to do something else with my time. I just don’t feel like sitting back being maligned and do nothing. But at this point I feel rather like filtering all of the nuisance posters here, and go back to posting what I please about subjects that interest me. I’m on vacation–that’s all I care to say about this fracas at this point. – sent via an evaluation copy of BulkRate (unregistered).

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : In any case, dragonslayer is conforming to established usage in : calling you a quack. There are many different definitions of the word : `quack’ and not all of them involve fraud. It is possible to give : your services away, be well intentioned and sincere and still be : considered a quack. : : Personally, I don’t approve of the use of that word – I think it : generates heat without any light, but that doesn’t change the fact : the DragonSlayer is not necessarily misusing it. : : sdb If DS uses a commercial account to post such things, it will be easy to supoena his actual name and sue him. He knows this, and has cowardly decided to post anonymously from a non-commerical account. But large as MIT is, it is only a matter of time before they find out who he is and stop him.

Oh, nonsense. I would hope that good old MIT has not gone that far off track that they would let a little bully like you turn them into censors. You’re so totally clueless about the net that you don’t even realize that even *if* you manage to talk MIT into taking action against DragonSlayer, all they are likely to do is boot him off the public machines. He can still post just as anonymously as he likes using any number of methods, including easily available anonymous posting services from any machine in the world. I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion.

This newsgroup is not ‘designated’ for alternative opinion. This is just more of your uneducated blather. Every newsgroup on usenet has what’s known as a ‘charter’ that defines the purpose of the newsgroup. Why don’t you do something positive for a change and discover how to read this charter, so that you can inform yourself about the true nature of this newsgroup? I think it would be interesting to see you sue DragonSlayer for libel. I doubt you would win. sdb —

Response:

: In any case, dragonslayer is conforming to established usage in : calling you a quack. There are many different definitions of the word : `quack’ and not all of them involve fraud. It is possible to give : your services away, be well intentioned and sincere and still be : considered a quack. : : Personally, I don’t approve of the use of that word – I think it : generates heat without any light, but that doesn’t change the fact : the DragonSlayer is not necessarily misusing it. : : sdb If you would also like the number of the VP at MIT whose office is investigating this misuse of their system, just ask. I’ve spoken with them personally–they don’t seem to be so generous about what they consider acceptable behavior on their system. If DS were to PAY for service, that might be different, but his current access is a service offered to him based on a certain policy contract with that school. If DS uses a commercial account to post such things, it will be easy to supoena his actual name and sue him. He knows this, and has cowardly decided to post anonymously from a non-commerical account. But large as MIT is, it is only a matter of time before they find out who he is and stop him. I hope he simply decides to back off his insults and libels and learn to actually discuss  ideas, without having to character assassinate people who disagree with him, especially when they are posting to a newsgroup that is designated for alternative opinion.

Response:

Hello Paul, and everyone, I have been following you and DragonSalyer’s posts for some time now, perhaps not all of the year you have been "here", and can only make this observation.  You are guilty of what you accuse DS of.  I know for a fact that the first time DS used "quack" he was refering to any (conv. or alt.) practitioner who makes claims without substantiation.  What he asks of us (and conventional practitioners) is integrity.  I think both of you have gone overboard in the personal attack department, but you have been at it a long time, and there is a lot of animosity behind it. Personally, I have been called many names, quack amongst them, and am quite unperturbed by such things.  My service to those who seek my aid, and the results they have accomplished with it is good enough for them and me, and that is all that matters, not what other people think of me or my modality. Lighten up Paul, a witchhunt only shows that perhaps you do not have the faith and maturity in your modalities of practice.  Or as the Course in miracles says "The truth cannot be threatened.". My advice is to simply put your views forward, ignore the criticism that causes you heartache, and if you decide to respond to it, do so honestly and adress the criticisms directly.  But I guess this is poor advice comming from a quack such as myself ;-) . Love & Light John — |Barwon Water                        ||Australia, Ph +61 52 269215          |

Response:

: I have been following your and DragonSlayer’s posts for some time now, : perhaps not all of the year you have been "here", and can only make this : observation.  You are guilty of what you accuse DS of.  I know for a fact : that the first time DS used "quack" he was refering to any (conv. or alt.) : practitioner who makes claims without substantiation.  What he asks of us : (and conventional practitioners) is integrity.  I think both of you have : gone overboard in the personal attack department, but you have been at it : a long time, and there is a lot of animosity behind it.         Another Here! Here!  With the added comment that people who over-vigorously defend their position often do so because they have self-doubts about their position.

Response:

: : : I have been following your and DragonSlayer’s posts for some time now, : : perhaps not all of the year you have been "here", and can only make this : : observation.  You are guilty of what you accuse DS of.  I know for a fact : : that the first time DS used "quack" he was refering to any (conv. or alt.) : : practitioner who makes claims without substantiation.  What he asks of us : : (and conventional practitioners) is integrity.  I think both of you have : : gone overboard in the personal attack department, but you have been at it : : a long time, and there is a lot of animosity behind it. : :  Another Here! Here!  With the added comment that people who : over-vigorously defend their position often do so because they have : self-doubts about their position. Well, that is an interesting position. The rules of the UseNet directly forbid harassment of others, or direct attacks, libels, and derogatory language. The first time ANYONE used the word ‘quack’ applied to an individual was a violation of that policy. All the proof you would need of this is to contact MIT by phone, as I did last week, and ask them. They are very concerned about it. As for ’self-doubts,’ that is a particularly cute gotcha game you’re setting up. If someone protects their honor, they must have doubts about it? Join the real world, where people defend themselves from attacks. DS is anti-intellectual, but that is his business. His lack of couth, from an anonymous high castle of ethical superiority, is bothersome and unpleasant to have to read. But his violations of policy and Internet standards of behavior is actionable, and that is an objective standard. It has nothing whatsoever to do with doubt.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – : : : I have been following your and DragonSlayer’s posts for some time now, : : perhaps not all of the year you have been "here", and can only make this : : observation.  You are guilty of what you accuse DS of.  I know for a fact : : that the first time DS used "quack" he was refering to any (conv. or alt.) : : practitioner who makes claims without substantiation.  What he asks of us : : (and conventional practitioners) is integrity.  I think both of you have : : gone overboard in the personal attack department, but you have been at it : : a long time, and there is a lot of animosity behind it. : :  Another Here! Here!  With the added comment that people who : over-vigorously defend their position often do so because they have : self-doubts about their position. Well, that is an interesting position. The rules of the UseNet directly forbid harassment of others, or direct attacks, libels, and derogatory language. The first time ANYONE used the word ‘quack’ applied to an individual was a violation of that policy. All the proof you would need of this is to contact MIT by phone, as I did last week, and ask them. They are very concerned about it. As for ’self-doubts,’ that is a particularly cute gotcha game you’re setting up. If someone protects their honor, they must have doubts about it? Join the real world, where people defend themselves from attacks. DS is anti-intellectual, but that is his business. His lack of couth, from an anonymous high castle of ethical superiority, is bothersome and unpleasant to have to read. But his violations of policy and Internet standards of behavior is actionable, and that is an objective standard. It has nothing whatsoever to do with doubt.

The poster raises an interesting point, Paul. Just exactly why is it you become so outraged when DragonSlobber calls you a quack? Who really gives a shit what DragonSlobber says anyway? More to the point, what all is behind this need to ‘defend your honor’? Readers are going to make up their mind about you based on what YOU post, not what DragonSlobber or some other mental midget posts. — Robert Greenstein                 When you’re right 95% of the time,

Response:

Paul, To you, the word Quack is inflamatory. To me, the word Quack is perfectly descriptive of your behavior. Paul, you were caught with your pants down. You can’t stand being called for your own unethical behavior, so you start swinging madly. If it isn’t me, others will call you on your behavior. DragonSlayer

Response:

Well, that is an interesting position. The rules of the UseNet directly forbid harassment of others, or direct attacks, libels, and derogatory language. The first time ANYONE used the word ‘quack’ applied to an individual was a violation of that policy. All the proof you would need of this is to contact MIT by phone, as I did last week, and ask them. They are very concerned about it.

The content of this paragraph is sure to do well in the annual ‘words from the net clueless’ competition that’s always held in April. I’m going to submit it. Starting with ‘rules of the UseNet’ and ending with the concern of MIT about dragonslayers use of the public machines – this is sure to win me of the top three prizes. Paul, just some good advice: Please subscribe to news.announce.newusers and study away so you can stop embarrassing yourself like this. In any case, dragonslayer is conforming to established usage in calling you a quack. There are many different definitions of the word `quack’ and not all of them involve fraud. It is possible to give your services away, be well intentioned and sincere and still be considered a quack. Personally, I don’t approve of the use of that word – I think it generates heat without any light, but that doesn’t change the fact the DragonSlayer is not necessarily misusing it. sdb —

Response:

: If that means that you : must ignore an insult and return courtesy in response to abuse, this : evidence of your maturity will be appreciated by those who read : your postings. I’ve been ‘here’ for nearly a year. You’ve apparently missed all the turn the other cheek part. ‘Quack’ is exactly like ‘nigger’ in misc.health.alternative. Such language should offend anyone who reads this newsgroup. It violates Usenet policy, and Internet policy. It is harrassment, and it is most likely illegal as well. Plenty of newsgroups have been ‘bombed’ by jerks with no sense of propriety, couth, proper comportment, or sensitivity. A simple note to the postmaster, and that poster is _gone_. Here we deal with someone who is anonymous, posting obstensibly from a general access terminal. I am calling the President’s office at MIT tomorrow (this) morning to begin a formal complaint procedure. I am going to insist that they eliminate DS’s access or fundamentally change their general access procedures. If they refuse, they will receive legal papers from my lawyer forthwith. Since MIT is an honorable member of the Internet community, they will track DS down and deal with him, without any threat of a lawsuit. He has given plenty of biographical information, and is obviously a staff member. Someone will recognize who this is, trace his postings, see what an abuse of the standards of the Internet he has been involved in, and eliminate him (or threaten him with some direct sanction if another complaint is filed for any reason). In any case, he will be out in the open with the rest of us, where he belongs. It is very easy to libel someone who posts with their real name, while you cower behind a pseudonym. If I was posting as ‘Zorro’ I would hardly care that he called me the Boston Strangler. But those who will not defend their honor have none. It is my name, it is my family’s name, and I will not ignore this obscene abuse any longer. It will CEASE. Sorry to everyone that this process has become necessary, but please point your finger at the rogue who made it necessary, not at me. May justice be swift, so we can get back to the intricacies of health exploration. Thank you.

Response:

: If the postings to this newsgroup were consistently thoughtful, : we could reasonably expect large numbers of prominient researchers : to post here regularly.  Let’s clean up the discourse so that we : can all benefit from such opportunities.         Here! Here! (That’s Brit. for I 2nd the motion)

Response:

A message to those who question the need for civility: Let’s imagine that you really have got the keys to the gates of enlightenment in your hands and it is your divine mission to spread this great gift to the readers of misc.health.alternative. Don’t you think that your message will be better received if you’re polite about how you deliver it?  Let’s also imagine that some poor deluded fool questions your patent on divinity and doesn’t have an immediate experience of revelation when exposed to your noble words.  Do you think that he is going to be easier to convince because you insult him?   In the non-internet world, people simply avoid those who are consistently rude.  When the pattern of discourse in a newsgroup is consistently discourteous, most people just stop tuning in.  I would like to suggest that those who are not interested in sabotaging the discourse simply be a little more polite.  If that means that you must ignore an insult and return courtesy in response to abuse, this evidence of your maturity will be appreciated by those who read your postings.  If you have a personal problem, that prevents you from being civil, this is not the place to work it out.   Please come back after you’ve solved your problem. Consider that one of the great opportunities of a forum such as this one is that it can attract people of diverse backgrounds with novel insights into an issue.  Someone from another background is going to have a whole different way of looking at the world. He or she will use different words.  Sometimes, when they use the same words that you do, they will intend different meanings and connotations.  Their experiences will be different, sometimes so different that it will be difficult to express them clearly in words you understand.  Being nasty to people with a different world view is no better than racism or other forms of prejudice.  Petty arrogance is evidence of a small mind.  An insult usually reveals more about the purveyor than about the target. If the postings to this newsgroup were consistently thoughtful, we could reasonably expect large numbers of prominient researchers to post here regularly.  Let’s clean up the discourse so that we can all benefit from such opportunities. e. evert

Response: