Question:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I must be one of those who doesn’t notice the effect of caffeine. As far as I can tell, it has NO effect, and it sorta bugs me. I can’t drink a coke to wake up in the morning, or to stay up at night. Jolt cola doesn’t affect me, either. As a matter of fact, the last time I tried No-Doz to stay up for a study session, it didn’t even WORK. At one time I thought that since I drank so much pop I was simply immune to caffeine. But, I really don’t think I have an addiction to it. If I go without it for any period of time, I don’t get headaches, get jittery, or have any other symptoms of withdrawal. Who knows? Maybe caffeine really DOESN’T affect everybody… Eldred My father drinks full octane java at ANY time, day or night, & never has a problem falling asleep, doesn’t get jittery, etc. The times when he’s stopped drinking coffee, he claims not to feel the least bit different & we’ve never seen any s/s of any caffeine withdrawl. I noticed I sleep better (more deeply, less waking in the middle of the night) when I cut back the caffeine. It doesn’t make me jittery or keep me awake, but I suppose its diuretic effect is what interrupted my getting a full night’s rest. I never liked coffee (except its wonderful aroma), so Coke used to be my caffeinated beverage of choice. Michele
About three years ago when I used to drink a can of Coke with meals and bottled Pepsi between meals I hardly slept at all. There was no point in laying down and trying to sleep because it just didn’t happen. Seemed like I could only take unexpected naps (usually while watching tv). I had no withdrawl problems when I switched to Caffeine-Free except I sure do sleep a LOT now.
Response:
I never mentioned duplicates. Please reread the sarcasm….LOL
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I haven’t been getting duplicates from wuzzy. It may be your server hiccuping. Tracy Get rid of your computer virus! You post three times every post. almost forgot this month’s 1: J Appl Physiol 2002 Jun;92(6):2347-52 Caffeine-induced impairment of glucose tolerance is abolished by beta-adrenergic receptor blockade in humans. There was a discussion on that June article a couple of weeks ago.. It shows adenosine receptor has nothing to do with it..
Response:
I’ve been getting three posts for each one, also. Smiles, cosette – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I haven’t been getting duplicates from wuzzy. It may be your server hiccuping. Tracy Get rid of your computer virus! You post three times every post. almost forgot this month’s 1: J Appl Physiol 2002 Jun;92(6):2347-52 Caffeine-induced impairment of glucose tolerance is abolished by beta-adrenergic receptor blockade in humans. There was a discussion on that June article a couple of weeks ago.. It shows adenosine receptor has nothing to do with it..
Response:
I haven’t been getting duplicates from wuzzy. It may be your server hiccuping. Tracy
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Get rid of your computer virus! You post three times every post. almost forgot this month’s 1: J Appl Physiol 2002 Jun;92(6):2347-52 Caffeine-induced impairment of glucose tolerance is abolished by beta-adrenergic receptor blockade in humans. There was a discussion on that June article a couple of weeks ago.. It shows adenosine receptor has nothing to do with it..
Response:
Get rid of your computer virus! You post three times every post.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – almost forgot this month’s 1: J Appl Physiol 2002 Jun;92(6):2347-52 Caffeine-induced impairment of glucose tolerance is abolished by beta-adrenergic receptor blockade in humans. There was a discussion on that June article a couple of weeks ago.. It shows adenosine receptor has nothing to do with it..
Response:
| Michael Roose has finally admitted that he is Dr. Chung. He and Dr. | Chung I am not Chung. I was never Chung. I will never be Chung.
ah, dr. chung! you fool no one! your kung fu is weak! now, prepare to meet your destiny! general ‘funky chicken’ gau begun, the clone war has – yoda marriage is a great institution, some of us just haven’t gotten it right. the guilt lasts for about four or five minutes, and then you get over it. – donald trump it’s just like the story of the grasshopper and the octopus. all year long, the grasshopper kept burying acorns for the winter, while the octopus mooched off his girlfriend and watched tv. but then the winter came, and the grasshopper died, and the octopus ate all his acorns. and also he got a racecar. is any of this getting through to you? – fry you can’t be that short and not be mad about it all the time. – julia phillips i have always thought the actions of men the best interpreters of thier thoughts. – john locke
Response:
almost forgot this month’s 1: J Appl Physiol 2002 Jun;92(6):2347-52 Caffeine-induced impairment of glucose tolerance is abolished by beta-adrenergic receptor blockade in humans. There was a discussion on that June article a couple of weeks ago.. It shows adenosine receptor has nothing to do with it..
Response:
As for the carb/insulin relationship, Atkins says: "Cafffeine mimics the effect of sugar on blood glucose levels by stimulating insulin release. It should be avoided by those who suspect they are caffeine dependent and taken in limited quanities by others." This in relation to low carb diet, of course.
Atkins is misleading, caffeine mimics *nothing* like sugar. Nonetheless he is correct in advising against caffeine as it *causes* insulin resistance (without a doubt see below). It used to be thought that it was adenosine mediated but currently believed to be catecholamine-mediated. REFERENCES: 1)Caffeine-induced impairment of insulin action but not insulin signaling in human skeletal muscle is reduced by exercise DIABETES 51 (3): 583-590 MAR 2002 2)Caffeine can decrease insulin sensitivity in humans. Diabetes Care. 2002 Feb;25(2):364-9. PMID: 11815511 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE] 3)Caffeine: a cause of insulin resistance? Diabetes Care. 2002 Feb;25(2):399-400. Review. No abstract available. PMID: 11815519 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE] 4)Caffeine ingestion elevates plasma insulin response in humans during an oral glucose tolerance test. Can J Physiol Pharmacol. 2001 Jul;79(7):559-65. PMID: 11478588 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE] 5)Caffeine ingestion decreases glucose disposal during a hyperinsulinemic-euglycemic clamp in sedentary humans DIABETES 50 (10): 2349-2354 OCT 2001 6)Effect of caffeine on metabolism, exercise endurance, and catecholamine responses after withdrawal J APPL PHYSIOL 85 (4): 1493-1501 OCT 1998 7)Effects of caffeine on glucose tolerance: A placebo-controlled study EUR J CLIN NUTR 52 (11): 846-849 NOV 1998 8)Metabolic and ergogenic effects of carbohydrate and caffeine beverages in tennis J SPORT MED PHYS FIT 37 (4): 258-266 DEC 1997 9))ADENOSINE RECEPTORS MEDIATE SYNERGISTIC STIMULATION OF GLUCOSE-UPTAKE AND TRANSPORT BY INSULIN AND BY CONTRACTIONS IN RAT SKELETAL-MUSCLE J CLIN INVEST 93 (3): 974-981 MAR 1994 10)Metabolic and hormone-related responses to caffeine in rats PHARMACOL RES 32 (3): 129-133 SEP 1995 EFFECT OF CAFFEINE AND SACCHARIN ON GLUCOSE-UPTAKE AND INSULIN RELEASE IN ISOLATED RAT-TISSUE S AFR J SCI 84 (2): 136-137 FEB 1988 11)DIETARY CAFFEINE, GLUCOSE-TOLERANCE AND INSULIN SENSITIVITY IN MICE J FOOD SCI 44 (6): 1761-1764 1979 12)RESTORING EFFECT OF CAFFEINE ON DECREASED SENSITIVITY OF INSULIN SECRETORY MECHANISM IN MOUSE PANCREATIC-ISLETS DURING STARVATION ACTA ENDOCRINOL-COP 82: 24-25 Suppl. 203 1976 13)EFFECT OF CAFFEINE ON SERUM-INSULIN DURING ACUTE IV GLUCOSE LOADING IN SOME PATIENTS WITH CHEMICAL DIABETES-MELLITUS Z ERNAHRUNGSWISS 15 (2): 151-155 1976 14)INFLUENCE OF ETHANOL, CAFFEINE AND INTRAGASTRIC COOLING ON GASTRIN AND INSULIN-SECRETION IN MAN NUTR METAB 17 (6): 352-359 1974 15)EFFECTS OF COFFEE AND CAFFEINE ON CARBOHYDRATE-METABOLISM, FREE FATTY-ACID, INSULIN, GROWTH-HORMONE AND CORTISOL PLASMA-LEVELS IN MAN ACTA DIABETOL LAT 10 (5): 1069-1084 1973
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I must be one of those who doesn’t notice the effect of caffeine. As far as I can tell, it has NO effect, and it sorta bugs me. I can’t drink a coke to wake up in the morning, or to stay up at night. Jolt cola doesn’t affect me, either. As a matter of fact, the last time I tried No-Doz to stay up for a study session, it didn’t even WORK. At one time I thought that since I drank so much pop I was simply immune to caffeine. But, I really don’t think I have an addiction to it. If I go without it for any period of time, I don’t get headaches, get jittery, or have any other symptoms of withdrawal. Who knows? Maybe caffeine really DOESN’T affect everybody… Eldred
My father drinks full octane java at ANY time, day or night, & never has a problem falling asleep, doesn’t get jittery, etc. The times when he’s stopped drinking coffee, he claims not to feel the least bit different & we’ve never seen any s/s of any caffeine withdrawl. I noticed I sleep better (more deeply, less waking in the middle of the night) when I cut back the caffeine. It doesn’t make me jittery or keep me awake, but I suppose its diuretic effect is what interrupted my getting a full night’s rest. I never liked coffee (except its wonderful aroma), so Coke used to be my caffeinated beverage of choice. Michele
Response:
Some people use caffeine, sometimes with ephedrine, specifically for its fat mobilizing and appetite suppressing properties. As for the carb/insulin relationship, Atkins says: "Cafffeine mimics the effect of sugar on blood glucose levels by stimulating insulin release. It should be avoided by those who suspect they are caffeine dependent and taken in limited quanities by others." This in relation to low carb diet, of course.
When the caffeine issue was discussed in asd-lc before, it was bought up that the "stalls" blamed on caffeine might have been caused by the citric acid in caffeine containing sodas as caffeine itself doesn’t stimulate insulin release. If anybody wants to experiment with this, try drinking Diet Coke one day and taking No Doze on another and see what effect both have on the ketostick. Of course this doesn’t mean that there are other reasons that some might consider cutting it out. — Ron Ritzman |[losing fat] is like running a government |You have to take out more then you put in |– Smokey
Response:
Also passing it on to a number of other groups. Please trim headers when posting to ASD. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Passing this along from the MFW newsgroup. I thought people would be interested in this: Passing this along from the MFW newsgroup. I thought people would be interested in this: Sorry folks, but these are some of the things that Michael Roose and Dr. Chung have posted on our newsgroups. We are as upset as you are and unfortunately some of our members have also been very upset and have posted somethings that they maybe should not have. —– Original Message —– Newsgroups: alt.support.diabetes Sent: Monday, June 03, 2002 7:38 AM : : |Sorry, I’ve been gone for a while, but I’ve seen a lot of talk about Dr. : |Chung….who is that, and what’s his relation to diabetes? : : I am Chung. Especially in newsgroups. My hypotheses is that this is directly linked with sexual dysfunctions and, shall we say, less than appealing, rampant obesity. Dull clitoral responses and limp penis syndrome aren’t exactly wonderful bedmates either. :))))))) What these problems cause is irrational Usenet behaviors and, with that as an explanation, I pour out my heart to you who are so afflicted. Try a popsickle stick and adhesive tape and apply L-Arginine vigorously and directly. "Viagra. The quicker dicker upper" Picture your smoldering carcass catapulted back to the ASD mudpile. — Dr. Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD Atlanta Cardiologist http://www.heartmdphd.com : LOL. Good point!
Ted Rodrick Yep, I keep my spear sharp. Back for more abuse, I see. When did your fetish for S&M start? Don’t you just hate it when you find yourself on the wrong side of a flame war? Your smoldering carcass has just been catapulted back to the ASD mud pile again. Be sure to come back if you want more. — Dr. Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD Atlanta Cardiologist http://www.heartmdphd.com These are things that Dr. Chung has posted on our newsgroups. Michael Roose has finally admitted that he is Dr. Chung. He and Dr. Chung have disrupted alt.support.diabetes and misc.health. diabetes and posted profanities there as well as medical information which could be very harmful to diabetics. Both of them (as one person) have been reported to the ADA, AMA, Georgia Board of Cardiologists, Emory University, etc. : |[ cross-posting removed.] why?
– Diva The Best Man for the Job is a Woman
Response:
With the preponderance of soda, tea and coffees as socially approved and acceptable substitutes for water, or as stimulants, I am inquiring if there are others out there In UsenetLand that have found caffeine to either be a major stumbling block to weight loss and weight control and/or as an addictive a substance as this gentleman has described. Addictive substance yes (more or less for some) but I don’t see how it can hamper weight loss or appetite control. If anything, being a stimulant, it should have the opposite effect. Some people use caffeine, sometimes with ephedrine, specifically for its fat mobilizing and appetite suppressing properties.
As for the carb/insulin relationship, Atkins says: "Cafffeine mimics the effect of sugar on blood glucose levels by stimulating insulin release. It should be avoided by those who suspect they are caffeine dependent and taken in limited quanities by others." This in relation to low carb diet, of course. — Mac
Response:
With the preponderance of soda, tea and coffees as socially approved and acceptable substitutes for water, or as stimulants, I am inquiring if there are others out there In UsenetLand that have found caffeine to either be a major stumbling block to weight loss and weight control and/or as an addictive a substance as this gentleman has described.
Addictive substance yes (more or less for some) but I don’t see how it can hamper weight loss or appetite control. If anything, being a stimulant, it should have the opposite effect. Some people use caffeine, sometimes with ephedrine, specifically for its fat mobilizing and appetite suppressing properties. — Ron Ritzman |[losing fat] is like running a government |You have to take out more then you put in |– Smokey
Response:
(James Teo) writes: I never advocated banning caffeine. I don’t think it is dangerous to the average person, I just think the public should be made aware that caffeine is also a drug like alcohol or nicotine and all drugs have side-efects. This doesn’t mean "don’t take it", it just means "be aware of it". Be aware that the weekly headache may be due to caffeine, be aware that you get dehydrated with caffeine, be aware that if you are hyperthyroid you are more prone to palpitations with caffeine. Also, people need to be aware that caffeine of various doses is in all sorts of things we may not realise It’s just a lesson that caffeine does affect people and people should be made aware of it. Not because it should banned or regulated but simply so that the layperson can make better decisions about their lifestyle.
I must be one of those who doesn’t notice the effect of caffeine. As far as I can tell, it has NO effect, and it sorta bugs me. I can’t drink a coke to wake up in the morning, or to stay up at night. Jolt cola doesn’t affect me, either. As a matter of fact, the last time I tried No-Doz to stay up for a study session, it didn’t even WORK. At one time I thought that since I drank so much pop I was simply immune to caffeine. But, I really don’t think I have an addiction to it. If I go without it for any period of time, I don’t get headaches, get jittery, or have any other symptoms of withdrawal. Who knows? Maybe caffeine really DOESN’T affect everybody… Eldred — Homepage – http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Thanks to those of you who made a donation for breast cancer research. The walkathon is over, but donations are still being accepted. Details on my webpage.
Response:
| | || ||I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is ||on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of ||itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some ||pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. | |Interesting. I wonder if there are diseases that are directly caused |by caffeine? | |Well, caffeine is very similar to the compound used to treat asthma |called theophylline (both are methylxanthines), and acts on the same |target enzyme (phosphodiesterase). Theophylline is a potentially |dangerous compound in high doses and in overdose can cause ionic |imbalances in the body as well as heart rhythm disorders, seizures, |agitation, vomitting and death. Now caffeine is much much safer than |theophylline but as far as I can tell it produces some of the same |qualitative effects in most people: |- GI disturbances (diarrhoea or nausea) |- agitation |- palpitations |- sympathetic stimulation | ||Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy ||drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often ||experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need ||to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). | |What would be the criteria and if there are not any known pathologies |to caffeine, what would be the precedence? | |Well dehydration can be compounded by caffeine. All those kids taking |ecstasy, downing shots of vodka and redbull while dancing the night |away can proceed to severe dehydration and in one case in UK, death |has occured. Now, I don’t think one should ban vodka, redbull or |dancing so the public should be educated instead. | |I once met an Italian guy who drank 10 espressos a day, and he had |atrial fibrillation (a heart rhythm disorder). While I don’t know if |it was the cause, that much caffeine can’t have helped. | ||<Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to | |Why? And why did you keep the ones you left? | |Well, my ISP news server told me I can’t send to so many newsgroups at |once. I just removed the ones which were on the left. |Nothing more than that. Thanks James.
Response:
Caffeine has been a part of my diet for as long as I can remember. I was brought up on tea and after marriage I graduated to Coca Cola. After beginning WW however, I did switch to Caffeine Free Diet Coke! It took very little time. I do drink French Vanilla Coffee every single day, am doing it now as a matter of fact. But mostly I drink the soda. Whether I drink an item that has caffeine in it or is caffeine free doesn’t bother me at all. Caffeine does not help me stay awake nor does it make me jittery. I’ve seen shows on tv where they explained how a product was made caffeine free and that worried me more than having the caffeine. But it is true that many women cannot drink caffeine as it causes lumps in their breast tissue.
Caffeine doesn’t keep me awake, it makes me tolerable. Interestingly enough, if anybody reads the Foxtrot comic, Roger is being made to quit caffeine by his wife, Andy. It is funny… and I can totally relate. ~M’isa
Response:
Maybe when you are over 30 you may discover you have big problems with coffee or maybe you may not even know it. Put it on your tombstone maybe?
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – James, for every single thing that is edible or drinkable, you can find someone somewhere who is convinced that item is bad for you! Everything causes cancer, even water has been reported to cause it. With all of this against us, how can we win? Stop eating? Naw….. Caffeine has been a part of my diet for as long as I can remember. I was brought up on tea and after marriage I graduated to Coca Cola. After beginning WW however, I did switch to Caffeine Free Diet Coke! It took very little time. I do drink French Vanilla Coffee every single day, am doing it now as a matter of fact. But mostly I drink the soda. Whether I drink an item that has caffeine in it or is caffeine free doesn’t bother me at all. Caffeine does not help me stay awake nor does it make me jittery. I’ve seen shows on tv where they explained how a product was made caffeine free and that worried me more than having the caffeine. But it is true that many women cannot drink caffeine as it causes lumps in their breast tissue. Knowing all of this, I eat what I like and drink what I like, within the boundaries of this program, naturally. But I do not pay attention to anybody’s bad comments on a particular food product, except when someone here has tried something and says it’s good. I’ll try it then. Doesn’t mean I’ll like it as we all have different tastes, but I’m willing to try. Today I’m trying two new recipes! One is for apple pie and the other is for my favorite all time veggie, squash casserole! I had no idea I could have these as the casserole has cheese in it, but hey, I’ve got the fat free kind so I’m trying it today
I recently engaged in a very compelling conversation with someone who had quit smoking and caffeine at the same time. He claimed that caffeine was much more difficult to curb his appetite for. He also indicated his diet was never under his control until he removed the excessive caffeine intake. With the preponderance of soda, tea and coffees as socially approved and acceptable substitutes for water, or as stimulants, I am inquiring if there are others out there In UsenetLand that have found caffeine to either be a major stumbling block to weight loss and weight control and/or as an addictive a substance as this gentleman has described. Is caffeine a missed frontier in our efforts to inform the public of the dangers in the typical American and international diet? Is Starbucks nothing more than a present day Moloko bar? I find that based on my personal experience caffeine does fulfil most of the criteria for physical dependence: – need for increasing doses of caffeine to achieve the same result – withdrawal periods when without caffeine. However, I don’t have a psychological addiction, as I have little problems taking holidays from caffeine regularly (I do it so that I keep myself sensitised when I do need caffeine on late nights). I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). <Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to
Response:
Today I’m trying two new recipes! One is for apple pie and the other is for my favorite all time veggie, squash casserole! I had no idea I could have these as the casserole has cheese in it, but hey, I’ve got the fat free kind so I’m trying it today
Now all we need is a way to dispose of all of the extra zucchini that end up in backyard gardens. I think that if we gave just 6 seeds to every starving person in the world it would only take harvesting the first crop to solve the problem. So print the darn casserole recipe, would ya? Sorry, got off on a tangent. But I will not, repeat not, be the recipient of any more zucchini from a poorly planned and executed back yard garden/gardner this year. How does any seed company expect a single family to consume the contents of that seed package, anyway. *hint, don’t heat up the fat free cheeses — they end up in puddles*
Response:
| |I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is |on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of |itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some |pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. Interesting. I wonder if there are diseases that are directly caused by caffeine?
Well, caffeine is very similar to the compound used to treat asthma called theophylline (both are methylxanthines), and acts on the same target enzyme (phosphodiesterase). Theophylline is a potentially dangerous compound in high doses and in overdose can cause ionic imbalances in the body as well as heart rhythm disorders, seizures, agitation, vomitting and death. Now caffeine is much much safer than theophylline but as far as I can tell it produces some of the same qualitative effects in most people: – GI disturbances (diarrhoea or nausea) – agitation – palpitations – sympathetic stimulation |Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy |drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often |experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need |to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). What would be the criteria and if there are not any known pathologies to caffeine, what would be the precedence?
Well dehydration can be compounded by caffeine. All those kids taking ecstasy, downing shots of vodka and redbull while dancing the night away can proceed to severe dehydration and in one case in UK, death has occured. Now, I don’t think one should ban vodka, redbull or dancing so the public should be educated instead. I once met an Italian guy who drank 10 espressos a day, and he had atrial fibrillation (a heart rhythm disorder). While I don’t know if it was the cause, that much caffeine can’t have helped. |<Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to Why? And why did you keep the ones you left?
Well, my ISP news server told me I can’t send to so many newsgroups at once. I just removed the ones which were on the left. Nothing more than that.
Response:
Ouch! Your poor sister! Too true that they put this in a lot of products without mentioning it, people need to learn to read the ingredients on their items. I know that I was surprised to find out what goes into making pearl fingernail polish, it grossed me out! I never worried about it before (food) because I figured the government wouldn’t let it be sold if it wasn’t safe, but then you see all these fast weight loss products that say ‘not approved’ and you just have to wonder. I know that sometimes if I hadn’t had caffeine for a day or two that I would get a headache and it took me a while to figure out how come! You are absolutely right that we all need to be aware, especially those with medical conditions that might need to avoid it! Hey, this is a silly other question
but do you suppose that when we lose fat, and while on this program, that we could be losing brain cells too? I just can’t help but wonder how a program such as WW could affect our brains. I mean, if we are losing everywhere else, are we losing there too? The way my memory has gone kookoo since being on this program makes me wonder, lmao
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – James, for every single thing that is edible or drinkable, you can find someone somewhere who is convinced that item is bad for you! Everything causes cancer, even water has been reported to cause it. With all of this against us, how can we win? Stop eating? Naw….. Caffeine has been a part of my diet for as long as I can remember. I was brought up on tea and after marriage I graduated to Coca Cola. After beginning WW however, I did switch to Caffeine Free Diet Coke! It took very little time. I do drink French Vanilla Coffee every single day, am doing it now as a matter of fact. But mostly I drink the soda. Whether I drink an item that has caffeine in it or is caffeine free doesn’t bother me at all. Caffeine does not help me stay awake nor does it make me jittery. I’ve seen shows on tv where they explained how a product was made caffeine free and that worried me more than having the caffeine. But it is true that many women cannot drink caffeine as it causes lumps in their breast tissue. Knowing all of this, I eat what I like and drink what I like, within the boundaries of this program, naturally. But I do not pay attention to anybody’s bad comments on a particular food product, except when someone here has tried something and says it’s good. I’ll try it then. Doesn’t mean I’ll like it as we all have different tastes, but I’m willing to try. I never advocated banning caffeine. I don’t think it is dangerous to the average person, I just think the public should be made aware that caffeine is also a drug like alcohol or nicotine and all drugs have side-efects. This doesn’t mean "don’t take it", it just means "be aware of it". Be aware that the weekly headache may be due to caffeine, be aware that you get dehydrated with caffeine, be aware that if you are hyperthyroid you are more prone to palpitations with caffeine. Also, people need to be aware that caffeine of various doses is in all sorts of things we may not realise One example: my sister had a bad flu & headache, so she went out and bought "Panadol Extra" (paracetemol also known as acetaminophen in USA, plus caffeine) to reduce her headache. However, she did not realise that the word "EXTRA" in it meant they added caffeine, and the formulation was targetted at people with flu & headaches who need to continue working. As a result, she couldn’t sleep all night and had a worse headache in the morning. Took more of the tablets, and this just worsened it with each day. She thought she had some serious illness and so asked me for advice. One quick glance at the box and I saw how much caffeine was in it and told her that was the problem not her flu. It’s just a lesson that caffeine does affect people and people should be made aware of it. Not because it should banned or regulated but simply so that the layperson can make better decisions about their lifestyle. – James Competing interests: I have drunk coffee since I was 6 years old and continue to do so when I need to stay up on-call. I use caffeine tablets and other energy drinks as well.
Response:
| |I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is |on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of |itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some |pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. Interesting. I wonder if there are diseases that are directly caused by caffeine? |Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy |drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often |experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need |to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). What would be the criteria and if there are not any known pathologies to caffeine, what would be the precedence? |<Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to Why? And why did you keep the ones you left?
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – James, for every single thing that is edible or drinkable, you can find someone somewhere who is convinced that item is bad for you! Everything causes cancer, even water has been reported to cause it. With all of this against us, how can we win? Stop eating? Naw….. Caffeine has been a part of my diet for as long as I can remember. I was brought up on tea and after marriage I graduated to Coca Cola. After beginning WW however, I did switch to Caffeine Free Diet Coke! It took very little time. I do drink French Vanilla Coffee every single day, am doing it now as a matter of fact. But mostly I drink the soda. Whether I drink an item that has caffeine in it or is caffeine free doesn’t bother me at all. Caffeine does not help me stay awake nor does it make me jittery. I’ve seen shows on tv where they explained how a product was made caffeine free and that worried me more than having the caffeine. But it is true that many women cannot drink caffeine as it causes lumps in their breast tissue. Knowing all of this, I eat what I like and drink what I like, within the boundaries of this program, naturally. But I do not pay attention to anybody’s bad comments on a particular food product, except when someone here has tried something and says it’s good. I’ll try it then. Doesn’t mean I’ll like it as we all have different tastes, but I’m willing to try.
I never advocated banning caffeine. I don’t think it is dangerous to the average person, I just think the public should be made aware that caffeine is also a drug like alcohol or nicotine and all drugs have side-efects. This doesn’t mean "don’t take it", it just means "be aware of it". Be aware that the weekly headache may be due to caffeine, be aware that you get dehydrated with caffeine, be aware that if you are hyperthyroid you are more prone to palpitations with caffeine. Also, people need to be aware that caffeine of various doses is in all sorts of things we may not realise One example: my sister had a bad flu & headache, so she went out and bought "Panadol Extra" (paracetemol also known as acetaminophen in USA, plus caffeine) to reduce her headache. However, she did not realise that the word "EXTRA" in it meant they added caffeine, and the formulation was targetted at people with flu & headaches who need to continue working. As a result, she couldn’t sleep all night and had a worse headache in the morning. Took more of the tablets, and this just worsened it with each day. She thought she had some serious illness and so asked me for advice. One quick glance at the box and I saw how much caffeine was in it and told her that was the problem not her flu. It’s just a lesson that caffeine does affect people and people should be made aware of it. Not because it should banned or regulated but simply so that the layperson can make better decisions about their lifestyle. – James Competing interests: I have drunk coffee since I was 6 years old and continue to do so when I need to stay up on-call. I use caffeine tablets and other energy drinks as well.
Response:
James, for every single thing that is edible or drinkable, you can find someone somewhere who is convinced that item is bad for you! Everything causes cancer, even water has been reported to cause it. With all of this against us, how can we win? Stop eating? Naw….. Caffeine has been a part of my diet for as long as I can remember. I was brought up on tea and after marriage I graduated to Coca Cola. After beginning WW however, I did switch to Caffeine Free Diet Coke! It took very little time. I do drink French Vanilla Coffee every single day, am doing it now as a matter of fact. But mostly I drink the soda. Whether I drink an item that has caffeine in it or is caffeine free doesn’t bother me at all. Caffeine does not help me stay awake nor does it make me jittery. I’ve seen shows on tv where they explained how a product was made caffeine free and that worried me more than having the caffeine. But it is true that many women cannot drink caffeine as it causes lumps in their breast tissue. Knowing all of this, I eat what I like and drink what I like, within the boundaries of this program, naturally. But I do not pay attention to anybody’s bad comments on a particular food product, except when someone here has tried something and says it’s good. I’ll try it then. Doesn’t mean I’ll like it as we all have different tastes, but I’m willing to try. Today I’m trying two new recipes! One is for apple pie and the other is for my favorite all time veggie, squash casserole! I had no idea I could have these as the casserole has cheese in it, but hey, I’ve got the fat free kind so I’m trying it today
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I recently engaged in a very compelling conversation with someone who had quit smoking and caffeine at the same time. He claimed that caffeine was much more difficult to curb his appetite for. He also indicated his diet was never under his control until he removed the excessive caffeine intake. With the preponderance of soda, tea and coffees as socially approved and acceptable substitutes for water, or as stimulants, I am inquiring if there are others out there In UsenetLand that have found caffeine to either be a major stumbling block to weight loss and weight control and/or as an addictive a substance as this gentleman has described. Is caffeine a missed frontier in our efforts to inform the public of the dangers in the typical American and international diet? Is Starbucks nothing more than a present day Moloko bar? I find that based on my personal experience caffeine does fulfil most of the criteria for physical dependence: – need for increasing doses of caffeine to achieve the same result – withdrawal periods when without caffeine. However, I don’t have a psychological addiction, as I have little problems taking holidays from caffeine regularly (I do it so that I keep myself sensitised when I do need caffeine on late nights). I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). <Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I recently engaged in a very compelling conversation with someone who had quit smoking and caffeine at the same time. He claimed that caffeine was much more difficult to curb his appetite for. He also indicated his diet was never under his control until he removed the excessive caffeine intake. With the preponderance of soda, tea and coffees as socially approved and acceptable substitutes for water, or as stimulants, I am inquiring if there are others out there In UsenetLand that have found caffeine to either be a major stumbling block to weight loss and weight control and/or as an addictive a substance as this gentleman has described. Is caffeine a missed frontier in our efforts to inform the public of the dangers in the typical American and international diet? Is Starbucks nothing more than a present day Moloko bar?
I find that based on my personal experience caffeine does fulfil most of the criteria for physical dependence: – need for increasing doses of caffeine to achieve the same result – withdrawal periods when without caffeine. However, I don’t have a psychological addiction, as I have little problems taking holidays from caffeine regularly (I do it so that I keep myself sensitised when I do need caffeine on late nights). I don’t think anyone thinks caffeine is "like water" but I doubt it is on the level of a "dangerous substance". Physical addiction in of itself I don’t think means it is dangerous. It may worsen some pre-existing disease though, and people should be made aware of it. Also, I think there should be some regulation on all those "energy drinks" like Red Bull. I sometimes take Red Bull myself and I often experience palpitations, but that’s something I tolerate when I need to be stimulated (late night on the wards, etc). <Snipped the huge number of groups this was crossposted to
Response: